Democracy: Meaning, Nature and Evolution

Democracy is the most widely accepted form of government in the modern world, and also one of the most debated ideas in political theory. Almost every state today claims to be democratic, from the largest countries to the smallest, and even rulers who do not allow free elections often use the word for their own system. This shows both the moral force of the idea and the confusion around it. A student must therefore ask what democracy really means, how it is different from other forms of rule, what its essential features are, and how it has grown over time.

The word democracy is easy to say but hard to define. In its simplest sense, it means rule by the people. But who are the people, how do they rule, and over what matters? Does democracy mean only free elections, or does it also need equality, rights, the rule of law and an active citizenry? Is it a form of government, a type of state, or a way of life? Thinkers from Pericles and Aristotle to Rousseau, Mill, Schumpeter, Dahl and Ambedkar have given different answers. A study of these answers is the base for all later topics on democracy, such as its models, its theories and its working in plural societies.

1. Meaning and nature of democracy

Meaning. The word democracy comes from two Greek words, demos, which means the people, and kratos, which means rule or power. Literally, therefore, democracy means rule of the people. In the ancient Greek city of Athens, it meant that the free male citizens met in an assembly and decided public matters themselves. In the modern world, it usually means a system in which the people choose their rulers in free and fair elections, the rulers are accountable to the people, and the rights of citizens are protected by law.

Democracy as a form of government. In this view, democracy is a way of organising the government. It is a system in which power is held by representatives chosen by the people, who can be removed at the next election. This is the common meaning in political science. It is contrasted with monarchy, in which one rules, aristocracy and oligarchy, in which a few rule, and dictatorship, in which power is not accountable to the people.

Democracy as a form of state and society. In a wider view, democracy is a principle that governs the whole society, and not only the government. It requires that the state respect the equality and dignity of all citizens and that social relations be free from domination. This view is held by thinkers such as Ambedkar, who held that political democracy cannot last without social democracy, and by Dewey, who called democracy a mode of associated living.

Democracy as a way of life. In its widest sense, democracy is a set of habits and values, such as tolerance, respect for others, readiness to hear different views, and the settling of disputes by discussion. Gandhi and Tagore spoke of it in moral terms, as self-rule of the individual and of the community. Without such values, the outer forms of democracy may become empty.

Procedural and substantive views. The procedural view, held by Schumpeter, Popper and Dahl in some of their writings, says that democracy is a method of choosing and removing rulers through competitive elections and the rule of law. The substantive view says that democracy is judged by its results and values, such as equality, justice and welfare. Most modern writers combine both, since a democracy needs fair procedures and some basic social conditions.

Direct and indirect democracy. In direct democracy, the citizens themselves make laws and decisions, as in the Athenian assembly and in the Swiss cantons. In indirect or representative democracy, the people elect representatives to make decisions on their behalf. In the large modern states, the second form is the common one, although direct elements like the referendum, initiative and recall are used in some places.

Liberal and non-liberal democracy. Liberal democracy combines free and fair elections with constitutional limits on power, an independent judiciary, and protection of individual rights. Fareed Zakaria has described states that hold elections but do not protect liberties as illiberal democracies. This distinction shows that the holding of elections alone does not make a state a full democracy.

ScholarUnderstanding of democracy
PericlesGovernment in the hands of the many rather than the few, with equal justice for all in private disputes
AristotleRule by the many who are free and poor, a deviation from polity when it serves the interest of the poor
RousseauGovernment in which sovereignty rests with the people and the general will makes the law
Abraham LincolnGovernment of the people, by the people and for the people
J. S. MillRepresentative government in which the whole people, or a large part of them, exercise power through deputies they elect
James BryceA form of government in which the ruling power is vested in the members of the community as a whole
Joseph SchumpeterAn institutional arrangement for reaching political decisions in which individuals acquire the power to decide by means of a competitive struggle for the people’s vote
Robert DahlPolyarchy: a system with effective participation, equality of votes, enlightened understanding, control of the agenda and inclusion of adults
C. B. MacphersonA system of government and a kind of society in which the people can develop their human capacities
Giovanni SartoriA system in which no one can choose himself, no one can invest himself with the power to rule, and no one can hold unconditional and unlimited power
John DeweyMore than a form of government; primarily a mode of associated living and of conjoint communicated experience
B. R. AmbedkarA form and a method of government whereby revolutionary changes in the economic and social life of the people are brought about without bloodshed
Amartya SenGovernment by discussion, and the exercise of public reasoning, with a universal value

Pericles. In the funeral oration recorded by Thucydides, Pericles described the constitution of Athens as one that is called a democracy because power is in the hands of the many and not the few. He added that all are equal before the law in private disputes, and that public honour goes to merit and not to class. He also noted that the citizens take an interest in public affairs and that the poor man is not barred by his poverty from serving the state.

Aristotle. In Politics, Aristotle classified governments by the number of rulers and by whether they ruled for the common good. He regarded democracy as the bad form of rule by the many, in which the poor rule in their own interest, and he preferred polity, a mixed constitution which joins the claims of the rich and the poor. Yet he also noted that the many together may be a better judge than the few, which is a defence of collective judgment.

Rousseau. In The Social Contract (1762), Rousseau held that sovereignty belongs inalienably to the people and is expressed in the general will, and that the people cannot be represented. He doubted that true democracy could exist in large states, and wrote that if there were a people of gods, they would govern themselves democratically, so perfect a government is not suited to men.

Abraham Lincoln. In the Gettysburg Address (1863), Lincoln gave the best known description of democracy as government of the people, by the people and for the people. The three phrases state that power comes from the people, that the people take part in its exercise, and that its purpose is the good of the people.

J. S. Mill. In Considerations on Representative Government (1861), Mill held that the ideal form of government is representative, and that the whole people, or some numerous part of it, exercises through deputies periodically elected the controlling power. He supported wide participation for the education of citizens, but also feared the tyranny of the majority and proposed proportional representation and plural votes for the educated.

James Bryce. In Modern Democracies (1921), Bryce described democracy as a form of government in which the ruling power of a state is legally vested not in any particular class or classes but in the members of the community as a whole. His definition stresses the wide base of authority and the legal form of rule.

Joseph Schumpeter. In Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy (1942), Schumpeter rejected the classical idea of the common good and the will of the people, and described democracy as a method of competition among leaders for the votes of the people. In his view, the role of the people is to produce a government, and the main test of democracy is the free competition for political leadership.

Robert Dahl. In Polyarchy (1971) and On Democracy (1998), Dahl used the term polyarchy for real-world democracies, in which there is a high degree of public contestation and inclusion. He listed institutions such as elected officials, free, fair and frequent elections, freedom of expression, alternative sources of information, associational autonomy and inclusive citizenship.

C. B. Macpherson. In The Life and Times of Liberal Democracy (1977), Macpherson held that democracy is a society in which individuals can develop their powers, and he criticised the liberal view as too tied to the market. He advocated participatory democracy for a more equal and developmental society.

Giovanni Sartori. In The Theory of Democracy Revisited (1987), Sartori distinguished the ideal from the real, and argued that democracy must be seen as a system of limited power which prevents the rise of unaccountable rule. He gave importance to the role of elites and to vertical control by the people.

John Dewey. In Democracy and Education (1916), Dewey defined democracy as more than a form of government, as primarily a mode of associated living, of conjoint communicated experience. This explains his stress on education, community and shared interests as the base of democracy.

B. R. Ambedkar. In his speeches in the Constituent Assembly and in the writings on social democracy, Ambedkar held that democracy is not only a form of government but a form of social organisation, which recognises liberty, equality and fraternity as a unity. He defined it as a form and method of government by which changes in the economic and social life of the people are brought about without bloodshed.

Amartya Sen. In The Argumentative Indian (2005) and in his essay on democracy as a universal value, Sen held that the central feature of democracy is public reasoning and government by discussion, and not merely the holding of elections. He argued that the value of democracy lies in its intrinsic importance for political freedom, its instrumental role in forcing governments to respond to the needs of the people, and its constructive role in forming values.

2. Characteristics of democracy

Popular sovereignty. The first feature of democracy is that the final power rests with the people. Governments get their authority from the consent of the governed, and not from birth, force or divine right. In India, the Preamble begins with the words We, the people of India, to show that the Constitution derives its authority from the people.

Free and fair elections. Rulers are chosen through regular elections in which all adult citizens can vote and contest, the votes are counted equally, and the results are respected. Elections allow the people to reward good governments and remove bad ones without violence. An independent election commission, a fair rule for campaigning and a secret ballot are needed to make elections real.

Political equality. Every citizen has an equal vote, and the vote of the poor counts as much as that of the rich. This is the idea of one person, one vote, one value. It was achieved only after long struggles against property qualifications and the exclusion of women, workers and minorities from the franchise.

Rule of law and constitutionalism. Democratic governments act within law, and the laws apply to rulers as well as the ruled. The powers of the government are limited by a constitution, and no one is above the law. This distinguishes democracy from the rule of a strong leader who acts as he likes, even if he was elected.

Fundamental rights and civil liberties. Citizens enjoy freedom of speech, assembly, association, religion and movement, and the right to a fair trial. These rights make it possible for the people to criticise the government and to organise alternatives. A democracy in which these liberties are denied is only democratic in name.

Majority rule with protection of minorities. Decisions are taken by the majority, but the majority may not take away the basic rights of the minority. Mill and Tocqueville warned about the tyranny of the majority. A good democracy joins majority rule with respect for the rights of those who are outvoted, and gives them a chance to become the majority in future.

Accountability and responsiveness. Rulers are answerable to the people and to institutions such as the legislature, courts, the press and audit bodies. They must explain their decisions and respond to the needs of citizens. Instruments like questions in Parliament, committees, audit reports and the Right to Information Act give practical form to accountability.

Competition among parties and a choice of alternatives. Democracy needs more than one party or candidate, and a real chance for the opposition to win. A peaceful change of government is a test of a democracy. A one-party system, even with elections, does not give a real choice.

Independent judiciary. Courts that are free from the control of the executive protect the rights of citizens, settle disputes between organs of the state, and keep the government within the constitution. Judicial review gives them the power to strike down laws and actions which violate the constitution.

Free press and access to information. A free media and open flow of information help citizens to form opinions and to watch the government. Censorship and control of information destroy the ability of people to judge their rulers. Sen has noted that famines have not occurred in functioning democracies with a free press, because governments are forced to respond.

Participation by citizens. Democracy does not end with voting. Citizens may join parties, unions, associations, social movements and local bodies, and take part in public discussion. The stronger the participation, the more democratic the system. Local government in India through the panchayats and municipalities is an effort to widen participation.

Peaceful settlement of conflict. Democracy provides a method by which disagreements between groups are settled by discussion, bargaining and voting, and not by violence. It accepts that conflict is normal in a free society and provides institutions, such as legislatures and courts, to deal with it. Its working depends on tolerance and a willingness to compromise.

Separation of powers and checks and balances. In most democracies, power is divided between the legislature, the executive and the judiciary, and often between the centre and the regions, so that no single organ can take over the whole. Montesquieu argued that power should check power. India follows a parliamentary system with a partial separation, along with federal division of power.

3. Essential conditions for the success of democracy

Political and civic education. Citizens must understand their rights and duties and the working of institutions to take part in a meaningful way. Literacy, schools and public discussion help in developing this understanding. Mill and Dewey gave great importance to education as a means of forming democratic citizens.

Economic base and reduction of extreme inequality. Democracy is more stable in societies where there is no very great poverty and extreme gaps in wealth. Hunger and insecurity limit the capacity of people to take part, and great wealth can buy political influence. Lipset argued that economic development supports democracy, though this view has been debated.

Social equality and the end of discrimination. A democracy cannot work well where caste, race or sex decides a person’s place. Ambedkar insisted that the political equality of one vote could not be secure without social and economic equality. Attitudes of equality and fraternity among citizens are needed.

Independent institutions. The election commission, the courts, the audit authority and the civil service must work without partisan control. Where these are captured by the ruling party, democracy loses its meaning.

Strong civil society and political parties. Voluntary associations, unions, media and parties link citizens to the state and provide channels for voicing demands. Tocqueville argued that associations are the schools of democracy.

Political culture of tolerance and compromise. Democracy needs leaders and citizens who accept defeat, respect opponents and prefer discussion to force. Almond and Verba described a civic culture which blends participation with respect for authority.

Respect for the constitution and a sense of national unity. There must be a shared agreement on the basic rules of the political game and a feeling of belonging that allows differences to be accepted. Dankwart Rustow stressed that national unity is the one background condition for democratisation.

Vigilance by citizens. Democracy, as is often said, requires eternal vigilance. Rights can be lost if citizens do not guard them. Public watchfulness, a free press and active opposition help to prevent misuse of power.

International environment. Support from other democracies and international norms may help democracies, while war, foreign interference or economic pressure may weaken them. The spread of democracy in Europe after 1945 and in Latin America and Eastern Europe in later decades was helped by regional and international support.

4. Evolution of democracy

Athenian democracy. The first well known democracy grew in the Greek city of Athens in the fifth century BCE, after the reforms of Solon, Cleisthenes and later Ephialtes and Pericles. The main organ was the Assembly, or Ekklesia, in which all male citizens above twenty years could speak and vote on laws, war and peace. A Council of Five Hundred, chosen by lot, prepared its business, and many officials were also chosen by lot, to give each citizen a chance to rule. Large juries decided legal cases. Pay for public service allowed poor citizens to take part. This was direct democracy, but it excluded women, slaves, and foreigners, so only a small part of the population enjoyed it. Critics like Plato regarded it as the rule of the ignorant, and the trial and death of Socrates in 399 BCE was used as an example.

Roman Republic. Rome developed a mixed constitution with consuls, a Senate and popular assemblies, and its idea of citizenship, law and representation influenced later thought. Polybius admired the balance of the three elements, and later writers such as Cicero praised the republic as the property of the people. The Roman contribution is the idea of law as the common bond of citizens and of republican limits on power.

Republics and assemblies outside Greece and Rome. Many societies had forms of collective decision. Ancient India had ganas and sanghas, such as the Licchavis and the Shakyas, in which assemblies took decisions. Tribal councils of Africa, the assemblies of the Vikings, and the town councils of Italian city republics such as Florence and Venice all show different forms of rule by councils. These examples show that democratic practice was not confined to the West.

Medieval period. In Europe, feudal and monarchical rule prevailed, but ideas of limited rule survived. The Magna Carta (1215) forced the English king to accept that he was bound by law and that taxes needed the consent of the barons. Later, the English Parliament, the French Estates General and the Spanish Cortes developed as bodies which represented estates and not individuals. The Church thinkers, such as Marsilius of Padua, argued that authority comes from the people. In the Islamic world, the principle of shura, or consultation, was part of the political tradition, though it did not take the form of popular government.

The Renaissance and the Reformation. The revival of republican ideas in Italy by thinkers like Machiavelli, who in his Discourses praised the Roman republic, and the Protestant challenge to the authority of the Church, spread the idea that individuals could think and decide for themselves. Religious conflicts later led to the argument for toleration and the right of resistance.

Social contract and the Enlightenment. In the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, thinkers such as Hobbes, Locke, Rousseau and Montesquieu argued that government rests on consent and exists for the protection of natural rights. Locke defended government by consent and the right to revolt against tyranny. Montesquieu, in The Spirit of the Laws (1748), advocated the separation of powers. Rousseau advanced popular sovereignty and the general will. These ideas gave a philosophical base to modern democracy.

Revolutions. The English Revolution of 1688 established the supremacy of Parliament, and the Bill of Rights (1689) laid down limits on the Crown. The American Revolution (1776) and the Constitution of 1787 created a large republic with representation, federalism and a written constitution. The French Revolution (1789) announced the Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen and the principles of liberty, equality and fraternity. Together these events turned democracy from a small city idea into a principle for large states.

Nineteenth century: liberal and democratic expansion. The franchise was gradually widened. In Britain, the Reform Acts of 1832, 1867 and 1884 extended the vote to larger groups of men, and the Chartist movement demanded universal male suffrage. Mill and Tocqueville wrote about the possibilities and the dangers of the democratic age. Socialist movements and trade unions demanded the vote and rights for workers, and the movement for women’s suffrage began. In the United States, the abolition of slavery in 1865 and the later amendments were steps in widening citizenship, though real equality came much later.

Twentieth century: universal suffrage and mass democracy. The vote was extended to women in New Zealand (1893), Britain (1918 in part and 1928 in full), the United States (1920) and many other countries. After the First World War new democracies were formed, but many collapsed into fascism and dictatorship in the interwar years, as in Italy, Germany and Spain. After the Second World War, democracy was restored in Western Europe, Japan and Germany, and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948) listed the right to take part in government. The decolonisation of Asia and Africa gave rise to many new states, India being the largest to adopt democracy with universal adult suffrage at its start in 1950.

Waves of democratisation. Samuel Huntington, in The Third Wave (1991), described three waves of democratisation, each followed by a reverse wave. The first long wave ran from 1828 to 1926, the second short wave from 1943 to 1962, and the third wave began in 1974 with the fall of the dictatorship in Portugal. It spread to Southern Europe, Latin America, parts of Asia and Africa, and then to Eastern Europe after the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1989 to 1991.

Contemporary period. After the end of the Cold War, some writers such as Francis Fukuyama argued that liberal democracy had triumphed as the final form of government. But in recent decades there have been signs of democratic backsliding, in which elected leaders weaken the courts, the media and opposition. Scholars use terms like electoral autocracy, illiberal democracy and hybrid regimes. Reports of organisations such as Freedom House, the Economist Intelligence Unit and the V-Dem Institute assess these trends, though their methods and rankings are debated.

New forms. Democracy has also adapted to new forms such as referendums, participatory budgeting, citizens’ assemblies, deliberative polls, and the use of digital media. These raise hopes of wider participation, and also concerns about misinformation, manipulation and polarisation.

PeriodDevelopmentKey feature
5th century BCEAthenian democracyDirect rule by male citizens; selection by lot
509 to 27 BCERoman RepublicMixed constitution; law and citizenship
1215Magna CartaRule bound by law; consent to taxation
1689English Bill of RightsParliamentary supremacy
1748Montesquieu, The Spirit of the LawsSeparation of powers
1762Rousseau, The Social ContractPopular sovereignty and general will
1776 and 1787American Declaration and ConstitutionRepresentation, federalism, written constitution
1789French Declaration of RightsLiberty, equality, fraternity
1832 to 1884British Reform ActsGradual extension of the franchise
1893 to 1928Women’s suffrage in many countriesWidening of citizenship
1948Universal Declaration of Human RightsInternational recognition of the right to take part in government
1950Indian ConstitutionUniversal adult franchise in a large, poor, plural society
1974 onwardsThird waveFall of dictatorships in Southern Europe, Latin America, Eastern Europe

5. The Indian perspective

Ancient traditions of collective decision. Early India had republics called ganas or sanghas, such as the Licchavis of Vaishali, the Shakyas and the Mallas, in which assemblies took decisions by discussion and vote, as described in Buddhist texts. The Buddhist sangha itself used rules of debate, quorum and voting. Village bodies like the sabha and samiti in the Vedic period, and the village assemblies of the Chola period known from the Uttaramerur inscriptions, show a tradition of local self-government with elections by lot. However, these were limited to certain groups, and the varna and jati order restricted equality, so they cannot be called democracy in the modern sense.

Medieval and colonial experience. Under the Sultanate and Mughal rule, authority was monarchical, though traditions such as the panchayat continued in villages and Bhakti and Sufi saints preached the equality of all human beings. The British introduced representative institutions in a limited and gradual way. The Indian Councils Acts of 1861, 1892 and 1909, the Government of India Acts of 1919 and 1935 expanded the councils and the franchise, but only a small part of the people could vote, and separate electorates divided the electorate by religion and caste. The national movement used the language of democracy to demand self-rule and civil liberties.

The national movement and democratic ideas. The Indian National Congress asked for representative government and civil rights from its start in 1885. The Nehru Report (1928) listed fundamental rights and demanded dominion status with a democratic constitution, and the Karachi Resolution (1931) promised adult suffrage and civil liberties. Leaders like Gandhi, Nehru, Tilak, Gokhale, Ambedkar and Subhas Bose offered different views on democracy, but most accepted that independent India would be a democratic republic.

Gandhi. Gandhi’s idea of democracy was linked with swaraj, which means self-rule that begins with self-control. He held that true democracy cannot come from above, but from below, from the self-governing village. In his picture of the oceanic circle, the individual is the centre of a series of widening circles of villages and states, with power moving upward from the base. He gave great importance to non-violence, means and ends, and the moral education of citizens, and he said that the weakest should have the same opportunity as the strongest. He was wary of the centralised parliamentary system, which he described in Hind Swaraj (1909) in critical terms, and he preferred a decentralised order of village republics.

Ambedkar. Ambedkar’s contribution is the idea that democracy is both political and social. In his speech to the Constituent Assembly on 25 November 1949, he said that political democracy cannot last unless it has social democracy as its base, and he defined social democracy as a way of life which recognises liberty, equality and fraternity as the principles of life. He warned that India was entering a life of contradictions, with equality in politics and inequality in social and economic life, and that these must be removed soon. He also held that constitutional morality, which means respect for the constitutional methods of change, must be cultivated, since Indians were not naturally disposed to it. He warned against hero worship in politics and against the use of agitation methods like civil disobedience after the achievement of a democratic constitution, which he called the grammar of anarchy.

Nehru. Nehru was committed to parliamentary democracy, civil liberties and secularism, and he linked political democracy to economic and social change through planning. He built institutions such as the Election Commission, the Planning Commission and the universities, and he accepted the role of the opposition. In his view, democracy needs tolerance and the habit of discussion, and without economic progress, it will be hollow.

Others. M. N. Roy argued for radical democracy based on local people’s committees. Jayaprakash Narayan advocated partyless democracy and total revolution in his later years, and the decentralisation of power. Lohia spoke of the four pillars of village, district, province and centre. Vinoba Bhave and the Sarvodaya movement saw democracy as a society based on service and consensus. Tagore criticised the narrow nation and held that freedom of mind is the base of society.

The Constituent Assembly and the choice of democracy. The Assembly, with members like Rajendra Prasad, Nehru, Patel, Ambedkar, Azad and Sarojini Naidu, chose a parliamentary democracy, with universal adult franchise from the beginning, though most citizens were poor and illiterate. This was a bold decision, and sceptics, including some British observers, doubted whether it could last. The Assembly also chose federalism, an independent judiciary and a bill of rights, and the Objectives Resolution moved by Nehru in 1946 set out the main aims.

Democratic features of the Constitution.

FeatureProvision
Popular sovereigntyPreamble: We, the people of India; Republic
Universal adult franchiseArticle 326: elections on the basis of adult suffrage, now at age 18 after the 61st Amendment (1988)
Independent Election CommissionArticle 324: superintendence, direction and control of elections
Parliamentary systemArticles 74 and 75; 163 and 164: Council of Ministers responsible to the legislature
Fundamental rightsPart III, including equality, freedoms, remedies
Independent judiciary and judicial reviewArticles 32, 124, 226 and 13
FederalismSeventh Schedule; Articles 245 to 255 on legislative relations
Local self-government73rd and 74th Amendments (1992): panchayats and municipalities, Articles 243 to 243ZG
Reservation for weaker sectionsArticles 330, 332, 243D, 243T; Article 15(4) and 16(4)
Directive PrinciplesPart IV: social and economic democracy
Fundamental DutiesArticle 51A
Free press and informationArticle 19(1)(a), and the Right to Information Act (2005)
Anti-defection lawTenth Schedule (52nd Amendment, 1985) and the 91st Amendment (2003)

Working of Indian democracy. India has held general elections since 1951 to 1952, with regular and mostly peaceful transfers of power at the Centre and in the states. Voter turnout has been high, and participation by the poor and the rural people, as well as by women, has grown. The party system has moved from the dominance of the Congress to coalition politics from 1989, and later to a period of one-party majority after 2014. The Election Commission has run elections of huge scale with the use of electronic voting machines and, more recently, voter verification systems. Local bodies have brought millions of women and members of the weaker sections into public office through reservation.

Judicial protection of democracy. In Kesavananda Bharati (1973), the Supreme Court held that democracy, along with the supremacy of the Constitution, federalism, secularism and judicial review, is part of the basic structure. In Indira Gandhi v. Raj Narain (1975), free and fair elections were held to be basic to the structure. In S. R. Bommai v. Union of India (1994), the Court limited the misuse of Article 356 against state governments. In People’s Union for Civil Liberties v. Union of India (2003), it held that voters have a right to know the criminal and financial background of candidates, and in Union of India v. Association for Democratic Reforms (2002), the same principle of voters’ information was laid down. In Kihoto Hollohan (1992), the Tenth Schedule was upheld, and in Anoop Baranwal v. Union of India (2023), the Court laid down a committee-based process for appointment of Election Commissioners, though a later law altered the composition of the committee. In Association for Democratic Reforms v. Union of India (2024), the electoral bonds scheme was struck down as violating the voters’ right to information.

Challenges to Indian democracy. The main challenges are the entry of money and criminals into politics, the role of identity in voting, communal and caste tensions, weakness of internal democracy in parties, declining discussion in legislatures, concentration of power in the executive, pressure on institutions and the media, misuse of security laws, and the gap between political and social equality that Ambedkar warned about. Yet the strength of popular participation, the role of the courts and the Election Commission, the vigilance of civil society, and the regular defeat of governments by voters show the resilience of Indian democracy.

6. Merits and demerits of democracy

Merits.

  • Government by consent. In a democracy, rulers hold power because the people have chosen them. This gives the government a moral right to rule and makes obedience more willing than in a system based on force. It also gives ordinary citizens a sense of ownership of the state.
  • Peaceful change of government. Elections allow rulers to be removed without bloodshed or coup. Popper argued that the main value of democracy is that it lets us get rid of bad rulers without violence, and this has been a great gain for political stability over the long run.
  • Protection of rights and liberties. Free speech, free association and a free press are parts of democratic life. Because rulers may lose power, they have a reason to respect the rights of citizens, including those who oppose them.
  • Accountability and responsiveness. Rulers must explain and defend their actions and face the voters. Sen has shown that no famine has taken place in a functioning democracy with a free press, as governments are pressed to act on suffering.
  • Equality and dignity of citizens. Democracy treats each person as an equal in the political process, whatever his wealth or status. This is an important expression of human dignity and recognises that each citizen is capable of judgment.
  • Education and development of citizens. Mill and Dewey argued that taking part in public affairs develops the intelligence and the moral character of people. A citizen who takes part in decisions learns to think of the common good and not only of private interest.
  • Better decisions through discussion. Debate, criticism and the pooling of knowledge help to find errors and consider more views. The many together may be a better judge than the few, as Aristotle observed, and open discussion tests policies before they are applied.
  • Legitimacy and stability. Decisions reached by fair procedures, even if disliked, are more easily accepted. Democracies have, over time, shown greater capacity for adjustment to changing demands than rigid systems, and they offer ways for dissatisfied groups to seek change within the system.
  • Reduces the chances of war between democracies. The democratic peace thesis, associated with Kant’s idea of perpetual peace and later empirical studies by Michael Doyle and others, holds that established democracies rarely fight one another. The thesis is debated, but it is widely discussed.
  • Makes room for diversity. A democratic system allows different groups to organise, put forward their claims and share power. In plural societies, it provides a peaceful means for settling conflicts among communities.
  • Supports development and welfare. Many studies suggest that democracies pay attention to health, education and relief of hardship because voters demand it. Though the link with growth is debated, the link with human development is often stronger.

Demerits and criticisms.

  • Rule of the ignorant. Plato held that the many lack the knowledge to rule, as a ship should not be run by the vote of the passengers. Modern critics add that voters often have little information about issues, and so can be swayed by slogans and emotion.
  • Tyranny of the majority. Tocqueville and Mill feared that the majority could oppress the minority, and ignore dissent. Without constitutional limits, democracy can become a means to persecute those who are outvoted.
  • Role of money and powerful interests. Elections are costly, and parties may depend on large donors, which gives the rich influence over policy. Critics from the left, like Marx and Macpherson, argue that liberal democracy mainly serves the interests of the propertied class.
  • Rule of elites. Michels, in his iron law of oligarchy, argued that every organisation, including a democratic party, ends up under the control of a small group of leaders. Mosca and Pareto likewise held that a ruling minority always governs, and Schumpeter accepted that democracy is a competition between elites.
  • Short-term thinking. Governments tied to election cycles may favour popular policies that bring quick results at the cost of long-term goals, as in the case of environmental protection or public debt.
  • Demagogy and populism. Leaders may win by appealing to fear and prejudice, and by promising simple answers to complex problems. Plato and Aristotle feared that democracy can slide into rule by a demagogue. Modern populist leaders sometimes claim to speak for the real people against the elite and then weaken institutions.
  • Slowness and indecision. The need to debate, build consensus and pass laws through many bodies may delay action, especially in times of crisis. Authoritarian regimes sometimes claim greater efficiency, though the claim is disputed.
  • Corruption and criminalisation of politics. In many democracies, including India, the entry of persons with criminal cases, the misuse of public funds and vote buying have affected the quality of representation.
  • Apathy and low participation. In some countries, many citizens do not vote or take part, leaving decisions to small groups. Democracy loses meaning where citizens do not care.
  • Polarisation and manipulation of media. Competitive politics can sharpen divisions on religious, regional or ideological lines, and the spread of false news and targeted advertising on digital platforms can distort the information on which citizens decide.
  • Formal equality hides real inequality. Equal votes may exist side by side with great inequality of wealth, caste and status, so that the poor have little real power. This is the point stressed by Marxists and by Ambedkar.

7. Critical analysis

Democracy is an essentially contested concept. Thinkers have used the word for a method of choosing rulers, for a form of society and for a moral ideal, and each use has led to a different test of success. Schumpeter and Dahl made it a matter of institutions and competition, while Macpherson, Pateman and Ambedkar made it a matter of social relations and equality. A critical student should notice that many arguments about democracy are not about facts but about which meaning is chosen. The better view may be to treat the procedural features as necessary and the substantive features as the direction in which democracy should develop.

There is a tension between democracy and liberalism. Democracy stresses the rule of the many, while liberalism stresses limits on power and individual rights. They are often joined, as in liberal democracy, but they are not the same. A majority can vote to restrict liberties, and a liberal state can restrict the vote. Zakaria’s illiberal democracy and Dahl’s concern for polyarchy show that the joining of the two is an achievement which needs constant protection through courts, a free press and a culture of rights.

There is a debate between elitist and participatory views. Schumpeter and the elite theorists held that the ordinary citizen is not able or willing to take part in a sustained way, and that the realistic function of voting is to choose and remove leaders. Participatory writers such as Rousseau, Mill, Pateman and Macpherson replied that low participation is the result of unequal conditions and that the capacities of people grow through use. Experience has mixed evidence, such as the strong turnout of poor voters in India, and the use of local institutions, which suggests that participation is wider than elites assume.

Democracy is also linked with economic and social conditions. The modernisation view of Lipset argues that wealth supports democracy, but India, a poor country that has kept democracy for decades, is an important exception. Przeworski and others found that while democracies are rarely overthrown in wealthy countries, wealth does not by itself create democracy. Ambedkar’s argument is more demanding. He held that without social and economic democracy, political democracy cannot be stable, and he saw caste inequality as the main danger. This has special force in a plural and unequal society.

A present debate concerns democratic backsliding. In many countries, elected governments have narrowed the space for the media, the courts and opposition without formally ending elections. Levitsky and Ziblatt, in How Democracies Die (2018), argued that democracies today more often decline through gradual erosion of norms like mutual toleration and institutional forbearance than by sudden coups. This shows that democracy depends on habits and values as well as on written rules, which agrees with Ambedkar’s concept of constitutional morality.

Another question concerns the claim of universality. Sen argues that democracy is a universal value, in that all people may value participation and public reasoning, and that it is not merely a Western product, since traditions of discussion exist in India, China and the Islamic world. Critics respond that some forms of democracy, imposed from outside, have failed, and that each society must find its own institutional forms. The balanced position is that the core values may be common while the institutions vary.

In sum, democracy is better seen as a continuing project than a finished system. It combines a method for choosing and removing rulers with an ideal of equal citizenship, and its quality depends on institutions, social conditions and the values of the people. Its faults are real, but as Churchill is reported to have said, it remains the worst form of government except for all the others that have been tried, and the remedy for the faults is generally more and better democracy.

8. Authors and books for UGC NET

AuthorBook or workContribution to the theme
ThucydidesHistory of the Peloponnesian War (Pericles’ Funeral Oration)Early description of Athenian democracy
PlatoThe RepublicCritique of democracy as rule of the ignorant
AristotlePoliticsClassification of governments; polity
J. J. RousseauThe Social Contract (1762)Popular sovereignty; general will
MontesquieuThe Spirit of the Laws (1748)Separation of powers
Alexis de TocquevilleDemocracy in America (1835–40)Equality of conditions; tyranny of the majority
J. S. MillConsiderations on Representative Government (1861)Representative government and participation
James BryceModern Democracies (1921)Comparative study of democracies
John DeweyDemocracy and Education (1916)Democracy as a way of life
Robert MichelsPolitical Parties (1911)Iron law of oligarchy
Joseph SchumpeterCapitalism, Socialism and Democracy (1942)Competitive elitist method
Karl PopperThe Open Society and Its Enemies (1945)Democracy as removal of rulers without bloodshed
Robert DahlA Preface to Democratic Theory (1956); Polyarchy (1971); On Democracy (1998)Polyarchy and institutions
S. M. LipsetPolitical Man (1960)Social requisites of democracy
Barrington MooreSocial Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy (1966)Class origins of regimes
C. B. MacphersonThe Life and Times of Liberal Democracy (1977)Models of democracy; participation
Carole PatemanParticipation and Democratic Theory (1970)Participatory democracy
Giovanni SartoriThe Theory of Democracy Revisited (1987)Conceptual analysis
Samuel HuntingtonThe Third Wave (1991)Waves of democratisation
Francis FukuyamaThe End of History and the Last Man (1992)Triumph of liberal democracy
Fareed ZakariaThe Future of Freedom (2003)Illiberal democracy
David HeldModels of Democracy (1987)Classification of models
Amartya SenThe Argumentative Indian (2005)Democracy as public reasoning
Steven Levitsky and Daniel ZiblattHow Democracies Die (2018)Democratic backsliding
B. R. AmbedkarConstituent Assembly speech, 25 November 1949Social democracy; constitutional morality
Granville AustinThe Indian Constitution: Cornerstone of a Nation (1966)Constitution-making and democracy
Rajni KothariPolitics in India (1970)Congress system and Indian democracy

9. Practice questions

Long answer questions

  1. Define democracy and discuss its main characteristics. How far does the holding of elections make a country a democracy?
  2. Trace the evolution of democracy from the Athenian city state to the present day.
  3. Discuss the procedural and substantive meanings of democracy with reference to the views of Schumpeter, Dahl and Macpherson.
  4. Critically examine the merits and demerits of democracy. Is it the best form of government?
  5. Explain Ambedkar’s idea of social democracy and constitutional morality. How relevant are they to India today?
  6. Discuss the conditions which are necessary for the success of democracy, with reference to India.

Medium answer questions

  1. Distinguish between direct and indirect democracy.
  2. Explain the difference between liberal democracy and illiberal democracy.
  3. Write a note on Dahl’s concept of polyarchy.
  4. Discuss Gandhi’s idea of democracy and decentralised village republics.
  5. Explain Huntington’s idea of the three waves of democratisation.
  6. What is meant by the tyranny of the majority?

Short answer questions

  1. What is popular sovereignty?
  2. What is meant by the iron law of oligarchy?
  3. What is the rule of law?
  4. What is constitutional morality?
  5. What are the democratic features of the Indian Constitution?
  6. What is democratic backsliding?

Very short answer questions

  1. Who described democracy as government of the people, by the people and for the people?
  2. Which Article of the Constitution provides for adult suffrage?
  3. Who wrote Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy?
  4. Name the Greek words from which democracy is derived.
  5. Which Constitutional Amendment lowered the voting age to 18?

Objective questions

  1. The term polyarchy is associated with: (a) Schumpeter (b) Dahl (c) Sartori (d) Macpherson
  2. The Athenian assembly was known as: (a) Boule (b) Ekklesia (c) Areopagus (d) Agora
  3. Who wrote The Third Wave? (a) Fukuyama (b) Zakaria (c) Huntington (d) Lipset
  4. The iron law of oligarchy was stated by: (a) Michels (b) Pareto (c) Mosca (d) Weber
  5. Which of the following is a procedural definition of democracy? (a) Competition for the people’s vote (b) Social and economic equality (c) Mode of associated living (d) Rule by the general will
  6. Assertion (A): Elections alone do not make a country a full democracy. Reason (R): Democracy also requires the protection of rights, the rule of law and an independent judiciary. (a) Both A and R are true and R explains A (b) Both are true but R does not explain A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true
  7. In which case did the Supreme Court hold that democracy is part of the basic structure? (a) Golaknath (b) Kesavananda Bharati (c) Shankari Prasad (d) A. K. Gopalan
  8. Match: (i) Dewey (ii) Ambedkar (iii) Sen (iv) Zakaria with (a) Illiberal democracy (b) Social democracy (c) Public reasoning (d) Associated living. (a) i-d, ii-b, iii-c, iv-a (b) i-a, ii-c, iii-b, iv-d (c) i-b, ii-d, iii-a, iv-c (d) i-c, ii-a, iii-d, iv-b

Analytical prompts

  1. A country holds regular elections, but the ruling party controls the media and the courts, and arrests opposition leaders. Analyse whether it is a democracy, using the ideas of Dahl and Zakaria.
  2. A village assembly in a remote area votes to exclude a minority group from its common well. Discuss the problem with reference to majority rule, rights and Ambedkar’s social democracy.
  3. “Democracy is the worst form of government except for all the others.” Examine the statement.
  4. Compare the Athenian and the modern Indian forms of democracy, in terms of who may take part and how decisions are made.

Key takeaways

  • Democracy means rule of the people, and it is understood as a form of government, a form of state and society, and a way of life.
  • Its main features are popular sovereignty, free and fair elections, political equality, the rule of law, rights, accountability, competition among parties, and an independent judiciary and press.
  • Definitions of Lincoln, Schumpeter, Dahl, Dewey, Ambedkar and Sen differ because some stress procedure while others stress equality and public reasoning.
  • Democracy grew from Athens through Rome, Magna Carta, the Enlightenment and the revolutions to universal suffrage and the three waves of democratisation.
  • Its success depends on education, reduction of extreme inequality, social equality, independent institutions, civil society and a culture of tolerance.
  • Its merits include peaceful change, protection of rights, accountability and education of citizens, while its demerits include majority tyranny, rule of elites, the influence of money, demagogy and apathy.
  • Ambedkar held that political democracy needs social democracy and constitutional morality, and Gandhi stressed decentralisation and self-rule.
  • The Indian Constitution gives democracy a firm base through adult franchise, an Election Commission, fundamental rights, an independent judiciary and federalism, and the courts treat it as part of the basic structure.

Further reading

  1. Robert Dahl, On Democracy
  2. Robert Dahl, Polyarchy: Participation and Opposition
  3. David Held, Models of Democracy
  4. Joseph Schumpeter, Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy
  5. C. B. Macpherson, The Life and Times of Liberal Democracy
  6. Carole Pateman, Participation and Democratic Theory
  7. Giovanni Sartori, The Theory of Democracy Revisited
  8. Alexis de Tocqueville, Democracy in America
  9. J. S. Mill, Considerations on Representative Government
  10. Samuel Huntington, The Third Wave: Democratization in the Late Twentieth Century
  11. Amartya Sen, The Argumentative Indian
  12. Steven Levitsky and Daniel Ziblatt, How Democracies Die
  13. Fareed Zakaria, The Future of Freedom
  14. Adam Przeworski, Democracy and the Market
  15. John Keane, The Life and Death of Democracy
  16. Granville Austin, The Indian Constitution: Cornerstone of a Nation
  17. Rajni Kothari, Politics in India
  18. Sunil Khilnani, The Idea of India
  19. Ramachandra Guha, India After Gandhi
  20. Rajeev Bhargava and Ashok Acharya (eds.), Political Theory: An Introduction

Frequently asked questions

1. What is democracy? Democracy is a form of government and society in which power rests with the people, who choose and remove their rulers through free and fair elections, enjoy equal rights and are protected by law. It is also understood as a way of life based on equality and tolerance.

2. What is the difference between direct and representative democracy? In direct democracy, citizens themselves make the laws, as in ancient Athens. In representative democracy, citizens elect representatives who make laws and decisions on their behalf, which is the form used in large modern states such as India.

3. Why did Ambedkar say that political democracy needs social democracy? He held that one person, one vote gives political equality, but in a society of caste and economic inequality, the lower groups are denied real equality. Unless liberty, equality and fraternity become a way of life, political democracy will be in danger.

4. What is the difference between procedural and substantive democracy? Procedural democracy is defined by methods like competitive elections, a free press and the rule of law. Substantive democracy is judged by results and values, such as equality, justice and the welfare of the people. Most modern writers combine both.

5. What are the main criticisms of democracy? The main criticisms are that the majority may oppress minorities, that voters may be ignorant or misled, that money and elites dominate, that decisions are slow, and that formal equality may hide real inequality. Defenders say these are faults of working, which can be corrected within a democracy.

6. Is democracy part of the basic structure of the Indian Constitution? Yes. The Supreme Court in Kesavananda Bharati (1973) and later cases has held that democracy, free and fair elections, the supremacy of the Constitution, federalism and judicial review are parts of the basic structure that Parliament cannot destroy by amendment.

Scroll to Top