A government may have an army, a police force and a treasury, and yet it may not be accepted by the people. Another government may have very little force, and still it is obeyed by nearly all citizens. The difference between the two lies in legitimacy. Legitimacy is the quality by which a government, a law or an office is accepted as rightful, so that the people believe that it ought to be obeyed. When a regime has legitimacy, citizens pay taxes, obey the laws and accept the results of elections, even if they dislike some decisions. When a regime loses it, the people withdraw their support, and rule becomes dependent on force alone, as happened in the last days of many dictatorships.
Legitimacy is the foundation on which authority stands, and it is among the most important concepts of political theory. Questions of legitimacy are at the heart of revolutions, coups, elections, constitutional change and the relation between citizens and the state. Thinkers from Plato and Kautilya to Rousseau, Weber, Habermas and Rawls have asked what makes political rule rightful, and how a ruler can win and keep the consent of the ruled. In this note, the meaning, sources, types and theories of legitimacy are explained in simple steps, together with the Indian perspective.
1. Meaning and definitions of legitimacy
The word legitimacy comes from the Latin legitimus, which means lawful or in accordance with law. In political theory, it has a wider sense. It does not mean only that an act is permitted by law (legality), but that the right of a ruler to rule, and the duty of the people to obey, is accepted as proper and just. In this sense, legitimacy is both a belief held by the people and a moral standard by which rule can be judged.
| Scholar | Definition in brief |
|---|---|
| Max Weber | Legitimacy is the belief of the ruled in the right of the rulers to rule; every system of domination tries to establish and cultivate this belief |
| Seymour Martin Lipset | Legitimacy is the capacity of a political system to produce and maintain the belief that existing institutions are the most appropriate for the society |
| David Easton | Legitimacy is the conviction on the part of a member that it is right and proper to accept and obey the authorities and to abide by the requirements of the regime |
| Jürgen Habermas | Legitimacy means a political order’s worthiness to be recognised, resting on good reasons |
| David Beetham | Power is legitimate when it is acquired and exercised according to established rules, the rules are justified by shared beliefs, and there is evidence of consent |
| Robert Dahl | Legitimacy is the belief that existing political institutions are right and just, and so the people are willing to follow them |
| John Rawls | A political power is legitimate when it is exercised in accordance with a constitution the essentials of which all citizens as free and equal may reasonably endorse |
| Jean-Jacques Rousseau | No authority is legitimate unless it is based on covenants and on the general will of the people |
| Dolf Sternberger | Legitimacy is the foundation of such governmental power as is exercised both with a consciousness on the part of the government that it has a right to govern, and with some recognition by the governed of that right |
Weber on legitimacy. Max Weber, in Economy and Society, made legitimacy a central idea of political sociology. He argued that no system of rule is satisfied with only material or emotional grounds for obedience, such as fear or interest. Each tries to build up a belief in its legitimacy. The legitimacy, for Weber, is a matter of what the people actually believe, and so he held that the sociologist should study the beliefs without judging whether they are morally right. He named three grounds of legitimate domination: tradition, charisma and legality.
Lipset on legitimacy. Seymour Martin Lipset, in Political Man (1960), defined legitimacy as the capacity of a system to engender and maintain the belief that existing political institutions are the most appropriate ones for the society. He held that the stability of a democracy depends upon its legitimacy and its effectiveness, which means its success in meeting the needs of the people. A regime which has both is stable; a regime which has neither is likely to fall; and one which has only one of them is at risk in a crisis.
Easton on legitimacy. David Easton, in A Systems Analysis of Political Life (1965), distinguished between specific support, which is given for the decisions and performance of the government, and diffuse support, which is a general goodwill towards the system as a whole. Legitimacy belongs to diffuse support, and it is a store of goodwill that allows a system to survive periods in which it fails to satisfy the people. He described three sources of legitimacy: ideology, structure and personal qualities of the leaders.
Habermas on legitimacy. Jürgen Habermas, in Legitimation Crisis (1973) and Between Facts and Norms (1992), held that legitimacy cannot rest on belief alone, but must be able to be defended by good reasons in public discussion. A political order is legitimate when its rules could be accepted by all those affected, after free and open debate. His idea links legitimacy with deliberative democracy.
Beetham on legitimacy. David Beetham, in The Legitimation of Power (1991), argued that Weber’s definition is too dependent on belief. He said that legitimacy has three levels: legality, which means that power is acquired and exercised in conformity with established rules; justifiability, which means that the rules are justified by the shared beliefs of the society; and legitimation through actions, which means that there is evidence of consent, such as elections, public oaths and mass participation.
Rawls on legitimacy. John Rawls, in Political Liberalism (1993), put forward the “liberal principle of legitimacy”. Political power is legitimate when it is exercised in accordance with a constitution, the essentials of which all citizens, regarded as free and equal, can reasonably be expected to endorse in the light of principles and ideals acceptable to their common human reason. This is a test of public reason.
Legitimacy and the related ideas.
| Concept | Meaning | Difference from legitimacy |
|---|---|---|
| Legality | Conformity with the law | A law may be legal and still be thought unjust; legitimacy asks whether the law and the lawmaker are rightful |
| Authority | The accepted right to command | Legitimacy is the ground on which authority rests |
| Power | Ability to get one’s will done | Power may exist without legitimacy; legitimacy makes power into authority |
| Sovereignty | Supreme legal power of the state | Sovereignty is a legal claim; legitimacy is the acceptance of that claim |
| Consent | Voluntary agreement of the governed | Consent is one source of legitimacy, though not the only one |
| Legitimation | The process of gaining and maintaining legitimacy | Legitimation is the activity; legitimacy is the result |
| Effectiveness | Success of government in delivering results | Effectiveness may support legitimacy but is not the same thing |
2. Nature and characteristics of legitimacy
Legitimacy is not a thing which can be seen or touched. It lives in the minds of citizens, in their trust in institutions, and in the way they behave towards the government. Its main characteristics are as follows.
- Based on belief and acceptance. Legitimacy depends on what people believe about the right of the rulers to rule. When a majority of citizens accept the government as rightful, it is legitimate in the empirical sense, even if outsiders disagree. A newly elected government in a stable democracy, for example, is accepted by those who voted against it also, because they believe in the election as a fair method.
- Also a moral standard. Legitimacy is not only a fact of belief, but also a standard by which the beliefs themselves can be judged. A regime may be believed in because of propaganda and fear, yet we may still say that it is not rightfully legitimate. This double character, empirical and normative, makes the concept both useful and difficult.
- Gives a reason to obey. Legitimacy supplies the answer to the question why the people should obey. A citizen who accepts the government as legitimate obeys because he thinks it right to do so, and not only out of fear. This sense of duty is more stable than obedience from fear or self-interest.
- Foundation of authority. Authority is power which is accepted as rightful, and legitimacy is the quality which makes it so. Without legitimacy, authority becomes mere power. Thus Weber’s three types of authority are in fact three types of legitimacy.
- A matter of degree. No government is wholly legitimate or wholly illegitimate. Legitimacy can be high or low, and it can be different among various groups. A government may be strongly accepted in one region or community and weakly in another, as seen in the case of regions of unrest in several countries.
- Changes over time. Legitimacy can be built up slowly and lost quickly. A leader who has won it by a freedom struggle may lose it by corruption or by failure in governance, while an unpopular regime may gain it by delivering security and growth. The fall of the Shah of Iran in 1979 and of the communist governments of Eastern Europe in 1989 show how rapidly it can vanish.
- Supported by effectiveness. Lipset stressed that a government which provides jobs, security and welfare is more likely to be seen as legitimate. Yet effectiveness is not the same as legitimacy, since a legitimate government can survive a bad period, and an effective but oppressive one can still be rejected.
- Related to the shared values of society. What is legitimate depends upon the values of a particular society. In one age, hereditary kingship was accepted, in another, popular election is the accepted ground. Legitimacy is therefore linked to the culture, religion and history of the people.
- Needs public justification. Rulers do not just assume legitimacy, but try to justify their rule through ideology, law, ritual and public speech. Oaths of office, national days, constitutions and coronation ceremonies are all methods of declaring and displaying the right to rule.
- Concerns both the right to rule and the way of ruling. Legitimacy has two sides. It asks how the ruler came to power, whether by election, inheritance or force, and also how he uses power, whether justly or arbitrarily. A ruler who comes by a fair election but then violates the rights of citizens may lose legitimacy by his conduct.
- Strengthens stability and reduces costs. A legitimate system needs less force to keep order. It can face economic difficulties, defeats and disputes without falling, since the citizens give it the benefit of the doubt. For this reason, legitimacy is called the reserve of political capital.
- Linked to consent and participation. In modern thought, legitimacy is closely connected with the consent of the governed, expressed through elections, referendums, discussion and protest. Where citizens have no way to express consent or refusal, claims of legitimacy are doubtful.
- Open to challenge. Because it depends on acceptance, legitimacy can always be questioned by movements, courts, the press and citizens. A system with a healthy legitimacy allows such questioning, while a weak one fears it.
3. Sources and bases of legitimacy
A regime may base its right to rule on several grounds, which often work together.
| Source | Explanation | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Tradition and custom | The right to rule rests on long practice and inheritance | Hereditary monarchies; the authority of tribal chiefs |
| Religion and divine sanction | Rule is said to be sanctioned by God or by sacred law | Divine right of kings; theocratic states |
| Charisma | Devotion to the exceptional quality of a leader | Gandhi, Nelson Mandela, Mao in his revolutionary period |
| Law and constitution | Power is acquired and used in accordance with a legal order | Constitutional governments with written constitutions |
| Popular consent and elections | The people choose their rulers by free and fair vote | Parliamentary and presidential democracies |
| Ideology | A set of ideas that justify the rule and give it a purpose | Socialism, nationalism, liberal democracy, Islamic republic |
| Performance and welfare | The government delivers security, growth and services | East Asian states after rapid development; welfare states |
| Nationalism and anti-colonial struggle | Rule is justified as the expression of the national will or as liberation | Post-colonial governments of Asia and Africa |
| Procedure and fairness | Decisions follow fair and open procedures | Courts, legislatures, public hearings |
| International recognition | Other states and bodies accept the government | Recognition by the United Nations and other states |
4. Types of legitimacy
Weber’s three types.
| Type | Ground | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Traditional legitimacy | Belief in the sanctity of old customs and the rulers who hold power under them | Hereditary monarch, tribal chief, patriarch |
| Charismatic legitimacy | Devotion to the extraordinary personal qualities of a leader | Prophets, revolutionary leaders, national liberators |
| Legal-rational legitimacy | Belief in the validity of enacted rules and the right of office-holders to give orders under them | Modern constitutional state, bureaucracy |
Other classifications of legitimacy.
| Basis | Types | Explanation |
|---|---|---|
| Nature of the claim | Empirical (descriptive) and normative legitimacy | Empirical legitimacy is the actual belief of the people; normative legitimacy is the moral right to rule according to some standard |
| Source of acceptance | Input and output legitimacy (Fritz Scharpf) | Input legitimacy comes from participation and consent, as in elections; output legitimacy comes from effective results for the people |
| Level of support | Specific and diffuse support (Easton) | Specific support is for particular policies and leaders; diffuse support is for the regime as such |
| Object of legitimacy | Legitimacy of the regime, of the government and of the community | The system of rule, the particular rulers, and the political community may each be accepted or rejected |
| Lipset’s grouping | Legitimacy and effectiveness | A regime may be legitimate and effective, legitimate but ineffective, effective but illegitimate, or neither |
| Time of origin | Legitimacy of origin and of exercise | Whether power was gained rightly, and whether it is used rightly |
| Beetham’s three levels | Legality, justifiability, consent | Rules, shared beliefs and acts of consent |
| Sphere | Political, legal, moral, social and international legitimacy | The field in which the claim to be rightful is made |
Legitimacy and Lipset’s combinations.
| High effectiveness | Low effectiveness | |
|---|---|---|
| High legitimacy | Stable system | Likely to survive, but at risk in a long crisis |
| Low legitimacy | Unstable, may fall if effectiveness drops | Collapse likely |
5. Legitimation, delegitimation and crisis of legitimacy
Legitimation. Legitimation is the process by which rulers seek to win and maintain the belief in the rightfulness of their rule. The usual methods are the following.
- Elections and referendums, which give a public sign of consent.
- Constitutions and laws, which give rule a lawful form.
- Ideology and education, which teach the citizens the values that support the system.
- Symbols and ceremonies, such as flags, anthems, oaths and national days.
- Welfare and development, by which the government shows benefit to the people.
- Appeals to the nation, religion or tradition, which link the regime to deeper loyalties.
- Use of media and propaganda, which in authoritarian states may be used to manufacture consent.
Delegitimation. Legitimacy is lost when the government breaks its own rules, uses violence against the people, fails to meet basic needs, loses a war, or is seen as corrupt, partial or foreign. Mass protests, civil disobedience, boycotts, strikes and refusal to pay taxes are the ways by which citizens withdraw legitimacy. The Indian national movement, the Arab uprisings of 2011 and the people’s movements of 1989 in Eastern Europe are examples.
Crisis of legitimacy. Habermas used the term legitimation crisis for a situation in which the state can no longer produce the loyalty of the citizens that it requires. He held that in advanced capitalist societies the state must support the economy and also satisfy democratic demands, and when it fails at both, a crisis arises. Other writers have spoken of a crisis of legitimacy where there is a gap between what the people expect and what the government delivers, as seen in falling trust in parties, parliaments and the media in many democracies.
6. Theories of legitimacy
Divine and traditional theories. In the oldest view, a ruler is legitimate because he rules by the will of God, or because of ancient custom and descent. In Europe, the divine right of kings held that the monarch was answerable to God alone. In India, the king was often described as having a divine origin, though he was also bound by dharma. These theories lost force as the belief grew that the right to rule must come from the people.
Social contract theory. The contract thinkers held that legitimate government arises from the agreement of the people.
- Hobbes. In Leviathan, he held that the people, to escape the fear of the state of nature, agree to obey a sovereign. Legitimacy lasts so long as the sovereign protects them.
- Locke. In Two Treatises of Government, he held that government is a trust, and is legitimate only when it protects life, liberty and property and has the consent of the majority. A government which breaks the trust loses legitimacy, and the people may resist and replace it.
- Rousseau. In The Social Contract, he held that legitimate authority rests on the general will, and that “man is born free, and everywhere he is in chains”. Only a government which expresses the general will has a right to be obeyed.
- Kant and Rawls. Kant used the contract as a test: a law is just if the people could have agreed to it. Rawls developed this in A Theory of Justice (1971), and in Political Liberalism he held that legitimacy requires principles which free and equal citizens can reasonably accept.
Weber’s theory. Weber held that legitimacy is a belief held by the people, and that it rests on tradition, charisma or legality. His theory is descriptive, which means that it tells what people believe, without a standard of what ought to be believed. It has been the most influential in political sociology, and it draws attention to the fact that even the most powerful rulers need a belief in their rightfulness.
Lipset’s theory of stability. Lipset connected legitimacy with the stability of democracy. He held that the more successful a country is in economic development, the greater the chances of a stable democracy, because economic success increases the effectiveness and the legitimacy of the system. He added that the conflict of church and state, the integration of the workers and the unity of the elites also matter.
Easton’s systems theory. Easton saw the political system as one that receives demands and support from the environment and produces decisions. Diffuse support, or legitimacy, is the reserve which allows the system to survive when specific outputs fail to satisfy. He held that legitimacy can be built up by socialisation of the young into the values of the system.
Beetham’s three-dimensional theory. Beetham said that power is legitimate when three conditions are met: it conforms to established rules, the rules are justifiable by reference to beliefs shared by rulers and ruled, and there is evidence of consent by the subordinate to the relation of power. This theory combines the legal, moral and empirical sides of legitimacy, and allows the study of different systems, from monarchies to democracies.
Habermas and deliberative theory. Habermas argued that in modern societies, religion and tradition can no longer supply legitimacy, and the only source left is the reasoned agreement of citizens. Legitimate law is the law that could be accepted by all affected in a discourse free from force and deceit. In Between Facts and Norms, he linked legitimacy with the rule of law and with a vigorous public sphere.
Rawls and public reason. In his theory, the exercise of political power is proper only when it is justified by reasons that all citizens can accept, whatever their religions and philosophies. This idea of public reason is meant for societies with many beliefs, where a single comprehensive doctrine cannot be imposed.
Marxist and Gramscian theory. Marxists argue that in class societies, the state serves the interest of the ruling class, and legitimacy is produced by ideology which makes class rule look natural. Antonio Gramsci explained this by the concept of hegemony, in which the ruling class secures the consent of the others through the culture, the school, the church and the media, and thus rules by consent as well as by coercion. The critical question, in this theory, is whose interests are served by what is called legitimate.
Decisionist theory of Carl Schmitt. Schmitt, in Legality and Legitimacy (1932), argued that legality, which is the following of rules, cannot by itself ground a political order, since the rules have to rest on a prior decision of the sovereign. He opposed legality and legitimacy, and held that in a time of crisis the sovereign is the one who decides on the exception. His ideas are controversial, since they were used by opponents of the Weimar democracy, but they bring out the tension between rule and decision.
Feminist and post-colonial critiques. Feminist thinkers such as Carole Pateman, in The Sexual Contract (1988), argue that the classical contract was also a contract among men that left out women, and so the claim of legitimacy based on consent was incomplete. Post-colonial writers argue that colonial rule claimed legitimacy through a civilising mission, and that the consent of the colonised was never sought.
Theory of output and input legitimacy. Fritz Scharpf, in studies of the European Union, distinguished input legitimacy, which is government by the people through participation, from output legitimacy, which is government for the people through effective solutions. This is useful for studying international bodies, which may be strong on one and weak on the other.
| Theory | Chief thinkers | Ground of legitimacy | Main idea |
|---|---|---|---|
| Divine and traditional | Filmer, Aquinas | God, custom | Ruler is rightful by divine will or inheritance |
| Social contract | Hobbes, Locke, Rousseau, Rawls | Agreement of the people | Government is a result of consent |
| Sociological | Weber | Belief of the people | Traditional, charismatic and legal-rational legitimacy |
| Stability and performance | Lipset | Legitimacy and effectiveness | Economic success supports democracy |
| Systems | Easton | Diffuse support | Legitimacy as a store of goodwill |
| Three-dimensional | Beetham | Rules, beliefs, consent | Legitimacy has legal, moral and empirical sides |
| Deliberative | Habermas | Reasoned public discussion | Law is legitimate if all affected could accept it |
| Public reason | Rawls | Reasons all can accept | Power must be justified to free and equal citizens |
| Marxist | Marx, Gramsci | Ideology and hegemony | Legitimacy hides class rule |
| Decisionist | Schmitt | Sovereign decision | Legality depends on a prior political decision |
| Input and output | Scharpf | Participation and results | Two sources of legitimacy |
7. The Indian perspective on legitimacy
Dharma as the source of legitimacy. In ancient India, the right of the king to rule rested on his observance of dharma. The ruler was legitimate so long as he protected the people, administered justice and respected the sacred law and the custom of the land. The Mahabharata and the Manusmriti describe the king as the servant of dharma, and the Shanti Parva says that a king who does not protect his subjects, but oppresses them, should be removed, in some passages even compared to a mad dog. This gives a moral test of legitimacy based on the welfare of the people.
The story of the first king. The Mahabharata and the Buddhist Aggañña Sutta both tell of a time when people lived without a ruler, and suffered from disorder. They then chose or appointed a king to give protection, and promised him a share of their produce. Scholars have compared this with the contract theory of the West, and have noted that legitimacy here rests on service to the people and on agreement.
Kautilya on legitimacy. In the Arthashastra, Kautilya treated the king’s right to rule as supported by his qualities and by the happiness of the subjects. He wrote that in the happiness of his subjects lies the happiness of the king, and that what pleases the subjects is the good of the king. He advised the king to win the loyalty of the people through justice, welfare, a good administration and the honour of the elites, and to avoid the anger of the people, which he considered a great danger to the state. He thus recognised that legitimacy affects the survival of the ruler, though he also accepted the use of danda and of secret agents when needed.
Ashoka and the dhamma. Emperor Ashoka, after the Kalinga war, based his rule on the moral idea of dhamma, and declared in his edicts that all men are his children and that he worked for their welfare in this world and the next. He appointed dhamma-mahamatras to look after the welfare of the people. This was an attempt to place legitimacy on moral and welfare grounds, rather than conquest alone.
Medieval legitimacy. Sultans and Mughal emperors sought legitimacy through the recognition of the caliph, through the claim to protect religion and justice, and through public ceremonies and the support of the nobles. Akbar built it on the broad principle of sulh-i-kul and the Din-i-Ilahi, and on the inclusion of the Rajputs in the administration. The idea of the “circle of justice” was also used to say that the ruler’s strength lay in his army and wealth, which came from the people, and so in justice to them.
Colonial rule and the nationalist challenge. The British justified their rule by the claims of law and order, a civilising mission and the benefits of modern administration. The Indian leaders, such as Dadabhai Naoroji and R. C. Dutt, argued that the rule drained the wealth of India and lacked the consent of the people. The Indian National Congress, in the early years, asked for representation, and later for purna swaraj in 1929. Gandhi’s non-cooperation, based on the idea that no government can rule without the cooperation of the ruled, is a practical withdrawal of legitimacy.
Gandhi on legitimacy. Gandhi held that an unjust law has no moral claim, and that the citizen has the duty to refuse obedience to it by non-violent means. In Hind Swaraj and in his speeches in the Non-Cooperation and Civil Disobedience movements, he taught that a government’s strength lies in the cooperation of the governed. His own moral authority, as a charismatic leader who lived by the ideas he preached, was a source of legitimacy for the national movement.
Ambedkar and constitutional legitimacy. B. R. Ambedkar held that the legitimacy of the new Indian state should rest on a Constitution based on liberty, equality and fraternity, and on democratic methods. He insisted that political democracy must be joined with social and economic democracy, since otherwise the system would lack the moral foundation. He also criticised the legitimacy of caste and scriptural authority, as they were against equality, and urged the use of reason and constitutional methods in place of hero-worship.
The Constitution of India and legitimacy.
- Popular sovereignty. The Preamble opens with “We, the people of India”, and declares that the people adopt, enact and give to themselves the Constitution. The Constitution thus claims the consent of the people as its source.
- Universal adult franchise. Article 326 gives every adult citizen the right to vote, and regular free and fair elections conducted by the Election Commission are the chief means of renewing the legitimacy of governments.
- Rule of law and fundamental rights. Articles 14, 19 and 21 and the power of the courts to review laws make power accountable to rules, and give a basis of legitimacy by procedure.
- Separation of powers and federalism. The division of power between the Union and States and among the organs of government prevents a concentration which would be seen as illegitimate.
- Directive Principles. Part IV sets goals of social and economic welfare, which give a basis of legitimacy by performance and justice.
- Judicial review and basic structure. The Supreme Court, in Kesavananda Bharati (1973), held that Parliament cannot alter the basic structure, so that even the majority has limits.
- Local self-government. The 73rd and 74th Amendments take legitimacy to the grassroots, by giving panchayats and municipalities constitutional status.
Legitimacy in the political experience of India.
- The founding period. The freedom struggle, the Constituent Assembly and the first general election of 1951–52 gave the new state a strong legitimacy, based on charisma, nationalism and popular participation.
- The Emergency (1975–77). The suspension of fundamental rights and press freedom caused a crisis of legitimacy, and the electorate removed the government in the 1977 election. This showed that the Indian voters can withdraw legitimacy through the ballot.
- Challenges of the 1970s and the JP movement. Jayaprakash Narayan’s call for “total revolution” questioned the moral right of the government after the Allahabad High Court judgment of 1975 against Indira Gandhi’s election.
- Regional and identity movements. Movements in Punjab, Kashmir, the North-East and in regions of Left-wing extremism show that the legitimacy of the state is not equally accepted among all groups, and that distribution of resources and rights is a source of dispute.
- Coalition politics and the rise of new groups. From the 1990s, the entry of backward classes, Dalits and regional parties into power has widened the social base of legitimacy.
- Institutions and public trust. The standing of the Election Commission, the courts, the press and other bodies affects public trust, and debates on electoral reform, electoral bonds, and the independence of institutions show that legitimacy has to be constantly renewed.
8. Importance and limitations of the concept of legitimacy
Importance.
- Basis of stable government. A legitimate government is obeyed willingly, and it can govern with less force. The stability of democratic systems is much dependent upon the belief of citizens that they are lawful and fair.
- Turns power into authority. Legitimacy is what changes mere power into rightful authority. It therefore explains the difference between a government and a gang, and between a tax and a theft.
- Helps to explain obedience and revolt. The concept shows why people usually obey the law, and why they may suddenly rebel when the belief in the regime fails. It is useful for the study of revolutions, coups and mass movements.
- Standard for judging regimes. In its normative sense, legitimacy allows us to ask whether a regime deserves support, and so is the basis of criticism of dictatorships, occupations and unjust laws.
- Supports democracy. The idea that rule is rightful only with the consent of the people gives a ground for elections, representation, the rule of law and the protection of rights.
- Helps peaceful transfer of power. Where all accept the rules of succession, such as elections, the change of governments takes place without violence. Acceptance of the outcome by the losers is a sign of legitimacy.
- Gives resilience in a crisis. A government with a store of legitimacy can face economic hardship, war or scandal, since citizens give it time. This gives room for reform without collapse.
- Strengthens implementation of policy. Laws and policies are carried out more easily when people believe in the right of the government to make them, which reduces the cost of enforcement and corruption.
- Important in international relations. Recognition by other states, adherence to international law and the legitimacy of international bodies such as the United Nations affect war, peace and diplomacy.
- Links politics with morality. The concept reminds that political power is not only a matter of force, but also of justice and public reason, and so joins political theory with ethics.
Limitations and difficulties of the concept.
- Two meanings. Legitimacy is used in an empirical sense, meaning belief, and in a normative sense, meaning moral rightness, and writers often mix them. This produces confusion in argument.
- Difficulty of measurement. Belief in legitimacy is hard to measure. Surveys of trust and of satisfaction with democracy give only partial evidence, and people may express support out of fear.
- Belief may be manufactured. If legitimacy is only belief, then a regime which controls schools and media can create legitimacy by propaganda. Critics such as Habermas and Beetham therefore argue that beliefs must be tested for the reasons behind them.
- Depends on culture and time. The grounds accepted as legitimate change from society to society and age to age, so there is no single standard that applies to all. This makes comparison difficult.
- Confusion with legality and effectiveness. Many treat legality or good performance as the same as legitimacy. A law may be legal and unjust, and a regime may be effective and still resented.
- Majority and minority problem. A government may be legitimate to the majority and illegitimate to a minority. Whose belief counts is a difficult question, especially in plural and divided societies.
- Tendency to support the status quo. Marxists and critical theorists argue that the study of legitimacy may explain how existing arrangements are justified, and thus help to hide domination by classes, castes or men.
- Western bias in theory. Most of the theories come from Western experience and may not fit societies where religion, caste or kinship give shape to political rule.
- Not a guide to action in a crisis. The concept does not say clearly when disobedience or revolution is justified, or what to do when two sources of legitimacy conflict, as when a lawful government acts unjustly.
- Global and digital rule. International bodies, global firms and digital platforms exercise much rule-making power, and it is difficult to find the consent of those affected, so the idea needs new development.
9. Critical analysis
The first difficulty in the study of legitimacy is that the word has two meanings, and the two do not always agree. In the descriptive sense of Weber, a regime is legitimate if its subjects believe it to be so. In the normative sense of Rawls and Habermas, a regime is legitimate if it deserves to be believed in, which means that it satisfies some standard of justice or reasoned agreement. If the first sense alone is used, a regime that has silenced all critics and filled the schools with its own teaching would be called legitimate, which seems wrong. If only the second sense is used, then the researcher has to decide what is just, and the study loses its neutrality. Beetham tried to solve this by joining rules, beliefs and consent, but even this does not settle who decides what the shared beliefs are.
The second difficulty is the relation between legitimacy and legality. In a constitutional state, legality is a main source of legitimacy, since laws are made and applied by recognised procedure. Yet history shows that legal orders may be unjust, as in apartheid South Africa or in colonial rule, and that illegal acts may be legitimate, as in the civil disobedience of Gandhi and Martin Luther King Jr. Carl Schmitt used this gap to argue that legality cannot ground itself, while liberal writers answer that the problem is solved by rights and by public reason. The Indian experience of the Emergency, in which actions were taken under the forms of law yet were widely felt to lack legitimacy, illustrates the problem.
A third question concerns the role of performance. Lipset and the modernisation school held that economic growth and welfare strengthen legitimacy. Later studies have shown that the relation is not simple. Some authoritarian regimes, such as those of East Asia, secured support by rapid growth, but became vulnerable when growth slowed or when a new, educated middle class asked for rights. On the other hand, some poor democracies, such as India, have survived for long, because the belief in the electoral process and in the Constitution has been independent of immediate results. This suggests that procedural legitimacy and performance legitimacy are different sources and that each can compensate for the other.
A fourth point is the position of plural societies. Where a state contains many communities of language, religion and caste, legitimacy has to be won from each of them, and a majority principle alone may not be accepted by minorities. The Indian model of federalism, reservation, minority rights and a secular constitution is an effort to build a legitimacy that all groups can share. Yet movements in Kashmir, the North-East and elsewhere show that the effort is incomplete, and that questions of recognition and fair share affect the acceptance of the state.
Finally, the critical theorists remind us that what passes for legitimacy may be the result of ideology and habit. Gramsci and Foucault show that consent is often produced by the culture and the institutions of daily life, and feminist and post-colonial writers show that some groups were left out of the original agreement. A fair study of legitimacy therefore needs to ask whose belief is counted, who is given a voice in justifying the rules, and what interests are served by the order. A healthy legitimacy is one that can survive open criticism and remains open to reform.
10. Authors and books for UGC NET
| Author | Book or work | Main contribution on legitimacy |
|---|---|---|
| Max Weber | Economy and Society; “Politics as a Vocation” (1919) | Three types of legitimate domination; legitimacy as belief |
| S. M. Lipset | Political Man (1960) | Legitimacy and effectiveness in the stability of democracy |
| David Easton | A Systems Analysis of Political Life (1965) | Diffuse and specific support |
| Jürgen Habermas | Legitimation Crisis (1973); Between Facts and Norms (1992) | Legitimation crisis; deliberative legitimacy |
| David Beetham | The Legitimation of Power (1991) | Legality, justifiability and consent |
| John Rawls | Political Liberalism (1993) | Liberal principle of legitimacy and public reason |
| Carl Schmitt | Legality and Legitimacy (1932) | Contrast between legality and legitimacy |
| Antonio Gramsci | Prison Notebooks | Hegemony and consent |
| Thomas Hobbes | Leviathan (1651) | Legitimacy from contract and protection |
| John Locke | Two Treatises of Government (1689) | Government by consent and trust |
| J.-J. Rousseau | The Social Contract (1762) | General will as the basis of legitimacy |
| Fritz Scharpf | Governing in Europe (1999) | Input and output legitimacy |
| Carole Pateman | The Sexual Contract (1988) | Feminist critique of contract legitimacy |
| Rodney Barker | Political Legitimacy and the State (1990) | Legitimation as a political activity of rulers |
| Kautilya | Arthashastra | Welfare of the subjects and the stability of rule |
| M. K. Gandhi | Hind Swaraj (1909) | Non-cooperation as withdrawal of legitimacy |
| B. R. Ambedkar | Speech in the Constituent Assembly (25 Nov 1949) | Constitutional morality and social democracy |
| Rajni Kothari | Politics in India (1970) | State, institutions and legitimacy in India |
| Partha Chatterjee | The Politics of the Governed (2004) | Political society and the state in India |
11. Practice questions
Long answer questions
- Define legitimacy and discuss its meaning, nature and characteristics. How does it differ from legality and authority?
- Explain the sources and types of legitimacy with reference to Max Weber, Lipset and Beetham.
- Discuss the contract, sociological, deliberative and Marxist theories of legitimacy.
- Explain the Indian perspective on legitimacy with reference to dharma, Kautilya, Gandhi, Ambedkar and the Constitution.
- What is a crisis of legitimacy? Discuss with examples.
Medium answer questions
- Distinguish between input and output legitimacy.
- Explain Easton’s idea of diffuse and specific support.
- Describe Habermas’s idea of legitimation crisis.
- Explain Rawls’s liberal principle of legitimacy.
- Write a note on Lipset’s views on legitimacy and effectiveness.
- Discuss how elections give legitimacy to a government.
Short answer questions
- Define legitimacy in the words of Weber.
- What is legitimation?
- What is meant by empirical and normative legitimacy?
- What is the difference between legality and legitimacy?
- What is charismatic legitimacy?
Very short answer questions
- Who wrote The Legitimation of Power?
- Name the three levels of legitimacy given by Beetham.
- Who wrote Legitimation Crisis?
- Which Latin word is the root of legitimacy?
- Which article of the Constitution of India provides for adult franchise?
Objective questions
- The belief of the ruled in the right of the rulers to rule is called (a) sovereignty (b) legitimacy (c) legality (d) coercion.
- The author of Political Man is (a) Lipset (b) Easton (c) Dahl (d) Almond.
- Diffuse support is a concept of (a) Easton (b) Weber (c) Rawls (d) Schmitt.
- Legality and Legitimacy was written by (a) Habermas (b) Carl Schmitt (c) Beetham (d) Gramsci.
- Legitimacy based on the personal qualities of a leader is (a) legal-rational (b) traditional (c) charismatic (d) procedural.
- Input legitimacy refers to (a) results (b) participation and consent (c) force (d) tradition.
- The idea of hegemony is associated with (a) Gramsci (b) Hobbes (c) Locke (d) Bentham.
- The Preamble of the Indian Constitution begins with (a) “In the name of God” (b) “We, the people of India” (c) “The Union of India” (d) “The President of India”.
Analytical prompts
- Can a government be legal but not legitimate? Discuss with examples.
- Does economic growth alone give a regime legitimacy?
- How far did the Emergency of 1975–77 and the 1977 election show the importance of legitimacy in India?
- Is legitimacy a matter of belief or of reason? Discuss with reference to Weber and Habermas.
Key takeaways
- Legitimacy is the acceptance of a government, law or office as rightful, and it turns power into authority.
- It has an empirical side, which is belief, and a normative side, which is moral standard.
- Legitimacy is different from legality, power, authority and effectiveness, though connected with each.
- Its sources include tradition, religion, charisma, law, consent, ideology, performance and fair procedure.
- Weber named traditional, charismatic and legal-rational legitimacy; Beetham named legality, justifiability and consent.
- Easton’s diffuse support, Lipset’s legitimacy and effectiveness, and Habermas’s legitimation crisis are important ideas.
- In India, legitimacy has rested on dharma and welfare, the freedom struggle, the Constitution and regular elections.
- Legitimacy is a matter of degree, can be lost, and must be renewed by justice, participation and accountability.
Twenty books for further reading
- Max Weber, Economy and Society
- David Beetham, The Legitimation of Power
- S. M. Lipset, Political Man
- David Easton, A Systems Analysis of Political Life
- Jürgen Habermas, Legitimation Crisis
- Jürgen Habermas, Between Facts and Norms
- John Rawls, Political Liberalism
- Carl Schmitt, Legality and Legitimacy
- Rodney Barker, Political Legitimacy and the State
- Thomas Hobbes, Leviathan
- John Locke, Two Treatises of Government
- J.-J. Rousseau, The Social Contract
- Antonio Gramsci, Selections from the Prison Notebooks
- Carole Pateman, The Sexual Contract
- Kautilya, The Arthashastra (trans. R. P. Kangle)
- M. K. Gandhi, Hind Swaraj
- B. R. Ambedkar, Annihilation of Caste
- Rajni Kothari, Politics in India
- Rajeev Bhargava and Ashok Acharya (eds.), Political Theory: An Introduction
- Andrew Heywood, Politics
Frequently asked questions
What is legitimacy in political science? Legitimacy is the quality by which a government, law or office is accepted as rightful, so that people believe that they ought to obey it.
What is the difference between legitimacy and legality? Legality means conformity with the law, while legitimacy means that the rule itself is accepted as rightful and just. A law may be legal and yet be thought unjust.
What are Weber’s three types of legitimacy? They are traditional legitimacy, based on custom; charismatic legitimacy, based on the personal qualities of a leader; and legal-rational legitimacy, based on law and rules.
What is a legitimation crisis? It is a situation in which the state cannot produce the loyalty and support it needs from its citizens, as described by Habermas, and the people begin to doubt the right of the government to rule.
How does a government lose legitimacy? By breaking its own laws, using violence against the people, failing to meet basic needs, corruption, defeat in war, or the denial of rights and fair elections.
How is legitimacy related to authority and power? Power is the ability to make others obey, authority is power accepted as rightful, and legitimacy is the ground of that acceptance.
