V. D. Savarkar: Hindutva and Nationalism

Vinayak Damodar Savarkar (1883–1966), popularly called “Veer” Savarkar, was a revolutionary, writer, social reformer and the principal ideologue of Hindu nationalism. His book Hindutva: Who is a Hindu? (1923) gave the classic definition of Hindu identity as a national and cultural category rather than a purely religious one, and laid the ideological foundation of the Hindu Mahasabha and, later, of the wider Hindutva movement. Savarkar remains one of the most debated figures in Indian political thought: admirers see him as a fearless patriot and rationalist reformer; critics see his nationalism as exclusionary and majoritarian. A good answer must explain his ideas accurately and assess them from both sides.

Life

  • Born on 28 May 1883 at Bhagur, near Nasik (Maharashtra), in a Chitpavan Brahmin family.
  • Revolutionary phase: founded the Mitra Mela (1899), which became Abhinav Bharat (1904), a secret revolutionary society inspired by Mazzini’s Young Italy.
  • In London (1906–10), he stayed at India House (Shyamji Krishna Varma) on a scholarship and organised Indian students. He wrote The Indian War of Independence of 1857 (1909), presenting 1857 as a national war of independence, not a mutiny; the book was banned in India. He also translated Mazzini’s writings into Marathi.
  • Arrest: after the assassination of Curzon Wyllie (by Madan Lal Dhingra, 1909) and of Nasik collector Jackson (1909), he was arrested in London (1910). During transportation to India, he attempted to escape at Marseilles (July 1910); the case went to the Permanent Court of Arbitration at The Hague (1911), which ruled in Britain’s favour.
  • Sentenced to two terms of transportation for life (50 years), he was imprisoned in the Cellular Jail, Andaman (1911–1921). He submitted mercy petitions to the government (1911, 1913 and later) — a subject of continuing controversy; admirers see them as a tactical move to gain release and continue work, critics as a compromise with colonial authority.
  • Moved to Ratnagiri jail (1921), where he wrote Hindutva; released in 1924 on condition that he remain in Ratnagiri district and not take part in politics (restrictions lifted in 1937). In Ratnagiri he campaigned against untouchability and caste restrictions.
  • President of the Hindu Mahasabha (1937–1943).
  • After Gandhi’s assassination (1948), he was tried as a co-accused but acquitted (1949) for lack of corroborative evidence; the Kapur Commission (1969) later examined the matter again.
  • He died on 26 February 1966 after voluntarily giving up food and medicine (atmaarpan).

Major works: The Indian War of Independence of 1857 (1909); Hindutva: Who is a Hindu? (1923); Hindu Pad-Padashahi (1925, on the Maratha empire); My Transportation for Life (Majhi Janmathep, 1927); Hindu Rashtra Darshan (collected presidential speeches, 1949); Six Glorious Epochs of Indian History (1963); many essays on rationalism and social reform.

  • Savarkar’s other key works: The Indian War of Independence of 1857 (1909), which called 1857 the first war of independence; Hindutva: Who is a Hindu? (1923); Six Glorious Epochs of Indian History.
  • Organisations: Abhinav Bharat (1904); Free India Society, London; president of the Hindu Mahasabha (1937–43).
  • Savarkar’s Hindutva is usually contrasted with Gandhi’s and Nehru’s inclusive nationalism and with Aurobindo’s spiritual nationalism.

Hindutva

Hindutva and Hinduism

Savarkar’s key move was to distinguish Hindutva (“Hinduness”) from Hinduism (a religion):

  • Hinduism is only one part of Hindutva — the religious beliefs and practices of Hindus, which are many and varied.
  • Hindutva is a much wider concept: it embraces “all the departments of thought and activity of the whole being of our Hindu race” — history, culture, language, territory, and blood ties. It is a national identity, not a theology.

Savarkar himself was a rationalist and atheist in his personal beliefs; he did not ground Hindutva in religious faith but in a shared nationhood.

Who is a Hindu? The three essentials

In Hindutva, Savarkar identifies three essentials of Hindutva:

  • Rashtra (a common nation / territory): a Hindu is one who regards the land of Sindhusthan / Bharatvarsha, from the Indus to the seas, as his pitribhu (fatherland).
  • Jati (a common race / blood): Hindus are bound by ties of common blood, descending from the Vedic forefathers, the Sindhus, through centuries of intermixing within the land.
  • Sanskriti (a common culture / civilisation): Hindus share a common culture expressed in their history, heroes, festivals, rituals, literature, art, laws and the Sanskrit language.

To these he adds the decisive criterion of the holy land: a Hindu is one who regards Bharatvarsha as both his pitribhu (fatherland) and his punyabhu (holy land) — the land of his prophets, seers and sacred places.

His well-known definition (in the Sanskrit verse at the end of Hindutva): a Hindu is one who regards the land from the Indus to the seas as his fatherland and holy land.

Implications of the definition

  • Inclusion: followers of all Indic religions — Sanatanis, Arya Samajists, Sikhs, Jains, Buddhists, tribal religions — are Hindus, since their holy lands lie within India. Even atheists born of Hindu parents are Hindus.
  • Exclusion: Muslims and Christians of India share the fatherland and often the blood and much of the culture, but their holy lands (Arabia, Palestine) lie outside India. Hence, in Savarkar’s view, their primary loyalty is divided, and they do not fully belong to the Hindu nation, unless they adopt India as their holy land.
  • Hindutva thus combines territorial, ethnic (racial) and cultural criteria, with the holy-land test as the boundary-marker.

Savarkar’s rationalism and social reform

A less-known side of Savarkar is his rationalism and social reform, which he saw as necessary to unite and strengthen the Hindu nation:

  • He attacked the “seven shackles” (saptabandi) of Hindu society: restrictions on Vedic study (vedokta-bandi), on occupation (vyavasaya-bandi), on touch (sparsha-bandi), on sea voyage (sindhu-bandi), on reconversion (shuddhi-bandi), on inter-dining (roti-bandi) and on inter-marriage (beti-bandi).
  • In Ratnagiri he organised inter-caste dining, opened the Patit Pavan Mandir (1931) for all castes including former untouchables, and supported temple entry.
  • He criticised cow worship, arguing that the cow is a useful animal to be protected for economic reasons, not a deity; he favoured science, technology and industrialisation, and rejected blind faith and astrology.
  • He supported shuddhi (reconversion) and the language reform movement (purging Marathi of Persian and English words).

His reformism was instrumental: caste divisions weakened Hindu unity, so they had to go.

Savarkar’s Nationalism

From revolutionary nationalism to Hindu nationalism

Savarkar’s nationalism passed through two phases:

  • Revolutionary, anti-colonial phase (1899–1911): inspired by Mazzini, the Italian Risorgimento and Shivaji, he called for armed revolution against the British. The Indian War of Independence of 1857 presented the revolt as a joint struggle of Hindus and Muslims for freedom and praised Muslim leaders of 1857.
  • Hindu nationalist phase (from the 1920s): after his imprisonment and the communal politics of the 1920s (Khilafat, Moplah rising), he defined the Indian nation in terms of Hindutva. His central concern became the unity, strength and political power of Hindus.

Hindu Rashtra

  • For Savarkar, the Hindus are the nation in India; India is a Hindu Rashtra in the sense that the majority community, bound by Hindutva, constitutes the national core.
  • At the Hindu Mahasabha’s Ahmedabad session (1937), he declared that India cannot be assumed to be a unitary and homogeneous nation; there are two nations in the main, the Hindus and the Muslims. (Ambedkar noted the parallel with Jinnah’s two-nation theory, though their conclusions were opposite: Savarkar rejected Partition.)
  • He stood for Akhand Bharat (undivided India) and opposed the creation of Pakistan.

The state and minorities

  • Savarkar proposed a state based on one person, one vote, with equal rights of citizenship for all, and no special privileges (no separate electorates, weightage or reservations) for any community.
  • Minorities would have freedom of religion, culture and language, but the state’s character would be shaped by the majority.
  • He opposed the Congress’s policy of concessions to the League, calling it appeasement.
  • Critics point out that his insistence that minorities accept Hindu cultural primacy, and his description of them as having divided loyalties, made his idea of citizenship unequal in practice.

Militarisation and realpolitik

  • His slogan as Mahasabha president: “Hinduise all politics and militarise Hindudom.”
  • During the Second World War, he urged Hindus to join the British Indian army in large numbers to gain military training, which would be useful for the nation later.
  • He opposed the Quit India Movement (1942), asking Mahasabha members to stay at their posts.
  • He favoured power politics and realism: nations survive through strength, not non-violence. He was a strong critic of Gandhian non-violence and of the Khilafat alliance, which he saw as appeasement.
  • He favoured rapid industrialisation, modern science and a strong military for India.

Cultural nationalism and history

  • Savarkar’s historical writings (Hindu Pad-Padashahi, Six Glorious Epochs) present Indian history as a long struggle of the Hindu nation against foreign invaders, glorifying resistance (Shivaji, the Marathas) and criticising what he saw as excessive tolerance and non-violence (he criticised Buddhism’s influence on this point).
  • History, language and culture were thus tools to build national consciousness.

Savarkar’s nationalism compared

PointSavarkar (Hindu nationalism)Gandhi / Congress (composite nationalism)
Basis of nationHindutva: territory + race + culture + holy landShared territory, history, culture of all communities
MinoritiesEqual citizenship but within Hindu cultural nation; no special safeguardsProtection and accommodation of minorities
MethodMilitarisation, realpolitik, armed strengthNon-violence, satyagraha
Religion and stateState shaped by majority cultureEqual respect for all religions (sarva dharma sambhava)
PartitionRejected; Akhand BharatResisted, but accepted in 1947
Social reformAbolish caste barriers for Hindu unityAbolish untouchability as moral duty

Critical Assessment

Arguments of admirers:

  • A revolutionary patriot who suffered decades of imprisonment for India’s freedom; The Indian War of Independence inspired generations of revolutionaries (including Bhagat Singh’s circle and the INA).
  • A rationalist and social reformer who fought untouchability and caste restrictions more boldly than many contemporaries.
  • A realist who stressed military strength, science and industrialisation for national security.
  • Offered a coherent theory of cultural nationalism that remains influential.

Arguments of critics:

  • Hindutva’s definition makes religion (holy land) the test of full national belonging, effectively excluding Muslims and Christians and creating a majoritarian nation; this conflicts with the secular, civic nationalism of the Constitution.
  • The emphasis on race and blood (jati) echoes European ethnic nationalism of the period.
  • His two-nation statement (1937) and hostility to Muslim politics contributed to communal polarisation.
  • His mercy petitions and his later opposition to Quit India and support for wartime recruitment are criticised as compromises with colonial rule.
  • His social reform was instrumental, aimed at Hindu unity against others rather than at universal equality.

Scholarly views: Historians such as Christophe Jaffrelot, Jyotirmaya Sharma (Hindutva: Exploring the Idea of Hindu Nationalism, 2003) and Vinayak Chaturvedi (Hindutva and Violence, 2022) analyse Savarkar as the founder of Hindu nationalist ideology; biographers like Vikram Sampath (Savarkar, 2 vols., 2019–21) present a more sympathetic account; Dhananjay Keer‘s biography (1950) is a classic.

Conclusion

Savarkar’s thought moved from revolutionary anti-colonialism to a theory of Hindu cultural nationalism. His concept of Hindutva — based on common territory, common blood, common culture and the holy-land criterion — redefined “Hindu” as a national identity, uniting followers of all Indic faiths but placing Muslims and Christians outside its core. Combined with rationalism, anti-caste reform, militarism and realpolitik, it produced a distinctive nationalism that sharply differed from Gandhian composite nationalism. Its influence on modern Indian politics makes Savarkar indispensable for understanding contemporary debates on nationalism, secularism and citizenship.

Quick Revision

ItemKey point
Dates28 May 1883 – 26 Feb 1966; born Bhagur, Nasik
OrganisationsMitra Mela (1899); Abhinav Bharat (1904); Hindu Mahasabha president (1937–43)
Early workThe Indian War of Independence of 1857 (1909)
ImprisonmentCellular Jail, Andaman (1911–21); Ratnagiri (1921–24); restrictions to 1937
HindutvaWritten in Ratnagiri jail; published 1923
EssentialsRashtra, Jati, Sanskriti
TestPitribhu (fatherland) + Punyabhu (holy land)
ReformSeven shackles; Patit Pavan Mandir (1931)
Slogan“Hinduise all politics and militarise Hindudom”
1937Ahmedabad: “two nations” statement

Memory aid: Hindutva = “R-J-S + P-P” — Rashtra, Jati, Sanskriti + Pitribhu, Punyabhu.

Exam Practice

Long-answer questions

  • Explain Savarkar’s concept of Hindutva. How does it differ from Hinduism?
  • Discuss the essentials of Hindutva according to Savarkar.
  • Examine Savarkar’s views on nationalism and the place of minorities in the Indian nation.
  • Critically evaluate Savarkar’s contribution to social reform.
  • Compare the nationalism of Savarkar with that of Gandhi.
  • “Savarkar’s nationalism was cultural rather than territorial.” Discuss.

Short-answer questions

  • What is Abhinav Bharat?
  • Why is The Indian War of Independence of 1857 significant?
  • What are pitribhu and punyabhu?
  • What are the three essentials of Hindutva?
  • What did Savarkar mean by the “seven shackles”?
  • What was the Patit Pavan Mandir?
  • What is the meaning of “Hinduise all politics and militarise Hindudom”?
  • What did Savarkar say at the Ahmedabad session of 1937?
  • What were Savarkar’s views on the cow?
  • What was Savarkar’s attitude to the Quit India Movement?

Multiple-choice questions

  • “Hindutva: Who is a Hindu?” was first published in: (a) 1909 (b) 1923 (c) 1937 (d) 1949. Answer: (b)
  • Savarkar founded the Mitra Mela in: (a) 1899 (b) 1904 (c) 1906 (d) 1910. Answer: (a)
  • According to Savarkar, a Hindu regards Bharatvarsha as: (a) Only fatherland (b) Only holy land (c) Both fatherland and holy land (d) Neither. Answer: (c)
  • Which is NOT one of the three essentials of Hindutva? (a) Rashtra (b) Jati (c) Sanskriti (d) Dharma. Answer: (d)
  • Savarkar was president of the Hindu Mahasabha during: (a) 1915–1921 (b) 1925–1930 (c) 1937–1943 (d) 1946–1950. Answer: (c)
  • Match the following: (A) The Indian War of Independence – (B) Hindutva – (C) Hindu Pad-Padashahi – (D) Six Glorious Epochs. (1) 1923 (2) 1909 (3) 1963 (4) 1925. Correct code: (a) A-2, B-1, C-4, D-3 (b) A-1, B-2, C-4, D-3 (c) A-2, B-4, C-1, D-3 (d) A-3, B-1, C-4, D-2. Answer: (a)
  • Savarkar’s attempted escape in 1910 took place at: (a) Dover (b) Marseilles (c) Aden (d) Colombo. Answer: (b)
  • Assertion (A): Savarkar included Sikhs, Jains and Buddhists in his definition of Hindu. Reason (R): Their holy lands lie within India. (a) Both true, R explains A (b) Both true, R does not explain A (c) A true, R false (d) A false, R true. Answer: (a)
  • The Patit Pavan Mandir was established by Savarkar at: (a) Nasik (b) Pune (c) Ratnagiri (d) Bombay. Answer: (c)
  • Savarkar was influenced in his early revolutionary phase by: (a) Marx (b) Mazzini (c) Tolstoy (d) Rousseau. Answer: (b)

Previous Years’ Questions

These questions were actually set in earlier examinations. Savarkar is in the UGC-NET syllabus (Unit 3) and in the University of Delhi B.A. (Hons.) paper Indian Political Thought–II.

UGC-NET (Political Science)

  • Match List I with List II: (A) Savarkar (B) M. N. Roy (C) Aurobindo Ghose (D) Jayaprakash Narayan — (i) associated with a secret society ‘Lotus and Dagger’ (ii) author of A Plea for Reconstruction of Indian Polity (iii) convicted in the Kanpur conspiracy case (iv) “Hinduise all politics…”. Answer: A–iv, B–iii, C–i, D–ii.

University examinations

  • Write a short note on Savarkar’s view on Hindutva. (University of Delhi, B.A. (Hons.), Indian Political Thought–II)

Answer pointers: Savarkar’s view on Hindutva

  • Hindutva: Who is a Hindu? (1923) separates Hindutva (a cultural-political identity) from Hinduism (a religion).
  • Three bonds of Hindutva: rashtra (common territory, Sindhu to the seas), jati (common blood and descent) and sanskriti (common culture); and the land as both pitrubhumi (fatherland) and punyabhumi (holy land).
  • Political conclusions: India as a Hindu nation; his slogan of Hinduising politics and militarising Hindudom as president of the Hindu Mahasabha.
  • Other aspects: rationalist, anti-caste reformer (Ratnagiri temple-entry and inter-dining work), critic of cow worship as superstition.
  • Assessment: supporters see cultural nationalism and social reform; critics (Nehru, Gandhian and secular scholars) see an exclusive nationalism that treats religious minorities whose holy land lies outside India as less than full members. Present both sides in a balanced conclusion.

Suggested Readings

  • V. D. Savarkar, Hindutva: Who is a Hindu? (1923; Hindi Sahitya Sadan reprints).
  • V. D. Savarkar, Hindu Rashtra Darshan (1949).
  • Dhananjay Keer, Veer Savarkar (Popular Prakashan, 1950; rev. 1966).
  • Jyotirmaya Sharma, Hindutva: Exploring the Idea of Hindu Nationalism (Penguin, 2003).
  • Christophe Jaffrelot, The Hindu Nationalist Movement in India (Penguin, 1996); (ed.), Hindu Nationalism: A Reader (Princeton, 2007).
  • Vikram Sampath, Savarkar: Echoes from a Forgotten Past and Savarkar: A Contested Legacy (Penguin, 2019–21).
  • Vinayak Chaturvedi, Hindutva and Violence: V. D. Savarkar and the Politics of History (SUNY, 2022).
  • B. R. Ambedkar, Pakistan or the Partition of India (1945), on Savarkar and Jinnah.
Scroll to Top