Equality and justice are so closely joined in political thought that it is often difficult to speak of one without the other. When people say that a society is unjust, they very often mean that some of its members are treated as lesser persons, denied the rights, chances or respect which others enjoy. When they ask for equality, they usually believe that they are asking for what is fair. Yet the two ideas are not the same. Justice is the wider idea of what is due to each person and how the institutions of society should be arranged, while equality is one of the principles, perhaps the most important, by which that due is decided.
The relationship has been discussed since Aristotle, who held that justice is a kind of equality, but a proportionate one, which treats equals equally and unequals unequally. In modern times, the question has taken new forms. Does justice require that all have equal shares, or that all have enough, or that all receive according to merit? Is every inequality unjust, or only those that arise from luck, birth and privilege? Can the demand for equality ever be unjust, as when it overrides rights or rewards? An understanding of these questions is necessary for the study of political theory and for understanding the Indian Constitution, which places justice, liberty, equality and fraternity together in its Preamble.
1. The two concepts in brief
Equality. Equality means that all human beings are of equal moral worth and are entitled to equal respect and to a fair share of rights and opportunities. It does not mean sameness, since persons differ in talents and needs. It asks that differences of birth, sex, caste, race or religion should not be the ground for denying persons the basic goods of life. Its main forms are legal, political, social, economic and gender equality, and equality of opportunity, of outcome and of capabilities.
Justice. Justice means fairness in the ordering of social relations, so that each person receives what is due to him and wrongs are set right. It includes fairness of distribution, which is distributive justice, fairness in the correction of wrongs, which is corrective justice, and fairness of procedure, which is procedural justice. Its main theories rest on merit, need, rights, utility, entitlement or fair agreement.
The link in one line. Equality supplies a main content of justice, by saying that persons are to be treated as equals unless there is a good reason for treating them differently, and justice supplies the test of the reasons, by asking which differences are relevant and which are arbitrary.
| Point | Equality | Justice |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | A principle about the equal standing and treatment of persons | A wider principle of fairness and due in all social arrangements |
| Scope | Mainly concerned with sameness and difference of treatment and share | Concerned with distribution, correction of wrongs, procedure and desert |
| Standard | Equal worth, equal rights, equal opportunity | Merit, need, rights, utility, entitlement or fairness, according to theory |
| Relation to difference | Allows difference only for good reason | Decides which differences are good reasons |
| Main forms | Legal, political, social, economic, gender, opportunity, outcome | Legal, political, social, economic, distributive, corrective, procedural |
| Possible fault | May become levelling, or ignore merit and choice | May become rigid, or serve the interest of a dominant group |
| Chief thinkers | Rousseau, Tocqueville, Tawney, Dworkin | Plato, Aristotle, Kant, Rawls, Nozick, Sen |
| Indian expression | Articles 14 to 18, Article 38, Article 39 | Preamble, Articles 21, 39A, 32 and Part IV as a whole |
2. How equality and justice are linked
Justice contains the idea of equal treatment. The oldest rule of justice is that like cases should be treated alike. A judge who punishes one thief and spares another in the same circumstances, only because one is rich, is unjust. Thus, the formal part of equality, that the same rule applies to all in the same position, is a basic condition for any system of justice.
Equality of moral worth is the base of justice. Most modern theories of justice begin from the view that each person counts and that no one is a mere instrument for the benefit of others. Kant spoke of persons as ends in themselves, Mill of the equal claim of each to happiness, and Rawls of persons as free and equal. If this equal worth were not accepted, the idea of fair treatment would have no starting point.
Justice decides which inequalities are acceptable. Equality does not mean that every difference of treatment is wrong. Pay may differ with work, and penalties with the gravity of an offence. Justice gives the reasons which make a difference fair, such as merit, effort, need or benefit to the worse off, and condemns those which rest on birth, caste, sex or race. Thus, equality asks the question and justice supplies the standard of the answer.
Proportionate equality. Aristotle held that justice is equality of ratios, and that what each receives should be in proportion to his relevant claim. In distribution, the claim might be merit, in exchange the value of the goods, and in correction the harm done. This shows that justice is not always the same share for all, but an equal measure of treatment in relation to the ground of claim.
Equality of opportunity as a part of justice. A fair society is one in which positions are open to all on the basis of ability, and not closed by birth. Rawls named this fair equality of opportunity and made it a part of his second principle of justice. It requires that persons with the same talent and willingness to try should have the same chances of success whatever their class of origin.
Equality before the law as procedural justice. The rule of law requires that the same law apply to rulers and ruled, that courts hear both sides, and that the judge be impartial. These are forms of equality in procedure, and they are basic to natural justice. Without them, even a good law would be applied unjustly.
Social justice as the removal of unjust inequality. When people speak of social justice, they mean the removal of group-based disadvantages of caste, class, gender, religion, region and disability. The aim is to put each on a position of equal dignity and fair access to public goods. In this sense, social justice is largely the practice of equality in society.
Economic justice and the reduction of extreme inequality. Great differences of wealth and income give some persons power over the lives of others and may reduce the equal value of political rights. For this reason, justice has been understood to require progressive taxes, minimum wages, public education and health, and social security, which narrow inequality and secure a decent life for all. Tawney, Laski and the welfare liberals argued on these lines.
Distributive justice uses equality as one principle among others. Theories of distribution rest on equality, need, merit, contribution and entitlement. Equal shares are right in some areas, such as votes and basic rights, and need is right in some, such as health care, while merit is right in jobs and awards. Justice requires choosing the right principle for each sphere, as Walzer noted.
Equality of respect and recognition. Injustice is not only a matter of money. Caste, racial and gender hierarchies humiliate persons by treating them as inferior. Nancy Fraser and Charles Taylor argued that justice requires equal recognition of persons and groups, along with fair distribution. The abolition of untouchability is the clearest example.
Equality of capabilities. Sen held that justice is served when persons have equal real freedom to lead valuable lives, and that the same resources may give unequal freedom to different people. A disabled person needs more resources to reach the same functioning. Hence, the just application of equality may require unequal inputs in order to give equal capabilities.
Equality in the correction of wrongs. Corrective justice treats parties as equals before the court, and asks that the harm to one be undone by the other, without regard to their rank. It restores the equality disturbed by the wrong. Compensation to a victim and punishment of an offender in proportion to the offence are examples.
Where equality and justice may conflict. The two ideas are linked but may pull apart, and it is important to know where.
| Situation | Claim of equality | Claim of justice | How it is settled |
|---|---|---|---|
| Equal pay for all regardless of effort | Same reward for all | Reward should reflect work and contribution | Use equality for basic needs and merit for extra reward |
| Reservation in jobs and education | Same rules for all candidates | Past and present disadvantage requires special measures | Treated as a means to real equality; limits like creamy layer apply |
| Progressive taxation | Equal burden would be the same rate | Those with more capacity should bear more | Taxation by ability to pay, with checks on confiscation |
| Equal treatment of unequal needs | Same help for all | Persons with disability need more help | Equal concern, with unequal provision |
| Punishment | All offenders to get the same penalty | Penalty must fit the offence and the offender | Proportionate sentencing under the rule of law |
| Compensation for past wrongs | Present generation equal to each other | Descendants of victims may have claim for repair | Debated; programmes of redress and affirmative action |
| Free speech and equal dignity | Equal respect for all groups | Liberty of expression and fair rules | Reasonable restrictions and proportionality |
The lesson of the table is that the conflicts arise when equality is understood as identical treatment or equal outcomes in every case. If equality is understood as equal concern and respect, most of the conflicts can be reduced, because justice then allows differences that are explained by relevant reasons.
3. Theoretical perspectives on the relationship
Plato and Aristotle. Plato held that justice is the harmony of the city, in which each class performs its own task, and he accepted inequality of function. Aristotle brought the idea of equality into the centre of justice by defining it as proportionate equality. Both thinkers regarded natural inequality of ability as a proper ground of unequal status, and Aristotle did not apply equality to slaves and women. Their views are the starting point of the later debate, because they show that justice is not the same as equal shares.
Natural law and social contract. The Stoics and Cicero held that all human beings share reason and are equal under a universal law of nature. Locke built on this by holding that all are equal in natural rights, and justice lies in protecting these rights equally. Rousseau held that justice requires a society in which no one is rich enough to buy another or poor enough to be sold. These views make equality of status the base of just government.
Utilitarianism. Bentham’s rule that each is to count for one and none for more than one gives an equal weight to the interests of all. J. S. Mill held that justice protects important interests and that the subjection of women was unjust. Yet utilitarian justice looks at total happiness, not at its distribution, and so can accept great inequality if it raises the sum. Rawls and others criticised this on the ground that it neglects the separateness of persons.
Kant. Kant held that all rational persons have equal dignity and that justice means equal external freedom under universal law. Thus, equality of right is part of the concept of justice itself, and the state may not treat any person merely as a means. This view sets limits to what may be done in the name of the general good.
Classical liberalism. Liberals of the nineteenth century, such as Locke, Bentham and Mill, supported equality before the law and equality of civil and political rights, and opposed feudal privilege. They considered inequality of property as consistent with justice if gained fairly. The focus was on equal liberty and formal equality of opportunity, and not on equality of condition.
Welfare liberalism and socialism. T. H. Green, Hobhouse, Tawney and Laski argued that justice requires the state to create the conditions in which all can develop themselves, and so extended equality to social and economic life. Tawney held that a good society should reduce class privilege and make the common services available to all. Democratic socialists made the demand of equality of condition central to social justice.
Marx. Marx held that equal rights in a capitalist society hide real inequality of class, because workers must sell their labour to those who own the means of production. For him, true justice cannot be achieved by equal rights alone, but by the abolition of class and exploitation. In the higher stage of communism, distribution is according to need. Marx was wary of speaking of justice in general moral terms, but his work was used to show that equal formal rights may support unequal power.
John Rawls. Rawls is the most important modern thinker on the relationship. He argued that the principles of justice are those that free and equal persons would choose behind a veil of ignorance. The first principle gives equal basic liberties to all. The second has two parts, fair equality of opportunity and the difference principle, by which inequalities are justified only if they benefit the least advantaged. Thus, equality is the starting presumption, and inequality needs justification. In his view, natural talents are morally arbitrary, and so those who are born with more should not gain except in ways that help the rest. He supported a property-owning democracy or a welfare state as the institutional form.
Ronald Dworkin. Dworkin held that equal concern for each citizen’s fate is the sovereign virtue of government. Justice requires equality of resources, in which people bear the costs of their own choices but are compensated for bad luck, such as disability and poor family background. He used the device of a hypothetical auction and an insurance scheme to explain this. Luck egalitarians like G. A. Cohen developed the idea that inequality is unjust when it results from unchosen circumstances.
Amartya Sen. Sen asked equality of what, and answered that it should be of capabilities. He held that justice requires a comparison of actual arrangements, to reduce manifest injustice, rather than a search for the perfect structure. For him, equality of income is not enough, because persons convert resources into freedom in different ways. His approach underlies the Human Development Index.
Robert Nozick and the libertarians. Nozick rejected patterned equality. He held that a distribution is just if it arose from just acquisition and just transfer, whatever its shape, and that attempts to maintain equality need constant interference with liberty. In this view, justice is a matter of respecting rights, and equality of rights, but not of holdings, is required. Hayek likewise distinguished equality before the law, which is just, from material equality, which he held to be the result of the market and not a matter of justice at all.
Michael Walzer. In Spheres of Justice, Walzer argued for complex equality. Different goods, such as money, office, education, security and love, should be distributed by their own principles, and the dominance of one good, such as wealth, over other spheres is unjust. Justice requires that no one’s advantage in one sphere is turned automatically into advantage in another.
Elizabeth Anderson and relational equality. Anderson and other relational egalitarians argue that the point of equality is to end oppression and hierarchy, so that people can stand as equals in society, not merely to equalise shares of goods. Justice in this view is about the relations of respect and power among citizens, which links equality with democracy.
Feminist and intersectional views. Susan Moller Okin argued that the unequal division of labour in the family is a matter of justice, since it affects the life chances of women. Iris Marion Young held that injustice is domination and oppression, and not merely maldistribution. Kimberle Crenshaw’s concept of intersectionality shows that disadvantages of caste, class, race and sex combine, so that equal treatment of a single category may leave some persons out.
Dalit-Bahujan thought. Phule, Periyar and Ambedkar held that caste is a system of graded inequality which is a basic injustice. For them, justice requires not only equal rights but the destruction of the social order that denies dignity, and a society based on liberty, equality and fraternity.
| Thinker | Place of equality in justice | Key idea |
|---|---|---|
| Aristotle | Justice is proportionate equality | Treat equals equally and unequals unequally |
| Rousseau | Equality is a condition of freedom and the common good | No one too rich or too poor |
| Bentham and Mill | Equal counting of interests | Each to count for one |
| Kant | Equal dignity of persons | Equal freedom under universal law |
| Tawney and Laski | Equality of condition and service | Remove class privilege |
| Marx | Real equality needs end of class | From each according to ability to each according to need |
| Rawls | Equality as the starting point | Difference principle |
| Dworkin | Equal concern and respect | Equality of resources; luck egalitarianism |
| Sen | Equality of capabilities | Reduce manifest injustice |
| Nozick | Equal rights, not equal holdings | Entitlement theory |
| Walzer | Complex equality | Separate spheres of distribution |
| Anderson | Relational equality | End hierarchy and oppression |
| Okin and Young | Justice includes family and structures of oppression | Gender justice |
| Ambedkar | Annihilation of graded inequality | Liberty, equality, fraternity |
4. The Indian perspective
Hierarchy, dharma and the older critique. In the Indian tradition, justice was linked with dharma, and the varna and jati order gave unequal duties and status by birth. This meant that the idea of justice itself was used at times to support inequality. At the same time, Buddha, Mahavira, the Bhakti saints, Basava, Kabir and Guru Nanak argued that birth cannot decide worth, and gave a moral base for equality. The conflict between the two strands has shaped modern Indian thinking on justice and equality.
Reformers. Phule, in Gulamgiri (1873), described caste as a system of domination by the Brahmins, and called for education and equal rights for the lower castes and women. Narayana Guru taught one caste, one religion, one God. Periyar’s Self-Respect Movement asked for equal dignity and rejected Brahmin supremacy. Ranade and Vidyasagar worked for reform of the status of women. All of them treated inequality of birth as a basic injustice.
Gandhi. Gandhi held that all human beings are equal in the eyes of God, and described untouchability as a sin and a stain on Hinduism. He combined justice with truth and non-violence, and asked that the rich act as trustees of wealth. He wanted equality of dignity through bread labour and village self-rule. His view of social equality was moral and gradual, and he did not wholly reject varna, which Ambedkar strongly criticised. The Poona Pact (1932), reached after his fast, gave reserved seats to the depressed classes in the legislatures in place of separate electorates, and shows the tension between the two thinkers on how justice for the oppressed should be secured.
Ambedkar. Ambedkar is the central figure for the relationship. He described caste as graded inequality, with a ladder of respect and contempt, which makes joint action impossible and keeps the lower castes in permanent subjection. He held that justice is another name for equality, liberty and fraternity, and that none can be separated from the others. In his speech at the close of the Constituent Assembly debates, he said that political democracy would fail unless it had a base of social democracy, and that India was entering a life of contradictions with equality in politics and inequality in social and economic life. He supported reservation, the abolition of untouchability, equal rights for women through the Hindu Code Bill, and economic measures such as state ownership of key industries. For him, formal equality before the law was a first step, and justice meant the removal of the structure of caste.
Nehru and the socialists. Nehru held that political equality without economic equality is incomplete, and worked for planning, land reform and a mixed economy for a socialistic pattern of society. Lohia asked for the removal of inequalities between man and woman, between castes, between colours, between nations and between rich and poor, and for special opportunities for the backward. These strands shaped the economic side of the Indian understanding of justice.
The Preamble. The Preamble places justice, social, economic and political, first among the aims, followed by liberty of thought, expression, belief, faith and worship, equality of status and of opportunity, and fraternity assuring the dignity of the individual and the unity and integrity of the nation. This order suggests that justice is the end, and liberty and equality are its main parts. Ambedkar’s idea of the unity of liberty, equality and fraternity is also reflected.
Constitutional scheme.
| Provision | Role in connecting equality and justice |
|---|---|
| Preamble | Justice as aim; equality of status and opportunity as its means |
| Article 14 | Equality before law and equal protection, with the test of reasonable classification and non-arbitrariness |
| Article 15(1) and (2) | No discrimination on grounds of religion, race, caste, sex, place of birth in state action and access to public places |
| Article 15(3), (4), (5) and (6) | Special provisions for women and children, for socially and educationally backward classes, SCs and STs including in private educational institutions, and for economically weaker sections |
| Article 16(1) and (2) | Equality of opportunity in public employment |
| Article 16(4), (4A) and (4B) | Reservation for backward classes and for SCs and STs in promotion, and carry-forward of vacancies |
| Article 17 | Abolition of untouchability |
| Article 21 | Right to life and personal liberty, read to include dignity, livelihood and fair procedure |
| Articles 23 and 24 | Against exploitation, forced labour and child labour |
| Article 38 | State to promote the welfare of people by securing a social order informed by justice, social, economic and political, and to minimise inequalities |
| Article 39(b), (c) | Distribution of resources to serve the common good and avoid concentration of wealth |
| Article 39(d) | Equal pay for equal work for men and women |
| Article 39A | Equal justice and free legal aid |
| Article 46 | Promotion of educational and economic interests of weaker sections |
| Articles 330 and 332 | Reservation of seats for SCs and STs in the Lok Sabha and State Assemblies |
| Article 243D, 243T | Reservation for women and weaker sections in local bodies |
Judicial approach. The courts have developed a test for linking equality with justice.
- Reasonable classification. In earlier cases, the Court held that Article 14 permits classification if it rests on an intelligible differentia and has a rational relation to the aim of the law.
- Non-arbitrariness. In E. P. Royappa (1974), the Court said that equality is a dynamic concept with many aspects and that arbitrariness is the opposite of equality. In Maneka Gandhi (1978), this was joined with the requirement of fair, just and reasonable procedure under Article 21.
- Substantive equality. In Indra Sawhney (1992), the Court upheld reservation for OBCs while excluding the creamy layer and fixing a general 50 per cent limit, on the idea that equality of opportunity requires special measures for those socially and educationally backward.
- Equal justice and legal aid. In Hussainara Khatoon (1979), the Court held that speedy trial and free legal aid are part of the right to life, since a person too poor to defend himself cannot get equal justice.
- Gender justice. In Vishaka (1997), the Court laid down guidelines on sexual harassment by reading international conventions into the right to equality, and in Joseph Shine v. Union of India (2018), it struck down the offence of adultery as being based on a view of women as property and contrary to equality and dignity.
- Sex and gender identity. In National Legal Services Authority (2014), the Court recognised transgender persons as a third gender entitled to equal rights, and in Navtej Singh Johar (2018), it held that criminalising consensual same-sex relations was contrary to dignity and equality.
- Reservation and economic backwardness. In Janhit Abhiyan (2022), the Court by majority upheld the 103rd Amendment, which gave up to 10 per cent reservation to economically weaker sections outside the existing categories. Three of the five judges upheld it and two dissented, with the dissent holding that excluding the SCs, STs and OBCs among the poor was a violation of equality.
- Sub-classification. In State of Punjab v. Davinder Singh (2024), a seven-judge bench held that the states may sub-classify Scheduled Castes for reservation if based on data of inadequate representation, since the groups within them are not equally placed.
Protective discrimination as the link. The Indian constitutional approach holds that treating unequals alike can perpetuate injustice, and so special provisions for the disadvantaged are part of equality itself. Article 15(4), Article 16(4) and the reserved seats in legislatures embody this idea. The argument of the Court is that equality of opportunity under Article 16(1) and the reservation under Article 16(4) are not opposed, but the latter is a means to give effect to the former.
Welfare law as the link. Statutes such as the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act (1989), the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act (2005), the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act (2016), the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act (2009), the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (2005) and the National Food Security Act (2013) aim to give a minimum of equality in life chances as a requirement of social and economic justice.
Continuing difficulties. Despite all this, caste discrimination, crimes against Dalits and women, high inequality of wealth, differences between regions, and unequal access to quality education and health persist. Questions such as the creamy layer for SCs and STs, the caste census, reservation in the private sector, and the 50 per cent ceiling show that the relationship between equality and justice remains a live issue in Indian politics and law.
5. Importance and limitations of understanding the relationship
Importance.
- Clarifies the meaning of fair treatment. The study shows that fairness is not always identical treatment, and that it asks for equal respect with different treatment where the relevant facts differ. This removes a common confusion in public debate.
- Gives a test for judging inequalities. By asking whether an inequality can be justified to those who are worse off, or whether it rests on arbitrary grounds like birth, the relationship helps to separate acceptable from unacceptable differences in pay, rank and opportunity.
- Guides the making of laws and policies. Tax, welfare, reservation, education and labour policy all need a view on how far equality should be pursued for the sake of justice. Policy makers use these ideas in framing and defending their measures.
- Explains the role of courts. Judges apply equality clauses such as Article 14 as tests of fairness and arbitrariness. Knowing the link helps to understand why the courts accept reasonable classification and substantive equality.
- Supports the case for social justice. The relationship shows why removal of caste, gender and other group-based disadvantages is a matter of justice, and not of charity. It gives a moral base to the demands of the weaker sections.
- Joins liberty, equality and fraternity. The study shows that justice is the aim that connects these values, as Ambedkar argued. It prevents a one-sided stress on freedom without fairness or on equality without freedom.
- Strengthens democracy. Political equality needs the support of social and economic justice, otherwise the formal rights of the poor are empty. This understanding underlies demands for inclusive governance and welfare.
- Helps in comparing political theories. Liberal, libertarian, socialist, communitarian and feminist thinkers differ mainly on how they connect equality and justice, and the relationship is a good way to organise the comparison.
- Useful for international questions. Debates on global poverty, trade, migration and climate change ask whether justice requires a greater equality among nations and persons, and the ideas studied here apply to them.
- Builds a habit of critical reasoning. Students learn to ask equality of what, among whom, and for what reason, which is useful in exams as well as in public life.
Limitations and difficulties.
- Absence of agreement. Theorists differ about whether justice requires equality at all, as libertarians deny that it does, and so the relationship cannot be stated in a single formula.
- Equality of what is unclear. Welfare, resources, opportunity, capabilities and status each give different answers about what justice requires, and it is hard to say which should be chosen.
- Risk of treating equality as the whole of justice. Justice also concerns desert, rights, procedure, liberty and the correction of wrongs. If equality alone is made the test, other important values may be neglected.
- Trade-offs with liberty and efficiency. Measures to promote equality may reduce incentives and restrict individual choice, and the right balance is disputed. The experience of various countries gives mixed lessons.
- Problem of identifying relevant differences. The rule to treat unequals unequally needs a view of which differences matter. The history of slavery, caste and patriarchy shows that societies have often wrongly treated certain differences as relevant.
- Group claims may conflict. Different disadvantaged groups may ask for equal treatment in ways that clash, and the inclusion of one group may be seen as exclusion of another, as in debates on reservation categories.
- Dependence on institutions. Even when principles are clear, their application depends on honest and efficient administration. Where courts and bureaucracies are weak, the aims of equality and justice remain on paper.
- Difficulty of measuring outcomes. It is hard to say whether a policy has actually made society more just, since the data on income, wealth, caste and gender are not always complete or agreed.
- Cultural and historical change. Standards of equal treatment change across time and place, and what one generation finds just may be seen as unjust by the next.
- Limits of the national frame. Most theories apply equality and justice within a state, and are less clear about duties to foreigners and to future generations.
6. Critical analysis
The first point is that the relationship is one of overlap and not of identity. Equality is the best known component of justice, and most theories give it a place, but justice has other components as well, and some theories give equality only a limited role. A study which merges the two ideas misses the main debates between egalitarians, who see justice mostly as equality, sufficientarians, who say that justice requires only that everyone has enough, prioritarians, who say that benefits matter more to the worse off, and libertarians, who say that justice is respect for rights and entitlements.
The second point is that the most useful reading is the one in which equality is a presumption, which can be set aside only for good reasons. This is close to the view of Rawls and Dworkin. Under it, every inequality has to be justified to those who are affected, and the burden is on those who benefit. This avoids the crude idea that all should have the same, and also avoids the opposite idea that any result of the market is just. It also fits the practice of courts, which ask whether a classification has a reasonable basis.
The third point concerns the influence of merit. Defenders of inequality of reward say that justice requires giving persons what they deserve by effort and talent. Egalitarians reply that talents and the capacity for effort are themselves partly the products of luck, such as family, health and the school one went to, and therefore do not give a clear moral claim to reward. Sandel has added that an exaggerated belief in merit may make winners proud and losers resentful. The better view may be a middle one, in which reward for effort is accepted within limits set by fair opportunity and the needs of the worse off.
The fourth point is the claim of the libertarian critique. Nozick’s argument is that any pattern of equality can be upset by free exchanges and that holding to it needs continuous interference with liberty. It is a strong challenge, but it has limits. It assumes that the starting holdings were justly acquired, whereas many fortunes arose from conquest, caste privilege and exploitation, as in India and elsewhere. Where injustice in the past is large, Nozick’s own principle of rectification would support redistribution.
The fifth point is the difference between formal and substantive equality. Equal rules can reproduce injustice when people start from very unequal positions, and the Indian Constitution therefore accepts special provisions as part of equality itself. However, it remains controversial how far this should go, who should be covered, and for how long. The creamy layer principle, sub-classification of categories, the reservation for economically weaker sections and the demand for a caste census are all different ways of asking how best to link equality with justice in a country with deep and overlapping inequalities.
The sixth point is that recognition and redistribution must be seen together. Caste is not only a matter of unequal incomes but also of stigma, exclusion from public life and violence. Policies that give resources without addressing respect may fail to give justice, while symbolic recognition without resources may be hollow. This is the point of Fraser’s analysis and of Ambedkar’s insistence on both material and moral change.
In sum, equality gives justice its sense of fairness among persons, and justice gives equality its limits and reasons. A society that wishes to be just must treat its members as equals in dignity and basic rights, must correct disadvantages which are not their fault, and must allow differences only where they can be defended by reasons all can accept.
7. Authors and books for UGC NET
| Author | Book or work | Contribution to the theme |
|---|---|---|
| Aristotle | Nicomachean Ethics, Book V | Justice as proportionate equality |
| J. J. Rousseau | Discourse on Inequality (1755); The Social Contract (1762) | Inequality and the general will |
| Jeremy Bentham | An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation (1789) | Equal counting of interests |
| Immanuel Kant | The Metaphysics of Morals (1797) | Equal dignity and equal freedom |
| J. S. Mill | Utilitarianism (1861); The Subjection of Women (1869) | Justice and equal rights |
| Karl Marx | Critique of the Gotha Programme (1875) | Equal right as bourgeois right; distribution by need |
| R. H. Tawney | Equality (1931) | Social equality and class privilege |
| Harold Laski | A Grammar of Politics (1925) | Equality and the conditions of the best self |
| F. A. Hayek | The Constitution of Liberty (1960) | Equality before law versus social justice |
| John Rawls | A Theory of Justice (1971) | Fair equality of opportunity; difference principle |
| Robert Nozick | Anarchy, State, and Utopia (1974) | Entitlement against patterned equality |
| Michael Walzer | Spheres of Justice (1983) | Complex equality |
| Susan Moller Okin | Justice, Gender, and the Family (1989) | Gender and justice in the family |
| Amartya Sen | Inequality Reexamined (1992); The Idea of Justice (2009) | Capabilities; comparative approach |
| Ronald Dworkin | Sovereign Virtue (2000) | Equality of resources; luck egalitarianism |
| Nancy Fraser | Justice Interruptus (1997) | Redistribution, recognition and representation |
| Elizabeth Anderson | What Is the Point of Equality? (1999) | Relational equality |
| Michael Sandel | The Tyranny of Merit (2020) | Critique of meritocracy |
| B. R. Ambedkar | Annihilation of Caste (1936); speech to the Constituent Assembly, 25 November 1949 | Graded inequality; social democracy |
| Jotirao Phule | Gulamgiri (1873) | Caste as injustice |
| Marc Galanter | Competing Equalities (1984) | Law and the backward classes in India |
| Andre Beteille | Inequality and Social Change (1972) | Sociology of inequality in India |
8. Practice questions
Long answer questions
- Discuss the relationship between equality and justice. Is justice nothing but equality?
- Examine the views of Aristotle, Rawls and Dworkin on the place of equality in a theory of justice.
- Critically examine the libertarian argument of Nozick against equality as a requirement of justice.
- Discuss how the Indian Constitution tries to join equality with social justice. Illustrate with decisions of the Supreme Court.
- “Treating unequals alike is as unjust as treating equals unequally.” Examine the statement with reference to reservation in India.
- Evaluate the contribution of Ambedkar to the understanding of the relationship between equality, justice and social democracy.
Medium answer questions
- Explain the meaning of proportionate equality.
- What is the difference principle and how does it connect equality with justice?
- Explain the distinction between formal and substantive equality in relation to justice.
- Discuss the idea of luck egalitarianism.
- What is meant by complex equality, and how does it limit the demand for equality?
- Explain the role of recognition and redistribution in a theory of social justice.
Short answer questions
- What is meant by reasonable classification?
- What is equality of opportunity?
- What is relational equality?
- What is meant by non-arbitrariness under Article 14?
- What is the creamy layer?
- What is the difference between equality of outcome and equality of capabilities?
Very short answer questions
- Who defined justice as proportionate equality?
- Which Article of the Constitution deals with equal justice and free legal aid?
- Who wrote What Is the Point of Equality?
- Name the case in which arbitrariness was held to be opposed to equality.
- Which Amendment provided reservation for economically weaker sections?
Objective questions
- The idea that justice is proportionate equality is found in: (a) Plato’s Republic (b) Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics (c) Hobbes’s Leviathan (d) Mill’s On Liberty
- The difference principle belongs to the theory of: (a) Nozick (b) Walzer (c) Rawls (d) Hayek
- Who criticised the idea of social justice as a mirage in a market order? (a) Hayek (b) Sen (c) Tawney (d) Laski
- Which Article gives equality before law and equal protection of the laws? (a) Article 13 (b) Article 14 (c) Article 15 (d) Article 16
- Equality of capabilities is associated with: (a) Dworkin (b) Sen (c) Rawls (d) Nozick
- Assertion (A): Reservation is consistent with the idea of equality in the Constitution. Reason (R): Equality of opportunity may require special measures for those who are socially and educationally disadvantaged. (a) Both A and R are true and R explains A (b) Both are true but R does not explain A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true
- The case which upheld reservation for OBCs with a creamy layer exclusion is: (a) Balaji (b) Indra Sawhney (c) Champakam Dorairajan (d) Royappa
- Match: (i) Tawney (ii) Walzer (iii) Anderson (iv) Okin with (a) Complex equality (b) Gender and the family (c) Relational equality (d) Social equality and class. (a) i-d, ii-a, iii-c, iv-b (b) i-a, ii-d, iii-b, iv-c (c) i-c, ii-b, iii-d, iv-a (d) i-b, ii-c, iii-a, iv-d
Analytical prompts
- Two applicants, one from a well-off family in a city and one from a poor rural background, score the same marks in an entrance examination. Analyse which principles of equality and justice may be applied in deciding between them.
- A government proposes to give a larger scholarship to students with disabilities than to others. Discuss whether this is consistent with equality and justice.
- “If everyone starts with an equal share, and the market then produces inequality through free choices, the result is just.” Examine with reference to Nozick and Rawls.
- Why does Ambedkar say that political equality without social and economic equality is dangerous for democracy?
Key takeaways
- Equality and justice overlap strongly, since justice includes the rule that persons be treated as equals unless there is good reason for difference, but justice is a wider idea.
- Aristotle’s proportionate equality shows that justice does not always mean equal shares, but fair treatment in proportion to relevant claims.
- Rawls makes equality a starting presumption and allows inequality only when it helps the least advantaged, while Dworkin and Sen ask for equal concern and equal capabilities.
- Nozick and Hayek hold that equality of rights is just but equality of holdings is not required, and Marx, Walzer and feminist thinkers stress class, spheres and structures of domination.
- Conflicts arise when equality is taken as identical treatment or equal outcomes, and they are reduced when equality is understood as equal concern and respect.
- Equality of opportunity, equality before law, social justice and economic justice are the main places where the two ideas join.
- Ambedkar holds that liberty, equality and fraternity must be seen as one, and that political democracy needs social democracy.
- The Indian Constitution links the two through the Preamble, Articles 14 to 17, Articles 38, 39 and 46, and the courts’ tests of reasonable classification, non-arbitrariness and substantive equality.
Twenty books for further reading
- Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics
- R. H. Tawney, Equality
- John Rawls, A Theory of Justice
- John Rawls, Justice as Fairness: A Restatement
- Ronald Dworkin, Sovereign Virtue
- Amartya Sen, Inequality Reexamined
- Amartya Sen, The Idea of Justice
- Robert Nozick, Anarchy, State, and Utopia
- Michael Walzer, Spheres of Justice
- David Miller, Principles of Social Justice
- Elizabeth Anderson, The Imperative of Integration
- Nancy Fraser and Axel Honneth, Redistribution or Recognition?
- Susan Moller Okin, Justice, Gender, and the Family
- Michael Sandel, The Tyranny of Merit
- Thomas Piketty, Capital in the Twenty-First Century
- B. R. Ambedkar, Annihilation of Caste
- Marc Galanter, Competing Equalities: Law and the Backward Classes in India
- Granville Austin, The Indian Constitution: Cornerstone of a Nation
- Gurpreet Mahajan, Political Theory: Concepts and Perspectives
- O. P. Gauba, An Introduction to Political Theory
Frequently asked questions
1. Is justice the same as equality? No. Equality is a main part of justice, since justice asks that persons be treated as equals unless there is a good reason, but justice also includes desert, rights, procedure and the correction of wrongs. Some theories of justice, like Nozick’s, give equality only a narrow role.
2. What did Aristotle mean by proportionate equality? He meant that equals should be treated equally and unequals unequally in proportion to their difference. Each should receive in proportion to his relevant claim, such as merit in the distribution of honour, so that justice is an equality of ratios and not always of shares.
3. How does Rawls link equality with justice? Rawls holds that persons behind a veil of ignorance would choose equal basic liberties, fair equality of opportunity and a difference principle. Inequalities are just only if they are open to all and work to the greatest benefit of the least advantaged.
4. Can reservation be justified as a part of equality? The Indian Constitution and the Supreme Court treat reservation as a means to substantive equality, since persons who were kept out for centuries cannot compete fairly under the same rules. The courts allow it within limits such as the 50 per cent ceiling and the creamy layer rule for OBCs.
5. What is the difference between formal and substantive equality? Formal equality means the same rules for all, while substantive equality takes account of actual social and economic conditions, and may ask for special measures to produce a fair result. Justice usually requires both.
6. Why did Ambedkar say that liberty, equality and fraternity must be taken together? He held that liberty without equality would produce the dominance of a few over many, equality without liberty would kill individual initiative, and neither could be kept without fraternity, the sense of common brotherhood. Together they form the base of social democracy and justice.
