← Back Limits of Structural Realism in South Asia Download PDF
PoliPrepHub
Making Political Science Easy
poliprephub.in

International Relations of South Asia

Limits of Structural Realism in South Asia

By Brajabandhu Mahanta•November 17, 2026•19 min read

Structural realism explains some patterns of South Asian security well, such as balancing, arms races and the failure of regional cooperation (see the previous topic). But it struggles to explain the sources, nature and content of most security threats in the region. This topic sets out its main limits, which together form the heart of Unit II.

The core argument in one paragraph

Structural realism was built to explain the behaviour of great powers in a system of strong, cohesive, sovereign states whose main threats come from other states. South Asian states are mostly post-colonial, internally divided and weakly consolidated. Their most frequent and deadly threats come from within (insurgencies, ethnic and religious conflict, regime crises) or from non-state and non-military sources (terrorism, migration, water, climate). Their foreign policies are shaped by identity, history and domestic politics, not only by the distribution of power. Therefore, the realist model of unitary states balancing each other in anarchy gives an incomplete and sometimes misleading picture of South Asian security.

Realist assumptions to be tested

Realist assumptionQuestion for South Asia
The main threats are external and militaryAre most threats actually internal or non-military?
States are unitary, rational actorsDo armies, parties, provinces and leaders pursue their own interests?
State interests come from structure, not identityAre rivalries driven by religion, nationhood and history?
States are the main actorsWhat about terrorist groups, insurgents and diasporas?
States are “like units” with full sovereigntyAre South Asian states weak, with porous borders and contested legitimacy?
Cooperation is rare and fragileWhy have some treaties and friendships lasted?
The theory is universalWas it built mainly on European and Cold War experience?

Each of these is discussed below.

Limit 1: Internal Threats and Regime Security

The problem

Structural realism assumes that security threats come mainly from other states across the border. In South Asia, the most frequent, long-lasting and deadly threats have been internal.

Concepts that explain this better

Examples of regime security driving “national” security

Why this matters

If the main threats are internal, then balance of power and military alliances cannot solve them. They require state-building, inclusive governance, federalism, development and political accommodation, which are outside structural realism’s scope.

Limit 2: The State Is Not a Unitary Actor

The problem

Waltz treats states as unitary “like units” and says his theory does not explain foreign policy. But in South Asia, security policy is often driven by domestic institutions, leaders, parties, provinces and public opinion, which can push states in directions that structure alone would not predict.

Civil-military relations in Pakistan

Domestic politics in India

Other examples

Better explanations

Limit 3: Identity, Ideology and History

The problem

Structural realism says state interests come from material structure (anarchy and the distribution of power), not from identity or ideas. But in South Asia, many conflicts are driven by who states think they are and how they see the “other”.

The India–Pakistan rivalry as an identity conflict

Other examples

Better explanations

Limit 4: Non-state Actors, Terrorism and the Limits of Deterrence

The problem

Structural realism is state-centric: only states matter as actors. But in South Asia, many of the most serious security events have been caused by non-state actors.

Why non-state actors challenge realism

The stability-instability paradox

Better explanations

Limit 5: Non-traditional and Human Security

The problem

Structural realism defines security narrowly as military protection of the state. In South Asia, the threats that affect the most people are often non-military and transnational, and the referent object of security is frequently the individual or community, not the state.

Major non-traditional threats

ThreatSouth Asian examplesWhy realism misses it
Poverty and hungerLarge shares of the world’s poor and malnourished live in the regionNot a military threat; needs development
Climate change and disastersFloods in Pakistan (2022); cyclones in Bangladesh and Odisha; sea-level rise in Maldives; glacial melt in the HimalayasTransnational; no enemy state to balance
Water scarcity and river disputesIndus, Ganga, Teesta, BrahmaputraRequires cooperation, not deterrence
Migration and refugeesPartition, 1971, Tibetans, Tamils, Lhotshampas, Afghans, RohingyaDriven by internal conflict and poverty
PandemicsCOVID-19No military solution
Drugs, trafficking and organised crimeGolden Crescent and Golden Triangle routesNon-state, cross-border networks
Economic crisesSri Lanka’s default (2022); Pakistan’s repeated IMF bailoutsInternal economic management

Human security

Better explanations

Limit 6: Post-colonial States and Contested Sovereignty

The problem

Waltz assumes that states are “like units” with full Westphalian sovereignty: clear borders, control over their territory and the same basic functions. South Asian states do not fit this assumption well.

How South Asian states differ

Why this matters

Better explanations

Limit 7: Cooperation, Amity and Change That Realism Cannot Explain

The problem

Structural realism expects cooperation to be rare, fragile and limited by relative-gains concerns. Yet South Asia also shows durable cooperation, friendships and peaceful settlement of disputes, as well as sharp changes in policy that structure does not predict.

Durable cooperation

Amity and the “security community” idea

Change not explained by structure

Better explanations

Limit 8: Eurocentric and Great-power Bias

The problem

Structural realism was developed mainly from the experience of European great powers (from the 17th to the 20th century) and the US–Soviet Cold War. Waltz himself said his theory is about great powers, because they shape the system. This creates several problems when the theory is applied to South Asia.

Main points of criticism

Third World and non-Western critiques

Why this matters

A theory built for great-power politics among strong states can capture the India–Pakistan–China military balance, but not the everyday insecurity of most South Asian states and peoples. This is why many scholars argue for alternative or complementary approaches, discussed in the next topic.

Summary: Realist Assumptions vs South Asian Reality

Realist assumptionSouth Asian realityBetter explanation
Threats are mainly external and militaryMost violence is internal: insurgencies, ethnic conflict, regime crisesSubaltern realism (Ayoob); weak states (Buzan); insecurity dilemma (Job)
States are unitary rational actorsArmy, parties, provinces and leaders shape policy (Kargil, Teesta, Sri Lanka)Neoclassical realism; liberalism; bureaucratic politics
Interests come from material structureRivalries are rooted in identity, religion and history (Kashmir)Constructivism; strategic culture; ontological security
Only states matterTerrorist groups, insurgents and diasporas trigger crisesTerrorism and insurgency studies; Sagan’s organisational theory
Nuclear weapons bring stabilityNo full war, but repeated crises (stability-instability paradox)Snyder; Kapur’s “dangerous deterrent”
Security means military defence of the stateClimate, water, migration, poverty and pandemics threaten peopleHuman security; Copenhagen School; environmental security
States are sovereign “like units”Colonial borders, porous frontiers, cross-border ethnic groups, weak state controlPost-colonial theory; Regional Security Complex Theory
Cooperation is rare and fragileIndus Waters Treaty lasted 65 years; Land Boundary Agreement; India–Bhutan amityNeoliberal institutionalism; constructivism (security community)
The theory is universalBuilt on European and Cold War great-power experienceGlobal IR; Third World and post-colonial critiques

Conclusion

Structural realism is not wrong about South Asia, but it is incomplete. It captures the inter-state military competition among India, Pakistan and China, but it misses the internal, identity-based, non-state and non-traditional dimensions that dominate everyday insecurity in the region. It treats states as cohesive, sovereign actors, when South Asian states are post-colonial, plural and still building themselves. It cannot explain why rivalries persist despite their costs, why some partnerships are deeply friendly, or why policies change sharply with governments and leaders.

A realistic understanding of South Asian security therefore needs to combine realism’s insights about power with approaches that take seriously the nature of the post-colonial state, identity, domestic politics, non-state actors and human security. These approaches (subaltern realism, Regional Security Complex Theory, constructivism, securitisation, human security and feminist perspectives) are the subject of the final topic of this unit.

Quick Revision: Thinkers and Concepts

ConceptThinkerKey work
Subaltern realism; late state-makersMohammed AyoobThe Third World Security Predicament (1995)
Weak states; regime securityBarry BuzanPeople, States and Fear (1983, 1991)
Insecurity dilemmaBrian Job (ed.)The Insecurity Dilemma (1992)
Wars within statesK.J. HolstiThe State, War, and the State of War (1996)
Stability-instability paradoxGlenn Snyder“The Balance of Power and the Balance of Terror” (1965)
Dangerous deterrentS. Paul KapurDangerous Deterrent (2007)
Organisational dangers of proliferationScott SaganThe Spread of Nuclear Weapons: A Debate (with Waltz, 1995)
Pakistan army’s ideological way of warC. Christine FairFighting to the End (2014)
Military business (Milbus)Ayesha SiddiqaMilitary Inc. (2007)
Sovereignty as organised hypocrisyStephen KrasnerSovereignty: Organized Hypocrisy (1999)
Indian strategic cultureGeorge TanhamIndian Strategic Thought (1992)
Human securityMahbub ul Haq (UNDP)Human Development Report (1994)
Anarchy is what states make of itAlexander WendtArticle (1992)
Global IRAmitav Acharya and Barry BuzanNon-Western International Relations Theory (2010)
Postcolonial insecuritiesSankaran KrishnaPostcolonial Insecurities (1999)

One-line memory aids

Exam Practice

Long-answer questions

  1. Critically examine the limits of structural realism in explaining South Asian security.
  2. “The main security threats to South Asian states are internal rather than external.” Discuss with reference to Ayoob’s subaltern realism.
  3. How do identity and ideology challenge the realist explanation of the India–Pakistan rivalry?
  4. Discuss the role of non-state actors in South Asian security. Why does this challenge structural realism?
  5. Explain the stability-instability paradox with reference to India and Pakistan.
  6. “Structural realism is a theory of great powers and cannot explain the security problems of post-colonial states.” Examine.
  7. How does the concept of human security broaden our understanding of security in South Asia?

Short-answer questions

  1. Subaltern realism
  2. Insecurity dilemma
  3. Regime security
  4. Stability-instability paradox
  5. Strategic culture
  6. Security community
  7. Human security
  8. Organised hypocrisy
  9. Global IR
  10. Weak state

MCQs (UGC-NET / OPSC style)

  1. “Subaltern realism” is associated with:
    • (a) Barry Buzan (b) Mohammed Ayoob (c) Amitav Acharya (d) Stephen Walt
    • Answer: (b)
  2. The concept of the “insecurity dilemma” in Third World states was developed by:
    • (a) Brian Job (b) John Herz (c) Robert Jervis (d) Kenneth Waltz
    • Answer: (a)
  3. Dangerous Deterrent (2007), which argues that nuclear weapons increased instability in South Asia, was written by:
    • (a) Sumit Ganguly (b) S. Paul Kapur (c) Scott Sagan (d) Stephen Cohen
    • Answer: (b)
  4. The stability-instability paradox was first formulated by:
    • (a) Glenn Snyder (b) Thomas Schelling (c) Bernard Brodie (d) Henry Kissinger
    • Answer: (a)
  5. Which event is often cited to show that the Pakistani army acted without full civilian approval?
    • (a) Operation Gibraltar (b) Kargil war (c) Operation Searchlight (d) Simla Agreement
    • Answer: (b)
  6. The concept of human security was popularised by the UNDP report shaped by:
    • (a) Amartya Sen (b) Mahbub ul Haq (c) Jagdish Bhagwati (d) Muhammad Yunus
    • Answer: (b)
  7. Match the following:
    • A. Sovereignty: Organized Hypocrisy – 1. C. Christine Fair
    • B. Fighting to the End – 2. Stephen Krasner
    • C. Postcolonial Insecurities – 3. K.J. Holsti
    • D. The State, War, and the State of War – 4. Sankaran Krishna
    • Answer: A-2, B-1, C-4, D-3
  8. Assertion (A): Nuclear deterrence has not prevented repeated crises between India and Pakistan. Reason (R): Nuclear weapons may encourage limited conflict and proxy war under the nuclear umbrella.
    • Answer: Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
  9. Which relationship is often described as resembling a “security community”?
    • (a) India–Pakistan (b) India–China (c) India–Bhutan (d) Pakistan–Afghanistan
    • Answer: (c)
  10. In 2011, the Teesta water-sharing agreement between India and Bangladesh was blocked mainly because of:
    • (a) China’s opposition (b) Opposition from the West Bengal government (c) A UN ruling (d) Pakistan’s objection
    • Answer: (b)

Suggested readings

Category: International Relations of South Asia
Tag: Limits of Structural Realism
Source: https://poliprephub.in/international-relations-of-south-asia/limits-of-structural-realism-in-south-asia/
© PoliPrepHub · Generated on November 20, 2026