When India became independent in 1947, many observers doubted that a democracy could survive in a country that was poor, largely illiterate, newly partitioned and divided by religion, language, caste and region. Democracy, they thought, needed prosperity, education and a common culture, and India had none of these in sufficient measure. Seventy-odd years later, India has held regular elections for the Union and the States, has seen many peaceful changes of government, and has kept together hundreds of millions of people of different faiths and tongues under one constitutional order. This experience has made India one of the most important cases in the study of democracy, and one that challenges many assumptions of political theory about the conditions under which democracy can last.
The Indian experience is also a story of strain and difficulty. The same diversity that is a source of richness has also led to communal violence, caste oppression, regional movements and conflicts over language and religion. The Constitution and the political system have responded by a mixture of devices: a federal structure, linguistic states, a secular state of principled distance from religions, reservation for historically excluded groups, protection for minorities, local self-government, a competitive party system and an independent judiciary. How well these arrangements work, what theories explain them and what challenges they face are the main questions of this topic. Understanding them requires a knowledge of the theory of pluralism, of the models of democracy and of the minority-rights debates, and it also requires attention to the actual history, institutions and social forces of India. The study of democracy in a plural society, with India as its main example, thus joins theory to practice.
1. Meaning of a plural society
Plural society. The term plural society was first used by J. S. Furnivall, a British colonial official and scholar, in his studies of Burma and the Netherlands Indies, in Colonial Policy and Practice (1948). He used it to describe a society in which different ethnic groups live side by side, meet only in the market, and have no common will or shared social life, so that economic forces alone hold them together. This was a negative description of a divided colonial society. M. G. Smith later developed the idea in the study of the Caribbean as a society made up of cultural sections with separate institutions, held together by the domination of one section over the others.
Plural society in contemporary use. In present-day political theory, the term is used more broadly and neutrally, for a society which contains several distinct groups, identified by religion, ethnicity, language, caste, race or region, with their own identities and often their own institutions. Arend Lijphart used the term plural societies for deeply divided societies in which segments are organised into separate political parties, interest groups and media, and in which political life is divided along group lines, as in the Netherlands before the 1960s, Belgium and Lebanon. A plural society in this sense is not necessarily unstable, but it faces the question of how to take decisions in a way that all groups regard as fair.
Cleavages and their types. Plural societies are marked by social cleavages, which are lasting divisions between groups. Cross-cutting cleavages, in which people who are divided on one ground are united on another, such as a person who shares a religion with some and a language with others, moderate conflict. Reinforcing or overlapping cleavages, in which the same people are on the same side on religion, language, class and region, make conflict sharper. Seymour Martin Lipset and Stein Rokkan, in their study of party systems, identified such cleavages in European history, and the contrast between cross-cutting and reinforcing cleavages is basic to the study of plural societies.
Democracy in a plural society. The question is how decisions can be taken by majority rule when the majority and minority may be fixed by birth, so that the same group is always in the minority. Where identities are fixed and there is no real chance for minorities to become part of a winning majority, majority rule may become domination, and democracy may be at risk. A democratic order in a plural society needs both the equal participation of all and safeguards for groups against being permanently excluded.
| Scholar | Definition or view in brief |
|---|---|
| J. S. Furnivall | A plural society is one in which different sections of the community live side by side but separately, within the same political unit, and meet only in the market. |
| M. G. Smith | A plural society consists of cultural sections with distinct institutions, held together by the domination of one section. |
| Arend Lijphart | Plural societies are those divided by segmental cleavages into groups with separate organisations, and they need consociational arrangements to be stable. |
| Rajni Kothari | The Indian polity is a plural system in which the political process absorbs diverse groups through the Congress system and later through competitive politics. |
| Alfred Stepan, Juan Linz and Yogendra Yadav | India is a state-nation, a type of democracy that accommodates multiple cultural identities within one political order, and not a nation-state that seeks cultural homogeneity. |
| Rajeev Bhargava | India is a political community of communities, whose constitutional design rests on principled distance and recognition of group differences. |
| Amartya Sen | India has an argumentative tradition of public reasoning and heterodoxy, which supports democracy in a plural society. |
Kothari. Rajni Kothari, in Politics in India (1970), described the Indian political system as one which, by the dominance of the Congress and the competition among its factions, drew in new social groups through a process of political bargaining. He argued that India’s democratic politics modernised caste by giving it a political role, and not the other way round. He also saw that the Congress system declined, and that competitive politics took its place.
Stepan, Linz and Yadav. In Crafting State-Nations: India and Other Multinational Democracies (2011), these writers drew a distinction between the nation-state model, in which a single national identity is built on cultural homogeneity, and the state-nation model, in which the state protects and values several cultural identities and builds loyalty to the state as a political community. They argued that India is the principal example of a successful state-nation, which uses asymmetric federalism, multiple languages and secularism to hold together a diverse people, and which contrasts with states that have followed policies of assimilation.
Bhargava and Sen. Bhargava has used the idea of a community of communities, and the idea of principled distance, to describe the Indian model of accommodation, as developed in his writings on the Indian Constitution and secularism. Sen, in The Argumentative Indian, finds in the long tradition of public debate and in the presence of many sects and schools the roots of Indian democracy. These views stress different aspects, but they agree that India’s democracy is closely linked with its plurality.
2. Origins: colonial legacy, national movement and the Constituent Assembly
Pre-colonial plurality. India had long been a land of many peoples, languages, faiths and polities. Empires such as the Mauryan, Gupta, Mughal and others ruled large parts of it, but did not impose a single culture, and often allowed local customs, laws and rulers. The bhakti and Sufi movements, the Sikh and Buddhist traditions and the composite culture of cities and courts reflected a living plurality. At the same time, society was marked by the hierarchy of caste, which gave rise to deep inequalities, and by regional divisions.
Colonial rule and the politicisation of difference. British rule brought unity of administration, a common legal system and new forms of communication and education, but also classified and counted people by religion and caste in the census, and introduced separate electorates in the Indian Councils Act of 1909 for Muslims, and later extended them to others under the Communal Award of 1932. The policy of divide and rule, as nationalists described it, and the growth of communal and caste-based organisations made the question of representation of groups a major political matter. At the same time, colonial rule created the conditions for the growth of modern ideas of liberty, equality and representation among the educated Indians.
The national movement and the idea of a composite nation. The national movement, in its main current, defined the Indian nation as made up of all communities, and not as the nation of one religion or culture. The Congress, from its start in 1885, aimed to represent all communities, and its presidents included persons of different faiths. Gandhi’s leadership brought in peasants, workers, women and people of many castes, and his ideas of non-violence, sarva dharma sambhava and communal harmony shaped the movement. Nehru spoke of unity in diversity, and the Karachi Resolution of 1931 promised fundamental rights, including equality before the law and religious freedom, to all. At the same time, the movement faced the challenges of Muslim League politics, the demand for Pakistan, the claim of Ambedkar and the depressed classes for separate political safeguards, and the aspirations of tribal and regional groups, and these challenges led to the compromises of the Poona Pact of 1932 and, in the end, to Partition in 1947.
Partition and its lesson. The Partition of the country, with the migration of millions and the violence which cost hundreds of thousands of lives, left a deep mark on the makers of the Constitution. They saw the danger of identity politics based on religion, and decided to build a state in which citizenship would not depend on religion, and in which all would be treated as equal. They also saw that a high degree of centralisation was needed to hold the country together at that time, but that the diversity of the country had to be recognised in the structure of the state.
The Constituent Assembly. The Constituent Assembly, elected indirectly in 1946 and meeting from December 1946 until the Constitution was adopted on 26 November 1949, represented many groups, though it was not elected by universal franchise. Its members included Congress leaders, minority representatives, women, tribal leaders such as Jaipal Singh and members of the Scheduled Castes, with Ambedkar as the chairman of the Drafting Committee. The Assembly debated at length the questions that a plural society poses: the nature of the Union and its units, the official language, secularism and religious freedom, rights of minorities, separate electorates, reservation for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, tribal areas, and the place of the village and of local self-government.
The choices made. The Assembly’s main decisions were as follows. It adopted universal adult franchise without regard to religion, caste, sex or property, though most of the population was poor and illiterate. It gave India a federal structure with a strong Centre, which the Constitution described as a Union of States, in the words of Ambedkar, as the country was not the result of an agreement among units and the units could not secede. It rejected separate electorates and provided reservation of seats for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes in joint electorates. It chose a secular state which guarantees the freedom of religion to all and does not accept an official religion. It gave minorities cultural and educational rights in Articles 29 and 30. It accepted Hindi in Devanagari script as the official language of the Union, with English continuing for fifteen years, and later indefinitely, and recognised many other languages in the Eighth Schedule. It provided special arrangements for tribal areas in the Fifth and Sixth Schedules. It wrote into the Directive Principles the aims of social and economic justice.
Ambedkar’s closing warnings. In his speech to the Constituent Assembly on 25 November 1949, Ambedkar said that India was entering a life of contradictions, with equality in politics and inequality in social and economic life, and that if this was not removed soon, those who suffered from inequality would blow up the structure of political democracy. He urged the use of constitutional methods, warned against hero-worship in politics, and said that political democracy could not last unless it had social democracy as its base, meaning a way of life which recognises liberty, equality and fraternity. This speech states with great clarity the problem of democracy in a plural and unequal society, and has become a standard reference for later discussion.
3. Features of Indian democracy in a plural society
- Universal adult franchise from the beginning. India gave the vote to all adult citizens in 1950, without condition of property, education, sex, caste or religion, when many Western democracies had taken a century or more to do so. This put the poor, women and the lower castes on a footing of political equality at the start, and made the politics of numbers the basis of competition. The age of voting was lowered from twenty-one to eighteen by the Sixty-first Amendment in 1988.
- Parliamentary federalism with a strong Centre. The Union and the States share powers under the Seventh Schedule, with the Centre holding wider powers, particularly in times of emergency, and the States having their own legislatures and governments. This structure allows regional majorities to rule in the States, while a national government rules at the Centre, so that the minority at one level may be the majority at another.
- A secular state with equal respect for all religions. The state has no official religion and treats all faiths with equal respect, protects freedom of religion and intervenes to reform practices that violate equality, as in the abolition of untouchability and the ban on instant triple talaq. This model, called principled distance by Bhargava, differs from both strict separation and the establishment of a religion.
- Constitutional protection of rights and minorities. Fundamental rights guarantee equality, freedom and cultural and educational rights, and are enforceable through the Supreme Court and High Courts under Articles 32 and 226. The rights of minorities are especially protected under Articles 29 and 30.
- Compensatory discrimination for historically excluded groups. Reservation in legislatures, education and public employment for Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Other Backward Classes, and from 2019 for economically weaker sections, seeks to correct the effects of caste and tribal disadvantage. It is a distinctive Indian response to a hierarchy that was not simply a matter of cultural difference.
- Accommodation of linguistic diversity. The reorganisation of States on linguistic lines, the recognition of twenty-two languages, the use of both Hindi and English for official purposes and the three-language formula in education show the effort to give every major language a place in public life.
- Asymmetric arrangements for special regions. The Sixth Schedule for tribal areas of the north-east, Article 371 provisions for several States, and, until 2019, Article 370 for Jammu and Kashmir, gave different degrees of autonomy to different regions according to their history and circumstances. The idea that the same rules need not apply to all units is called asymmetric federalism.
- Multi-level democracy with local self-government. The Seventy-third and Seventy-fourth Amendments created a third tier of elected panchayats and municipalities, with reservation for Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and women, so that the democratic process reaches the village and the ward.
- Competitive party system with regional and social parties. India has a large number of parties, national, regional and caste-based, and a pattern of coalition governments from 1989 to 2014, in which regional parties had a significant place. This allows many social groups to find a political voice, though it also encourages identity-based mobilisation.
- Independent institutions. The Election Commission, Supreme Court, Comptroller and Auditor General and other bodies are meant to function without partisan control. The Election Commission has managed elections for an electorate that has grown to more than ninety crore voters, and the Court has developed the doctrine of the basic structure.
- A vigorous civil society and media. A large number of associations, movements, non-governmental organisations, trade unions and newspapers and television channels, in many languages, give a public sphere in which different groups express and contest their views. Movements such as those for the right to information, forest rights and women’s rights have changed laws and policies.
- Democracy as a vehicle of social change. In India, the democratic process has been an instrument by which groups at the bottom of the social order have entered politics, a process which Yogendra Yadav calls the democratic upsurge. High turnout among the poor, women and weaker sections, compared with the better-off, is a distinctive feature of Indian elections.
- Unity in diversity as a political principle. The state does not seek a single cultural identity. India’s national symbols and policies emphasise the many languages, faiths and regions as part of the nation, and national identity is based on the Constitution and a shared political life.
4. Devices of accommodation in the Indian Constitution
| Device | Main provisions | What it accommodates |
|---|---|---|
| Federalism | Articles 1 to 4; Seventh Schedule; Articles 245 to 263 | Regional and linguistic communities |
| Linguistic reorganisation | States Reorganisation Act, 1956; later reorganisations | Language groups |
| Official language policy | Articles 343 to 351; Eighth Schedule; Official Languages Act, 1963 | Hindi and non-Hindi speakers |
| Secularism and religious freedom | Preamble; Articles 25 to 28 | Religious communities |
| Minority rights | Articles 29, 30, 350A, 350B | Religious and linguistic minorities |
| Reservation | Articles 15(4), 15(5), 16(4), 330, 332, 243D, 243T | Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, backward classes, women |
| Tribal autonomy | Fifth and Sixth Schedules; PESA; Forest Rights Act | Scheduled Tribes |
| Special provisions for regions | Articles 371 to 371J | Particular States |
| Local self-government | Articles 243 to 243ZG | Rural and urban communities |
| Independent institutions | Articles 124, 148, 324 | All citizens |
Federalism and regional accommodation. The Constitution describes India as a Union of States, with a strong Centre, to protect unity, but the States are not mere administrative units. They have constitutional status, their own legislatures and a share of power, and their boundaries have been reorganised to reflect language and culture. The Supreme Court, in S. R. Bommai v. Union of India (1994), held that federalism is a part of the basic structure, and limited the use of Article 356 to dismiss State governments. In State of West Bengal v. Union of India (1963) the Court spoke of the Union as one with a strong Centre, but the later trend, along with the rise of regional parties and coalition governments in the 1990s, strengthened the position of States. The Goods and Services Tax Council, formed in 2017, is an example of cooperative federalism, in which the Union and States decide together, though some States raise concerns about their fiscal autonomy. Scholars such as Stepan, Linz and Yadav call this a holding-together federalism, in which power is devolved to keep a multinational democracy united, in contrast to a coming-together federalism in which previously independent units form a union.
Linguistic reorganisation. The Constituent Assembly was at first cautious about language-based States, after Partition, and the Dar Commission (1948) and the JVP Committee (1949) advised against it. The death of Potti Sriramulu after a fast in 1952, in support of a separate Andhra State, led to the formation of Andhra in 1953, and the States Reorganisation Commission (1953-55) recommended the reorganisation of States on a mainly linguistic basis. The States Reorganisation Act, 1956, formed fourteen States and six Union territories. Later, Bombay was divided into Maharashtra and Gujarat in 1960, Punjab into Punjab and Haryana in 1966, and States such as Nagaland, Meghalaya, Mizoram, Chhattisgarh, Uttarakhand, Jharkhand and Telangana were created. Contrary to the fear that language-based States would encourage separatism, the reorganisation, by satisfying regional aspirations, is widely seen as having strengthened national unity.
Language policy. The question of the national language was one of the most contested in the Assembly, ending in the Munshi-Ayyangar formula, which made Hindi in Devanagari script the official language of the Union, with English to continue for fifteen years. The anti-Hindi agitations, especially in Tamil Nadu in 1965, led to the Official Languages (Amendment) Act of 1967, under which English remains in use as long as any non-Hindi State wishes it. The three-language formula in education, adopted in 1968, aims to teach Hindi, English and a regional language, although it has been unevenly applied. The Eighth Schedule has grown from fourteen languages to twenty-two, with recent additions of Bodo, Dogri, Maithili and Santhali in 2003, and Konkani, Manipuri and Nepali in 1992.
Secularism and religious freedom. Articles 25 to 28 guarantee freedom of conscience and the free practice and propagation of religion, equal treatment of religious denominations in managing their affairs, freedom from taxes for promotion of a religion, and freedom from religious instruction in state-funded institutions. The words secular and socialist were added to the Preamble by the Forty-second Amendment in 1976. The Supreme Court in Bommai (1994) held secularism to be a part of the basic structure, and in earlier cases such as Ratilal Panachand Gandhi v. State of Bombay (1954) and Shirur Mutt (1954) it drew a distinction between essential religious practices, which are protected, and secular activities associated with religion, which the state may regulate. The Essential Religious Practices test has since been applied in many cases, such as that on Sabarimala (2018).
Reservation. Reservation of seats in Parliament and State Legislatures for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Articles 330 and 332), originally for ten years and extended by amendments, reservation in jobs and educational institutions under Articles 15(4), 15(5) and 16(4), and in local bodies for Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, OBCs and women, form the large structure of group representation in India. Indra Sawhney v. Union of India (1992) held that reservation for OBCs is valid, but limited the total to fifty per cent in general and excluded the creamy layer. The Constitution (One Hundred and Third Amendment) Act, 2019, added reservation for economically weaker sections, which the Court upheld by a majority in Janhit Abhiyan v. Union of India (2022). The Constitution (One Hundred and Sixth Amendment) Act, 2023, provides a one-third reservation for women in the Lok Sabha and State Legislative Assemblies, to take effect after delimitation. Supporters see these measures as necessary for substantive equality, while critics argue that they benefit a few within each group, that they may harden caste identities, and that the demand for reservation by new groups, such as the Jats, Patidars and Marathas, shows the political pressure involved. In State of Punjab v. Davinder Singh (2024), a seven-judge bench held that States may make sub-classifications within Scheduled Castes for reservation, an important recent ruling on how the benefit is distributed.
Federal-provincial accommodation of tribal and border communities. For tribal groups in the north-east, the Sixth Schedule’s autonomous councils, accords such as the Mizo Accord of 1986 which ended an insurgency, and special provisions in Articles 371A for Nagaland and 371G for Mizoram, show how political negotiation has been used to bring regions into the democratic framework. For the central tribal belt, the Fifth Schedule, PESA and the Forest Rights Act give some protection to land and self-rule, although implementation is weak and conflicts over mining and displacement have persisted.
5. Phases in the working of democracy
| Period | Main features |
|---|---|
| 1947 to 1967 | Congress dominance; nation-building; linguistic States; planning |
| 1967 to 1977 | Decline of Congress dominance; non-Congress State governments; split in Congress; centralisation; Emergency |
| 1977 to 1989 | Janata experiment; Congress return; Punjab, Assam and north-east problems; Mandal and Mandir politics begin |
| 1989 to 2014 | Coalition governments; rise of regional and caste-based parties; Mandal reservation; economic liberalisation; communal conflicts |
| 2014 onwards | Single-party majority governments; dominance of a national party; debates on federalism, secularism, citizenship and institutions |
The Congress system, 1947 to 1967. After independence, the Indian National Congress, with its prestige from the national movement and the leadership of Nehru, Patel and others, dominated Union and State politics. Rajni Kothari described this as the Congress system, in which a single dominant party contained many factions, and the opposition worked within and outside it, as a pressure on the party. The party was a broad coalition of castes, communities and interests, and bargaining among them took place inside the party. The first three general elections, held in 1952, 1957 and 1962, were conducted successfully on a large scale. The decade saw the adoption of planning, the linguistic reorganisation of States, the framing of the Hindu Code Bills, land reforms of limited effect and a firm commitment to secularism. Critics argue that dominance by one party delayed the growth of a competitive system and that it relied on dominant castes in the villages.
Erosion of dominance, 1967 to 1977. In the elections of 1967, after the death of Nehru (1964) and Shastri (1966), and in a period of economic difficulty and food shortage, the Congress lost power in several States and its majority in the Lok Sabha was greatly reduced. Non-Congress coalition governments appeared in many States. The Congress split in 1969, and Indira Gandhi, with the slogan of garibi hatao in 1971, won a large victory, and personalised and centralised power in the party and the government. The Allahabad High Court’s judgment against her election in 1975, the movement led by Jayaprakash Narayan, and the declaration of Emergency under Article 352 on 25 June 1975 led to the suspension of rights, censorship, mass arrests of opponents, and the Forty-second Amendment. This period showed the fragility of democratic institutions, but also their resilience, since the electorate, in the elections of March 1977, voted out the Congress and returned a Janata government, which restored freedoms and made changes in the Constitution through the Forty-third and Forty-fourth Amendments. In Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala (1973) and Minerva Mills v. Union of India (1980), the Court affirmed the doctrine of basic structure, which put democracy and federalism beyond easy amendment.
Competition and new challenges, 1977 to 1989. The Janata Party government collapsed in 1979, and Indira Gandhi returned in 1980. The 1980s saw movements for regional autonomy and some violence, especially in Punjab, culminating in Operation Blue Star in 1984, the assassination of Indira Gandhi and the anti-Sikh riots that followed, the agitation in Assam over migration, ended by the Assam Accord of 1985, and insurgencies in parts of the north-east and in Jammu and Kashmir. Rajiv Gandhi won a large majority in 1984, but by 1989 the Congress had lost its position. The period also saw the growth of social movements, and the rise of new parties such as the Telugu Desam and the Asom Gana Parishad, which expressed regional identity.
Coalition era, 1989 to 2014. From 1989, no single party won a majority in the Lok Sabha until 2014. Coalition governments led by the Janata Dal, the Congress, the United Front, the National Democratic Alliance led by the Bharatiya Janata Party, and the United Progressive Alliance led by the Congress, depended on regional parties, which thus gained a strong voice at the Centre. The implementation of the Mandal Commission’s recommendation for 27 per cent reservation for OBCs in 1990 changed caste politics, strengthening backward-caste parties such as the Samajwadi Party, the Rashtriya Janata Dal and the Janata Dal (United), and the Bahujan Samaj Party gave the Dalits a major political vehicle. At the same time, the Ram Janmabhoomi movement, the demolition of the Babri Masjid in 1992 and the riots that followed, and the rise of the Bharatiya Janata Party, reshaped religious politics. Economic liberalisation, from 1991, changed the economic structure and raised new questions about inequality. The Seventy-third and Seventy-fourth Amendments, in 1992, deepened democracy at the local level. Writers such as Yogendra Yadav describe this phase as the second democratic upsurge, when the backward castes and, later, the poor and women, increased their political participation, and as a period of the federalisation of the party system.
Since 2014. In 2014 the Bharatiya Janata Party won a majority of seats in the Lok Sabha on its own, with about thirty-one per cent of the votes, and repeated the success in 2019, while in 2024 it fell short of a majority by itself and formed a coalition government with its allies. This period has seen debates about the centralisation of power, the working of federalism, secularism and minorities, citizenship, the role of the media and of institutions, and the use of welfare schemes and identity in elections. Scholars such as Yadav and Suhas Palshikar speak of a new dominance, a third phase of the party system, while others like Christophe Jaffrelot have used the term ethnic democracy, or majoritarian turn, in describing the change. Defenders argue that the electorate has repeatedly chosen the governments and that the democratic process continues, with strong competition at the State level. The assessment of these developments is much debated, and students should treat it as a continuing discussion.
6. Social cleavages and their management
| Cleavage | Nature | Main devices of management |
|---|---|---|
| Caste | Hierarchical, birth-based; sharp inequality | Abolition of untouchability; reservation; atrocities law; political mobilisation |
| Religion | Communal division; legacy of Partition | Secularism; minority rights; personal laws; courts |
| Language | Regional identities; official language dispute | Linguistic States; Eighth Schedule; three-language formula |
| Region | Disparities and regional identity | Federalism; Finance Commissions; special provisions |
| Tribe | Distinct communities with land rights | Fifth and Sixth Schedules; PESA; Forest Rights Act |
| Class | Economic inequality | Directive Principles; welfare schemes; planning |
| Gender | Patriarchy and unequal status | Fundamental rights; women’s reservation; reform laws |
Caste and politics. Caste is the most characteristic Indian cleavage. The Constitution abolished untouchability, prohibited discrimination and provided for reservation, and the Protection of Civil Rights Act, 1955, and the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989, gave legal protection. In politics, caste has become a basis of mobilisation. The Rudolphs, in The Modernity of Tradition (1967), held that caste associations helped to bring traditional groups into modern democratic politics, M. N. Srinivas wrote of the dominant caste in the villages, and Kothari argued that politics had caused a politicisation of caste, and not a casteisation of politics. Later writers such as Christophe Jaffrelot, in India’s Silent Revolution (2003), described the rise of the lower castes into positions of power, in a process that took place peacefully, through the ballot. At the same time, caste violence, atrocities and discrimination in education, employment and marriage continue, and the question of the sub-classification and the creamy layer within reserved categories continues to be debated.
Religion and communalism. The religious cleavage is the most sensitive. The Partition left a legacy of suspicion and the state has tried to place religion outside of politics. Communal riots, in 1984, 1992-93 and 2002, and incidents of lynching and targeted violence have been serious failures. The studies by Ashutosh Varshney, in Ethnic Conflict and Civic Life (2002), found that cities with strong associational links across communities, such as joint business bodies, trade unions and professional groups, had little riot violence, even when there was political tension, while cities with only everyday contact were more prone to violence. The question of the personal laws and the Uniform Civil Code, the debates on conversion, and the controversies over religious symbols in public institutions show the continuing difficulty of finding a balance between religious freedom and equality. The Places of Worship (Special Provisions) Act, 1991, intended to maintain the religious character of places of worship as at 15 August 1947, except for the Ayodhya dispute, has been the subject of litigation, and the Supreme Court, in M. Siddiq v. Mahant Suresh Das (2019), decided the Ayodhya case and directed that land be allotted for a mosque.
Language and region. The language question led to the movement for the reorganisation of States, to agitations in Tamil Nadu, to the Assam language movement and to concerns in the north-east. The solutions found, linguistic States, the continuation of English and the Eighth Schedule, were mostly successful. Fresh debates arise on the language of the Union, the three-language policy and the National Education Policy 2020. Regional inequalities, between developed and backward States, and the share of States in resources, are handled partly through the Finance Commission’s recommendations. Another source of tension is the distribution of Lok Sabha seats between States, which has been frozen on the basis of the 1971 Census until after the first Census after 2026, and the question of delimitation raises concern in the southern States, which have lowered their population growth.
Tribes and the north-east. For Scheduled Tribes, who form about 8.6 per cent of the population, the issues are land, forests, displacement, identity and development. The Sixth Schedule, the Fifth Schedule, PESA and the Forest Rights Act give protection, but displacement by mining and dams, and insurgency in several areas, show gaps. The north-east has experienced a number of insurgencies, which the state met by a mixture of force and negotiation, as in the Mizo Accord of 1986, the Bodo accords, the Naga peace process, and the use of the Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act, which has been criticised for violation of rights. The creation of new States and autonomous councils reflects the policy of accommodating identity within the democratic framework.
Class and inequality. The Constitution’s Preamble and Directive Principles promise economic justice, and the state has used planning, land reform, public sector enterprises, rural employment and food security programmes for this aim. Yet inequality of income and wealth remains high, and economic reforms from 1991 raised growth but also made inequality sharper, as noted by writers like Jean Drèze, Amartya Sen and Thomas Piketty and his co-authors. The overlap of caste and class, in that the poor are mostly from the lower castes and tribes, means that economic and social inequalities reinforce each other, and Ambedkar’s warning concerning the contradiction between political equality and social and economic inequality is as important today as in 1949.
Gender. Women’s political participation has risen, with turnout now equal to or higher than men in many elections, and with a third or more of local body seats reserved for them. The women’s representation in the Lok Sabha is still low, at about fifteen per cent after the 2024 elections, and the Women’s Reservation Act of 2023 awaits implementation. Social change through laws on dowry, domestic violence, sexual harassment and inheritance, and landmark judgments such as Vishaka v. State of Rajasthan (1997), have been given by Parliament and the courts, but patriarchal customs and violence against women remain serious problems.
Cross-cutting and reinforcing cleavages. India’s stability has been explained in part by the fact that its many cleavages cut across one another. A person’s caste, religion, language, region and class do not always line up, so that groups that are rivals on one ground may be allies on another. This reduces the chance that a single division would split the country. Where cleavages reinforce each other, as in some border or conflict regions, the problem has been more serious. Varshney, Kothari and others have pointed to the role of the party system and of elections in shifting alliances and thus reducing the pressure of any one cleavage.
7. Theories and interpretations of Indian democracy
| Scholar | Main idea | Key work |
|---|---|---|
| Rajni Kothari | Congress system; politicisation of caste; democracy as a process of accommodation | Politics in India (1970) |
| Arend Lijphart | India as a consociational democracy despite adverse conditions | “The Puzzle of Indian Democracy” (1996) |
| Alfred Stepan, Juan Linz, Yogendra Yadav | State-nation as against nation-state; democracy that respects multiple identities | Crafting State-Nations (2011) |
| Ashutosh Varshney | Civic networks restrain ethnic violence; Hindu-Muslim relations | Ethnic Conflict and Civic Life (2002) |
| Lloyd and Susanne Rudolph | Caste associations and modernisation of tradition | The Modernity of Tradition (1967) |
| Partha Chatterjee | Civil society and political society; politics of the governed | The Politics of the Governed (2004) |
| Sudipta Kaviraj | Peasant-based and vernacular democracy; fuzzy communities | The Imaginary Institution of India (2010) |
| Pranab Bardhan | Heterogeneous proprietary classes; democracy with development problems | The Political Economy of Development in India (1984) |
| Christophe Jaffrelot | Silent revolution of lower castes; ethnic democracy | India’s Silent Revolution (2003) |
| Yogendra Yadav | Democratic upsurges; party system phases | “Democracy and the Deepening of Participation” |
Kothari: accommodation and the Congress system. Rajni Kothari held that Indian democracy functioned because the dominant party was capable of absorbing demands from many groups, and that competition among factions inside the party and between the party and the opposition provided the basis of the political process. He argued that democracy in India was not borrowed, but was a process in which traditional structures such as caste found a role in the modern political order. His view that caste was politicised, rather than politics being casteised, remains a common starting point, though later scholars point out that he gave too little attention to the inequality of caste.
Lijphart: the puzzle of consociational democracy. In his presidential address to the American Political Science Association in 1996, Arend Lijphart called the persistence of democracy in India a puzzle, since the theory of democracy held that stable democracy needs a homogeneous society, a high level of income and literacy, and a common culture. He argued that India has features of a consociational democracy, namely power sharing among groups in the coalition, a degree of autonomy for groups through federalism and personal laws, proportionality in representation through reservation and in appointments, and a minority veto in the form of constitutional provisions. He admitted that some features were absent, such as the grand coalition at all times and the system of proportional representation in elections.
Stepan, Linz and Yadav: the state-nation. In Crafting State-Nations (2011), the authors distinguish the nation-state, which attempts to make the political boundary and the cultural identity coincide, from the state-nation, which holds that the state can be a home for many cultural nations and identities without insisting on a single one. India, they say, is the most successful example among the multinational democracies, because it combined the recognition of multiple identities, the federal division of power, the use of different languages, and the existence of a political party and the state, which are attached to the idea of India as a unity in diversity. They also warn that the state-nation is under strain when a majority identity claims to define the whole.
Varshney: civic life and ethnic conflict. Ashutosh Varshney compared the cities of Aligarh, Calicut, Hyderabad, Lucknow, Surat, Ahmedabad and Kanpur, where Hindu-Muslim tensions were roughly similar, and found that peace was maintained where there were organised forms of civic engagement across the communities, and that violence took place where only everyday forms of interaction existed. His study draws attention to the role of associations, such as chambers of commerce, trade unions, and professional bodies, and to the role of local political parties, which may be useful in controlling violence. Critics point to the limited number of cases and to the roles played by the state and the police.
Chatterjee: political society. Partha Chatterjee argued that in most of the postcolonial world, the ideas of citizenship and civil society, which are based on rights and the rule of law, apply to a small section of the people, while the majority, such as slum dwellers, street vendors and squatters, live in a political society, where they get claims recognised not through rights but through negotiation, pressure and the support of leaders. This theory helps to understand why the poor take part in politics actively, though outside the strict legal framework of citizenship.
Other contributions. Sudipta Kaviraj stressed that democracy in India had a deep social base in the political participation of peasants and the lower castes, though the elites had a more doubtful commitment to it. Pranab Bardhan analysed the dominant proprietary classes, the industrial capitalists, rich farmers and the professionals, whose conflicting interests limited the state’s capacity for reform. Atul Kohli, in Democracy and Discontent (1990), described a growing crisis of governability, with the weakening of the institutions and the rise of populist politics. Yogendra Yadav described three democratic upsurges, the first with the participation of the backward castes, the second with the poor and the lower classes entering the electoral field in large numbers, and the third as a still unfolding process. Amartya Sen, in The Argumentative Indian (2005), stressed the long tradition of public debate, tolerance and heterodoxy in India, as the foundation of its democratic practice.
8. Challenges to democracy in a plural society
Communalism and majoritarianism. The use of religious identity for political mobilisation harms the equal citizenship that the Constitution promises. The riots of 1984, 1992-93, and 2002, and the continuing cases of hate speech, lynching and discrimination, are serious concerns. A majoritarian approach, in which the majority’s culture is treated as the national culture, strains the idea of a state-nation. The constitutional answer is secularism, which is a part of the basic structure, as the Supreme Court stated in S. R. Bommai v. Union of India (1994), and the continuing task is to enforce it fairly in everyday governance.
Caste discrimination and the politics of identity. Caste inequalities persist in rural and in urban India. Atrocities against Dalits, honour killings, and discrimination in access to land, jobs and housing show the gap between formal and social equality. Competition for reservation has led to demands from dominant groups, such as the Jats, Patidars and Marathas, for inclusion in the backward category, and to disputes over the creamy layer, the sub-classification of Scheduled Castes, and the ceiling of fifty per cent set in Indra Sawhney v. Union of India (1992). In Janhit Abhiyan v. Union of India (2022), the Supreme Court, by a majority, upheld the ten per cent reservation for economically weaker sections in the 103rd Amendment, and in State of Punjab v. Davinder Singh (2024), a seven-judge Bench held that States may make sub-classification within Scheduled Castes. These decisions show the continuing effort to balance equality and social justice.
Regional inequality and federal tensions. Differences in the development of States, disputes about the sharing of river waters, the demand for special status, the role of Governors, the use of the Centre’s powers, and the tax shares of States, create strains in the federal structure. The Goods and Services Tax, introduced in 2017, has altered fiscal federalism, and States have raised concerns over their autonomy. Demands for separate States, such as Telangana, which was created in 2014, show the continuing process of the redrawing of boundaries, while the question of delimitation is a point of tension between the more populated and the less populated States.
Insurgency, security laws and civil liberties. Insurgencies in the north-east, Jammu and Kashmir, and parts of central India affected by Left-wing extremism have led the state to use special security laws, such as the Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act and the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, which have been criticised for restricting rights. Balancing the security of the state and the rights of the people is a permanent difficulty, as is the problem of ensuring accountability for abuses. The revocation of the special status of Jammu and Kashmir in August 2019 and its reorganisation as Union Territories, upheld by the Supreme Court in In re Article 370 (2023), remains much discussed with regard to federalism and consent.
Criminalisation, money and the quality of representation. The growing number of candidates with criminal cases, the high cost of elections, and the opacity of political funding, including the electoral bond scheme, which the Supreme Court struck down in Association for Democratic Reforms v. Union of India (2024), make representation less fair to citizens of limited means. Dynastic politics narrows the access of newcomers. These weaknesses affect the capacity of the system to represent the diversity of society in a meaningful way, since the poor and minorities may not have the resources to compete.
Weakening of institutions and the quality of deliberation. The functioning of Parliament, with frequent disruptions and reduced time for debate and committee scrutiny, the pressure on investigative agencies, the media and universities, the delay in judicial appointments and in the disposal of cases, and the use of ordinances, have been raised as concerns about the checks that a diverse democracy requires. Defenders note that courts, the Election Commission, the press and civil society continue to function and to correct excesses, and that the voters respond to governments in elections.
Gender inequality and the exclusion of women. Women’s presence in legislatures and in leadership of parties remains low, while the delay in the implementation of reservation shows the difficulty in changing a male-dominated political culture. Violence against women, the skewed sex ratio in certain regions, and the unequal burden of unpaid work continue to limit effective citizenship.
Economic inequality, migration and displacement. Differences in income and wealth, the informal nature of most employment, distress among farmers, and the problems of migrant workers, which came to light in the lockdown of 2020, show that political equality coexists with severe economic disadvantage. Displacement caused by large projects affects tribal and rural people, who have less political voice. Without economic and social democracy, political democracy may be hollow, which was Ambedkar’s central warning.
Citizenship, migration and the question of belonging. Disputes over migration, as in Assam, where the National Register of Citizens was updated in 2019, and the Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 2019, which provides a fast track to citizenship for persons from certain religious minorities from three neighbouring countries, with the exclusion of Muslims, have raised questions of equality and of the secular character of citizenship. The petitions against the Act are before the Supreme Court. The issue shows how the definition of the people can become contested in a plural democracy.
Digital communication, misinformation and polarisation. Social media has widened participation and given voice to marginal groups, but has also been used to spread rumours, hate speech and disinformation, which have, at times, led to violence. Internet shutdowns, which have been frequent in India, affect the freedom of expression. Regulation of the digital sphere without losing freedom is a new problem for the democratic order.
9. Strengths and weaknesses of Indian democracy
Strengths
- Continuity of free elections. Since 1952, elections have been held regularly at the Union, State and local levels, and governments have changed peacefully many times, including in 1977, 1989, 1996, 1998, 2004 and 2014. The Election Commission, with its constitutional status under Article 324, has conducted elections with an electorate of nearly a billion people, and has used electronic voting machines since 1999 to 2004. This record, in a country of great poverty and diversity, supports the claim that democracy is not restricted to rich and homogeneous societies.
- Wide popular participation. Turnout in Lok Sabha elections has remained around sixty to sixty-six per cent, and the poor, the rural population, women, Dalits and Adivasis vote at rates equal to or higher than the better-off groups. Yogendra Yadav calls this the democratic upsurge. Voting is thus seen as a means of claiming dignity and of holding leaders accountable, and not a mere ritual.
- Constitutional recognition of diversity. The Constitution does not demand cultural uniformity. Languages are listed in the Eighth Schedule, religious freedom is protected by Articles 25 to 28, minorities have the right to run educational institutions under Article 30, and many groups have protection through reservation. This recognition lets people claim a place in the nation without giving up their identity, as when a Tamil speaker is a full citizen without being asked to speak Hindi.
- Federal and linguistic accommodation. The reorganisation of States on the basis of language, after the Andhra agitation of 1953 and the States Reorganisation Act, 1956, turned a possible source of separatism into a means of stable accommodation. Strong regional parties give a voice to State interests at the Centre, and this reduces the sense of exclusion.
- Secularism of the state with principled distance. India has not chosen a state religion and has also not removed religion from public life as in the French model. The state intervenes in matters of religion to reform them, as in the abolition of untouchability and of temple entry restrictions, and supports all religions in some ways. This arrangement, which Rajeev Bhargava calls principled distance, has permitted a workable coexistence, with failures that remain visible.
- Independent judiciary and rights protection. Through judicial review, the doctrine of basic structure laid down in Kesavananda Bharati, public interest litigation, and the broad reading of Article 21 in Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India (1978), the courts have extended rights to the poor, women, minorities and prisoners. In Navtej Singh Johar v. Union of India (2018), the Court decriminalised consensual same-sex relations, and in K. S. Puttaswamy v. Union of India (2017), it recognised the right to privacy as fundamental.
- Social inclusion through reservation and local government. Reservation has brought members of historically excluded groups into legislatures, education and public jobs, and the Seventy-third and Seventy-fourth Amendments reserved seats in local bodies for Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and women. Over a million elected women now serve in the panchayats, which has changed the character of local politics in many villages.
- A vibrant civil society and free press. Social movements, such as the Chipko movement, the Narmada Bachao Andolan, the movement for the right to information, which led to the Right to Information Act, 2005, and the movements for the right to work and food, have shaped laws. A large and varied press and a number of non-governmental groups carry the voices of ordinary people to the state.
- Cross-cutting cleavages and a flexible party system. Since caste, religion, language and class overlap in different ways in different regions, no single division has defined the whole polity. The party system, with its alliances, has moved from one-party dominance to a competitive multiparty system, and this provides many routes through which groups can seek power.
- Resilience in crisis. The country passed through wars, the Emergency, secessionist movements, assassinations of two Prime Ministers, and severe communal violence without ending its democratic framework. The voters defeated the Emergency government in 1977, which is regarded as one of the most important demonstrations of the strength of democratic commitment among ordinary people.
Weaknesses
- Gap between political and social equality. Equal votes coexist with caste hierarchy, patriarchy and wealth inequality. Ambedkar’s warning of 1949 that India would be entering a life of contradictions has not lost its force. Where social domination is intact, the formal equality of voting does not secure real power for the lower groups, as seen when Dalit candidates are intimidated in local elections in some places.
- Communal polarisation and majoritarian tendencies. Religious identity used for votes, and violence against minorities, threaten equal citizenship. The riots of 1984, 1992-93 and 2002 and the later incidents of mob violence show that constitutional secularism has not been fully secured in practice, and that the state has, on occasion, failed to protect vulnerable groups.
- Criminalisation and the role of money. A significant proportion of the members of legislatures face criminal cases, and elections need large amounts of money. Opaque political funding, now struck down in one form by the Supreme Court, gave the wealthy a disproportionate influence. Honest candidates without resources find it hard to compete, and the poor are thus under-represented in practice.
- Dynasty and the concentration of power in parties. Many parties are run by families or by individual leaders, with little internal democracy, which limits the selection of candidates and the renewal of leadership. The anti-defection law, in the Tenth Schedule, while meant to prevent unprincipled changes of party, has the effect of making legislators follow the party leadership, and so weakens individual deliberation.
- Weak institutions and delays in justice. Courts have a very large number of pending cases, the police are often subject to political pressure, and implementation of laws by the administration is uneven. Weak state capacity means that rights remain on paper for the poor, who cannot afford long litigation, and that corruption is commonplace in dealing with officials.
- Under-representation of women and minorities. Women hold about fifteen per cent of the seats in the Lok Sabha, and the proportion of Muslims in the Lok Sabha is far below their share of the population. A democracy that claims to represent a plural society needs fair representation of its groups, and the first-past-the-post system, by giving a majority of seats to a party with a minority of votes, makes this difficult to achieve.
- Centralisation and federal strain. The strong Union, the powers of the Governor, the use of Article 356 in the past, central control over finance, and recent disputes over taxation and over policy areas in the State List, create tension. The imbalance reduces the autonomy of the States, which is a vital condition for managing diversity.
- Regional and economic disparities. The gap between prosperous and backward States, between cities and villages, and between the rich and the poor, produces discontent and migration. Economic growth has not produced enough jobs, and the informal sector, which employs most workers, has weak protection. Such disparities can feed identity-based conflicts as groups compete for scarce opportunities.
- Restrictions on freedom and dissent. The use of sedition, now replaced by new provisions in the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, preventive detention, stringent laws on unlawful activities, internet shutdowns, and pressure on media and civil society, raise concerns about the shrinking space for dissent. International indices have recorded a decline in India’s ranking in recent years, though the government disputes their methods.
- Unresolved conflict zones. Some areas such as parts of the north-east, Manipur, since 2023, Jammu and Kashmir, and areas of Left-wing extremism, continue to experience violence or alienation. These show that the accommodation of identities has not always succeeded and that the use of force has often been preferred to political solutions.
10. Critical analysis
The study of democracy in a plural society in India shows both an achievement and an unfinished task. The achievement is that democracy has survived, and has deepened in the sense that more groups take part in it than in 1950. The comparative literature of the 1950s and 1960s, by writers such as Gabriel Almond, Seymour Martin Lipset and Barrington Moore, tended to predict that a country with mass poverty, illiteracy, linguistic diversity and religious division would not sustain democracy. India disproved this, and Lijphart’s description of the puzzle has provoked a search for explanations. Some stress institutions, such as the Constitution, the Election Commission, federalism and the party system. Others stress political leadership, particularly the national movement’s training of leaders in the values of constitutionalism and compromise. Others point to the social structure, in which caste and other divisions cut across each other and make it hard for any single group to dominate permanently. A balanced explanation gives weight to all of these, together with the demonstration effect of repeated elections, in which people learned that power could be changed by the vote.
The analysis of whether India is a consociational democracy shows the limits of borrowing models. Lijphart’s idea of power sharing explains many features, but India does not have a grand coalition in the Dutch or Swiss sense, nor group-based proportional representation, and its accommodation has depended on practices that are flexible and often informal. The state-nation idea of Stepan, Linz and Yadav is appealing in recognising multiple identities, but critics say that it treats the state as more neutral than it is, and that it underestimates the pressures of cultural homogenisation. Both models help to capture something, but neither describes the whole. It is, therefore, more useful to treat Indian democracy as a case with its own logic, a pattern that has grown out of history and that mixes liberal rights, group-differentiated provisions and a strong, centralising state.
The relation between democracy and inequality is the most serious difficulty. Optimists point to the rise of lower-caste leaders such as Mayawati and the growing presence of the backward classes in the State legislatures and in local government, and see this as evidence of a silent revolution. Sceptics reply that representation in office has not always meant a change in material conditions, and that new elites from the previously disadvantaged groups may speak for the whole group while serving only their narrow section. The debate on the creamy layer and on the sub-classification of reserved categories reflects this concern. At the same time, the politics of recognition has competed with the politics of redistribution, so that questions of identity attract more mobilisation than those of land, wages and public services. The question that remains is whether democracy in a plural society can deliver both recognition for identity and a fairer distribution of resources.
The contemporary debate on majoritarianism divides scholars. One group argues that India is experiencing democratic backsliding, with the weakening of institutional checks, the concentration of power in the executive, and the marginalisation of minorities, in what is described as an electoral or illiberal democracy, or, in Jaffrelot’s words, a form of ethnic democracy. Another group replies that the electorate has repeatedly chosen the governments in free elections, that opposition parties win in many States, that courts continue to check the executive in many cases, and that mobilisation on the basis of the majority’s identity is a democratic expression of the wishes of a large number of citizens, which was long ignored by elites. A careful student should distinguish between the procedures of democracy, which continue, and the liberal and plural values that such procedures are meant to protect, and should see that a plural democracy is tested above all by the treatment of its smallest minorities.
The Indian experience also raises a general question for political theory, which is whether a democracy requires a shared national identity or can work with a thin commitment to the constitutional order. The Indian case suggests that a constitutional patriotism, based on rights and procedures and a belief in the unity of the state, can be a sufficient bond, provided that groups feel secure and that their languages and faiths are respected. The same case also shows that this bond is not automatic. It has to be renewed through fair treatment, through effective institutions, and through leaders who choose accommodation over polarisation. In this sense India’s experience is both an encouragement to other plural societies and a reminder that democratic stability in such societies is a continuing achievement, and not a final settlement.
11. Authors and books for UGC NET
| Author | Work | Main contribution |
|---|---|---|
| B. R. Ambedkar | Annihilation of Caste (1936); Constituent Assembly speeches (1949) | Social democracy; warning about political equality without social equality |
| Granville Austin | The Indian Constitution: Cornerstone of a Nation (1966) | History of the framing; consensus in the Constituent Assembly |
| J. S. Furnivall | Netherlands India (1939) | Concept of plural society |
| M. G. Smith | The Plural Society in the British West Indies (1965) | Cultural pluralism and its political consequences |
| Rajni Kothari | Politics in India (1970) | Congress system; politicisation of caste |
| Arend Lijphart | “The Puzzle of Indian Democracy” (1996) | Consociational features of India |
| Alfred Stepan, Juan Linz, Yogendra Yadav | Crafting State-Nations (2011) | State-nation model |
| Ashutosh Varshney | Ethnic Conflict and Civic Life (2002) | Civic engagement and communal peace |
| Lloyd and Susanne Rudolph | The Modernity of Tradition (1967) | Caste associations and democracy |
| Christophe Jaffrelot | India’s Silent Revolution (2003) | Rise of the lower castes |
| Partha Chatterjee | The Politics of the Governed (2004) | Political society |
| Sudipta Kaviraj | The Imaginary Institution of India (2010) | Vernacular politics; fuzzy communities |
| Pranab Bardhan | The Political Economy of Development in India (1984) | Dominant proprietary classes |
| Atul Kohli | Democracy and Discontent (1990) | Crisis of governability |
| Rajeev Bhargava | Secularism and Its Critics (1998) | Principled distance; contextual secularism |
| Amartya Sen | The Argumentative Indian (2005) | Tradition of public reasoning |
| Yogendra Yadav | “The Second Democratic Upsurge” (1999) | Democratic upsurges; party system phases |
| Zoya Hasan | Politics and the State in India (2000) | State, parties and social groups |
| Sunil Khilnani | The Idea of India (1997) | Political idea of India and its democratic experiment |
| Ramachandra Guha | India after Gandhi (2007) | Political history of independent India |
| Neera Chandhoke | Beyond Secularism (1999) | Rights of minorities and the state |
| Will Kymlicka | Multicultural Citizenship (1995) | Group-differentiated rights and the Indian case |
12. Practice questions
Long answer questions
- What is meant by a plural society? Discuss the working of democracy in India as a plural society, with reference to the constitutional devices of accommodation.
- Examine the role of the Constituent Assembly in shaping a democratic framework for a divided society, with reference to the views of Ambedkar, Nehru and Patel.
- Discuss the different phases in the working of Indian democracy from 1947 to the present, and explain the changes in the party system.
- Critically evaluate Lijphart’s view that India is a consociational democracy, and compare it with the state-nation approach of Stepan, Linz and Yadav.
- How have caste, religion and language influenced democratic politics in India? Examine the methods used by the state to manage these cleavages.
- Assess the major challenges to democracy in India’s plural society and suggest measures to meet them.
Medium answer questions
- Explain the concept of a plural society in the writings of Furnivall and M. G. Smith.
- Describe the main features of the Congress system as explained by Rajni Kothari.
- Explain the role of federalism and linguistic reorganisation in accommodating diversity in India.
- Discuss the Indian model of secularism and the idea of principled distance.
- Explain Varshney’s argument on civic engagement and ethnic conflict.
- Examine the importance of reservation for democracy in a plural society, with reference to Indra Sawhney and later judicial developments.
Short answer questions
- Write a note on cross-cutting cleavages.
- What is consociational democracy?
- Explain the concept of a state-nation.
- Write a note on the Eighth Schedule of the Constitution.
- Explain the democratic upsurge as described by Yogendra Yadav.
- What is the importance of the Seventy-third and Seventy-fourth Amendments for democracy in a plural society?
Very short answer questions
- Who coined the term plural society?
- Name the author of Crafting State-Nations.
- Which article of the Constitution abolishes untouchability?
- When was the Mandal Commission’s recommendation on OBC reservation implemented?
- Which case laid down the doctrine of basic structure?
Objective questions
- The term plural society was first used by: (a) M. G. Smith (b) J. S. Furnivall (c) Arend Lijphart (d) Rajni Kothari
- Who wrote The Politics of the Governed? (a) Partha Chatterjee (b) Sudipta Kaviraj (c) Pranab Bardhan (d) Atul Kohli
- The States Reorganisation Act was passed in: (a) 1950 (b) 1953 (c) 1956 (d) 1966
- Which of the following is the author of Ethnic Conflict and Civic Life? (a) Ashutosh Varshney (b) Christophe Jaffrelot (c) Yogendra Yadav (d) Zoya Hasan
- The ceiling of fifty per cent on reservation was laid down in: (a) Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala (b) Indra Sawhney v. Union of India (c) S. R. Bommai v. Union of India (d) Minerva Mills v. Union of India
- Assertion (A): India has been described as a puzzle for theories of democracy. Reason (R): Democratic theory had held that stable democracy requires a homogeneous and prosperous society. (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A (c) A is true, but R is false (d) A is false, but R is true
- Match the scholar with the idea: (i) Rajni Kothari (ii) Arend Lijphart (iii) Alfred Stepan (iv) Partha Chatterjee (A) State-nation (B) Political society (C) Congress system (D) Consociational democracy Codes: (a) i-C, ii-D, iii-A, iv-B (b) i-D, ii-C, iii-B, iv-A (c) i-C, ii-A, iii-D, iv-B (d) i-B, ii-D, iii-A, iv-C
- The Emergency of 1975 was declared under: (a) Article 352 (b) Article 356 (c) Article 360 (d) Article 370
Analytical prompts
- Indian democracy has survived despite conditions that theory considered unfavourable. Examine the institutional, social and political reasons for this survival.
- Does the politics of identity strengthen or weaken democracy in a plural society? Discuss with examples from India.
- Political equality exists in India alongside social and economic inequality. Analyse the consequences for the working of democracy.
- Compare the strengths and weaknesses of consociational and state-nation approaches in explaining Indian democracy.
Key takeaways
- A plural society is one in which cultural, religious, linguistic and social groups live within one political order, and democracy in such a society must manage competing claims fairly.
- India’s democracy rests on choices made in the Constituent Assembly: universal adult franchise, fundamental rights, federalism, secularism and special provisions for disadvantaged groups.
- The Constitution accommodates diversity through federalism, linguistic States, the Eighth Schedule, religious freedom, minority rights, reservation and the Fifth and Sixth Schedules.
- Indian democracy has passed through phases: Congress dominance, the erosion of that dominance and the Emergency, the coalition era, and the period of dominant-party politics since 2014.
- Caste, religion, language, region, tribe, class and gender are the major cleavages, and their overlapping and cutting across one another has helped stability.
- Scholars explain Indian democracy through the Congress system (Kothari), consociational features (Lijphart), the state-nation (Stepan, Linz and Yadav), civic networks (Varshney) and political society (Chatterjee).
- The strengths include free elections, wide participation, an active judiciary, a federal accommodation and a strong civil society, while the weaknesses include communalism, inequality, criminalisation and weak institutions.
- A plural democracy is tested by the treatment of its minorities and weakest groups, and its stability depends on continuing fair accommodation, and not on a final settlement.
Further reading
- B. R. Ambedkar, Annihilation of Caste.
- Granville Austin, The Indian Constitution: Cornerstone of a Nation.
- Granville Austin, Working a Democratic Constitution: The Indian Experience.
- Rajni Kothari, Politics in India.
- Arend Lijphart, Democracy in Plural Societies.
- Alfred Stepan, Juan Linz and Yogendra Yadav, Crafting State-Nations.
- Ashutosh Varshney, Ethnic Conflict and Civic Life.
- Lloyd I. Rudolph and Susanne Hoeber Rudolph, The Modernity of Tradition.
- Christophe Jaffrelot, India’s Silent Revolution.
- Partha Chatterjee, The Politics of the Governed.
- Sudipta Kaviraj, The Imaginary Institution of India.
- Pranab Bardhan, The Political Economy of Development in India.
- Atul Kohli (ed.), The Success of India’s Democracy.
- Rajeev Bhargava (ed.), Secularism and Its Critics.
- Amartya Sen, The Argumentative Indian.
- Sunil Khilnani, The Idea of India.
- Ramachandra Guha, India after Gandhi.
- Zoya Hasan, Politics and the State in India.
- Neera Chandhoke, Beyond Secularism: The Rights of Religious Minorities.
- Niraja Gopal Jayal, Citizenship and Its Discontents: An Indian History.
Frequently asked questions
Q1. What is a plural society? A plural society is one in which different cultural, religious, linguistic or ethnic groups live together in one political system, often keeping their separate identities. The term was used by J. S. Furnivall for colonial societies in which groups met only in the market, and it is now used more widely for any society marked by deep diversity.
Q2. Why is Indian democracy called a puzzle? Arend Lijphart used this description because democratic theory had held that stable democracy needs a fairly homogeneous society, a high level of income and literacy, and a common culture. India has had democracy for decades with widespread poverty, many languages and religions, and a caste hierarchy, which does not fit the theory.
Q3. How does the Indian Constitution accommodate diversity? It does so through federalism, the reorganisation of States on the basis of language, the recognition of many languages in the Eighth Schedule, the freedom of religion, minority educational rights, reservation for Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and backward classes, and special arrangements for tribal and border areas.
Q4. Is India a consociational democracy? Lijphart argued that India has important consociational features, such as power sharing, group autonomy, proportionality and minority protection. Other scholars say that India does not meet all the conditions, since it lacks a permanent grand coalition and group-based proportional representation, and that its accommodation has been flexible and informal.
Q5. What is a state-nation? A state-nation is a political arrangement in which a state is a home for several cultural identities and does not require a single national culture. Stepan, Linz and Yadav use this idea to explain how India holds together many linguistic and religious communities within a democratic framework.
Q6. What are the main challenges to democracy in India’s plural society? The main challenges are communal polarisation, caste discrimination, regional and economic inequality, insurgency and the use of special security laws, the role of money and criminalisation in elections, the under-representation of women, strains on federalism and the pressure on institutions and freedom of dissent.
