|
PoliPrepHub
Making Political Science Easy
|
poliprephub.in |
Federalism
Centre–State Relations: The Constitution of India establishes a federal system of governance by distributing legislative, executive, and financial powers between the Union (Centre) and the States. While authority is divided in these spheres, the Constitution does not provide for a separate judicial system for the Union and the States. Instead, India has a single integrated judiciary, headed by the Supreme Court, which ensures uniform interpretation and enforcement of both Union and State laws.
Although the Union and the States are sovereign within their respective constitutional domains, effective governance requires close cooperation, coordination, and mutual respect. To maintain the balance of federalism and promote national unity, the Constitution lays down detailed provisions governing the relationship between the Centre and the States.
Centre–State relations under the Indian Constitution are broadly classified into three categories:
These constitutional provisions collectively ensure the smooth functioning of India’s federal polity while preserving both national integrity and state autonomy.
Legislative relations constitute the foundation of India’s federal system. Articles 245 to 255 of Part XI of the Constitution regulate the distribution of legislative powers between the Union and the States. In addition, several other constitutional provisions also influence Centre–State legislative relations.
Unlike a rigid federation, the Indian Constitution establishes a strong Union with a flexible federal structure. It divides legislative authority based on territory and subject matter, while also empowering Parliament to legislate on State List subjects under specified extraordinary circumstances. The Constitution further provides mechanisms through which the Union may exercise control over State legislation.
Dimensions of Legislative Relations
The legislative relationship between the Centre and the States can be studied under four broad heads:
The Constitution defines the territorial jurisdiction of legislative powers as follows:
(i) Parliament’s Territorial Jurisdiction
(ii) State Legislature’s Territorial Jurisdiction
(iii) Extra-territorial Legislation by Parliament
Parliament alone possesses the power to enact extra-territorial legislation. Such laws may apply:
Constitutional Limitations
Although Parliament enjoys extensive territorial jurisdiction, certain constitutional exceptions exist:
| Area | Constitutional Position |
|---|---|
| Union Territories | The President may make regulations for specified Union Territories, which have the same force as an Act of Parliament. |
| Scheduled Areas | The Governor may direct that an Act of Parliament shall not apply or shall apply with modifications to Scheduled Areas within a State. |
| Autonomous Districts of Assam | The Governor may modify or exclude the application of Parliamentary laws. |
| Autonomous Districts of Meghalaya, Tripura and Mizoram | Similar powers are exercised by the President under the Sixth Schedule. |
The Constitution adopts a three-fold distribution of legislative powers under the Seventh Schedule.
| List | Legislature | Present Number of Subjects* | Examples |
|---|---|---|---|
| Union List (List I) | Parliament | 98 | Defence, Foreign Affairs, Atomic Energy, Banking, Currency, Insurance, Railways, Telecommunications, Inter-State Trade |
| State List (List II) | State Legislatures | 59 | Police, Public Order, Public Health, Agriculture, Local Government, Fisheries, Markets, Prisons |
| Concurrent List (List III) | Parliament and State Legislatures | 52 | Criminal Law, Civil Procedure, Marriage, Divorce, Education, Forests, Labour Welfare, Electricity, Population Control |
Note: The 42nd Constitutional Amendment Act, 1976 transferred five subjects from the State List to the Concurrent List:
- Education
- Forests
- Protection of Wild Animals and Birds
- Weights and Measures
- Administration of Justice (organisation of courts except the Supreme Court and High Courts)
Union Territories
Parliament has exclusive authority to legislate for Union Territories on any subject, including matters mentioned in the State List.
Goods and Services Tax (GST)
Following the 101st Constitutional Amendment Act, 2016:
Residuary Powers
Any subject not mentioned in any of the three lists falls under the residuary powers, which belong exclusively to Parliament (Article 248).
Examples include:
The Constitution establishes a hierarchy among the three lists.
| Conflict Between | Prevailing Authority |
|---|---|
| Union List vs State List | Union List prevails |
| Union List vs Concurrent List | Union List prevails |
| Concurrent List vs State List | Concurrent List prevails |
Where a Central law and a State law on a Concurrent List subject are inconsistent:
then the State law prevails within that State.
Nevertheless, Parliament may subsequently override such State legislation by enacting another law.
Although State List subjects normally fall within the exclusive jurisdiction of State Legislatures, the Constitution permits Parliament to legislate on these subjects under five exceptional circumstances.
Parliament may legislate on a State List subject if:
Validity
While a National Emergency is in operation:
If two or more State Legislatures pass resolutions requesting Parliament to legislate on a State List subject:
Examples
Parliament may legislate on any subject—including State List matters—to implement:
Examples include legislation implementing environmental agreements, international civil aviation obligations, and intellectual property commitments under TRIPS.
When President’s Rule is imposed in a State:
The Constitution provides several mechanisms through which the Union exercises legislative supervision over the States.
Reservation of Bills
The Governor may reserve certain Bills passed by the State Legislature for the consideration of the President. The President may:
Previous Presidential Sanction
Certain State Bills can be introduced only after obtaining the previous sanction of the President, particularly where Union interests may be affected.
Reservation of Financial Bills During Financial Emergency
During a Financial Emergency (Article 360), the President may direct States to reserve specified Money Bills or Financial Bills for Presidential consideration.
| Topic | Key Constitutional Provision |
|---|---|
| Legislative Relations | Articles 245–255 |
| Territorial Jurisdiction | Article 245 |
| Distribution of Legislative Powers | Article 246 & Seventh Schedule |
| Residuary Powers | Article 248 |
| Rajya Sabha Resolution | Article 249 |
| National Emergency | Article 250 |
| Conflict between Central and State Laws | Article 254 |
| Parliament on Request of States | Article 252 |
| International Agreements | Article 253 |
| President’s Rule | Article 356 |
| Financial Emergency | Article 360 |
Administrative relations define the distribution and exercise of executive powers between the Union and the States. While legislative powers are divided under the Seventh Schedule, executive powers generally follow the same pattern. However, to ensure national unity, effective governance, and constitutional compliance, the Constitution grants the Union certain supervisory and coordinating powers over the States.
The constitutional framework governing Centre–State administrative relations is primarily contained in Articles 256–263 of Part XI, along with several other relevant provisions.
Administrative relations may be studied under the following heads:
The executive powers of the Union and the States generally correspond to their respective legislative powers.
Executive Power of the Union
The executive power of the Union extends to:
Executive Power of the States
The executive power of a State extends to matters on which the State Legislature has exclusive legislative authority (State List).
Concurrent List
For subjects included in the Concurrent List:
The Constitution imposes two important obligations upon every State:
(i) Compliance with Parliamentary Laws
The executive power of every State shall be exercised so as to ensure compliance with:
(ii) Non-Interference with Union Executive Power
A State shall exercise its executive authority in a manner that does not impede or prejudice the exercise of the Union’s executive power.
Constitutional Consequence
Under Article 365, if a State fails to comply with Union directions, the President may hold that the constitutional machinery in the State has failed, which may lead to the imposition of President’s Rule under Article 356.
The Union Government may issue directions to States in matters of national importance, including:
Failure to comply with these directions may attract action under Articles 365 and 356.
To ensure administrative efficiency and cooperative federalism, the Constitution permits delegation of executive functions.
Delegation by the President
The President may, with the consent of the State Government, entrust Union executive functions to the State Government.
Delegation by the Governor
Similarly, the Governor may, with the consent of the Union Government, entrust State executive functions to the Union.
Delegation by Parliament
Parliament may, by law, confer powers or impose duties upon States regarding Union subjects, even without the consent of the State Government.
The Constitution provides several institutional mechanisms to promote cooperation.
(i) Inter-State River Water Disputes
Parliament may enact laws for the adjudication of disputes relating to the use, distribution, and control of inter-State rivers and river valleys.
(ii) Inter-State Council (Article 263)
The President may establish an Inter-State Council to:
(iii) Full Faith and Credit
Public acts, records, and judicial proceedings of the Union and every State are recognised throughout India.
(iv) Interstate Trade Authority
Parliament may appoint an authority to administer constitutional provisions relating to interstate trade, commerce and intercourse.
India follows a unique administrative model in which certain civil services serve both the Union and the States.
Present All India Services
Constitutional Provision
Article 312 empowers Parliament to create new All India Services if the Rajya Sabha passes a resolution supported by a two-thirds majority of members present and voting.
Features
Significance
All India Services:
The Constitution creates independent Public Service Commissions at the Union and State levels.
Centre–State Relations in Public Service Commissions
| Provision | Constitutional Position |
|---|---|
| Removal of State PSC Chairman/Members | Only by the President |
| Joint State Public Service Commission | Parliament may establish for two or more States on their request |
| UPSC Assistance | UPSC may assist a State Government with Presidential approval |
| Joint Recruitment | UPSC may assist States in framing schemes for joint recruitment requiring special qualifications |
Unlike many federal countries, India has a single integrated judiciary.
Features
Centre’s Role
The Centre’s administrative authority expands considerably during emergencies.
(i) National Emergency (Article 352)
(ii) President’s Rule (Article 356)
(iii) Financial Emergency (Article 360)
The Union may direct States regarding:
Duties of the Union (Article 355)
The Union has the constitutional duty:
Governor
State Election Commissioner
Although appointed by the Governor, the State Election Commissioner can be removed only in the manner and on the grounds applicable to a High Court Judge, ensuring independence.
Besides constitutional provisions, several institutions strengthen cooperative federalism.
Important Institutions
Important Conferences
Regular conferences facilitate Centre–State coordination, including:
| Topic | Constitutional Provision |
|---|---|
| Administrative Relations | Articles 256–263 |
| Obligation of States | Article 256 |
| Union Directions to States | Articles 256–257 |
| Inter-State Council | Article 263 |
| Duty of the Union | Article 355 |
| Failure to Comply with Union Directions | Article 365 |
| President’s Rule | Article 356 |
| National Emergency | Article 352 |
| Financial Emergency | Article 360 |
| All India Services | Article 312 |
| High Court Judges | Articles 217 & 222 |
Financial relations constitute one of the most significant aspects of Indian federalism. They regulate the distribution of taxing powers, financial resources, grants, borrowing powers, and fiscal responsibilities between the Union and the States. Since revenue generation and expenditure responsibilities are not evenly distributed, the Constitution establishes a comprehensive framework to maintain fiscal balance while preserving the autonomy of the States.
The constitutional provisions governing Centre–State financial relations are primarily contained in Articles 268–293 of Part XII, supplemented by other provisions such as the Finance Commission (Article 280) and the Goods and Services Tax (GST) Council (Article 279A).
Financial relations may be studied under the following heads:
The Constitution distributes taxation powers between the Union and the States through the Seventh Schedule.
Union Taxing Powers
Parliament has exclusive authority to levy taxes on subjects enumerated in the Union List.
Examples include:
State Taxing Powers
State Legislatures have exclusive authority to levy taxes on subjects enumerated in the State List.
Examples include:
Goods and Services Tax (GST)
The 101st Constitutional Amendment Act, 2016 introduced a major exception.
Both Parliament and State Legislatures have concurrent power to legislate on GST.
However,
Residuary Taxation Powers
Taxes not mentioned in any of the three lists fall under the residuary powers, which belong exclusively to Parliament (Article 248).
Constitutional Restrictions on State Taxation
The Constitution imposes certain limitations upon States.
States cannot tax:
Other restrictions include:
The Constitution distinguishes between:
This ensures equitable fiscal distribution between the Union and the States.
The present scheme was substantially revised by:
A. Taxes Levied by the Centre but Collected and Appropriated by the States (Article 268)
Examples include:
The entire proceeds belong to the States.
B. Taxes Levied and Collected by the Centre but Assigned to the States (Article 269)
Includes taxes on specified inter-State transactions.
The net proceeds are assigned to the concerned States according to principles prescribed by Parliament.
C. GST on Inter-State Trade (Article 269A)
IGST is:
D. Taxes Levied and Collected by the Centre but Shared with the States (Article 270)
Most Central taxes fall within this category.
The distribution of net proceeds is based on the recommendations of the Finance Commission.
E. Surcharge for Union Purposes (Article 271)
Parliament may levy surcharges on certain Central taxes.
Important Points:
F. Taxes Levied, Collected and Retained by the States
These include taxes assigned exclusively to the States under the State List.
Examples:
Major non-tax sources include:
Major sources include:
To reduce vertical and horizontal fiscal imbalances, the Constitution provides for grants from the Union to the States.
Parliament may provide grants to States requiring financial assistance.
These grants include:
They are provided on the recommendations of the Finance Commission.
Both the Union and the States may make grants for any public purpose, even beyond their legislative competence.
These grants provide flexibility in financing:
Article 279A
The GST Council was established through the 101st Constitutional Amendment Act, 2016.
The Council recommends:
The GST Council is an important institution of cooperative fiscal federalism.
Article 280
The President constitutes a Finance Commission every five years, or earlier if necessary.
A Chairman and four other members appointed by the President.
The Finance Commission recommends:
The Finance Commission is regarded as the balancing wheel of fiscal federalism in India.
Certain financial Bills affecting States may be introduced in Parliament only on the recommendation of the President.
These include Bills relating to:
The Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) certifies the net proceeds of taxes, and such certification is final.
The Union may:
A State may:
Where a State has outstanding loans guaranteed or advanced by the Union, it cannot raise additional loans without the consent of the Central Government.
The Constitution provides reciprocal tax immunities between the Union and the States.
Property of the Union is generally exempt from State taxation unless Parliament provides otherwise.
Property and income of States are generally exempt from Union taxation.
However,
During a National Emergency:
During a Financial Emergency, the Union may direct States:
| Topic | Constitutional Provision |
|---|---|
| Financial Relations | Articles 268–293 |
| Taxes Levied by Centre but Collected by States | Article 268 |
| Taxes Assigned to States | Article 269 |
| GST on Inter-State Trade (IGST) | Article 269A |
| Distribution of Central Taxes | Article 270 |
| Surcharge for Union | Article 271 |
| Grants-in-Aid | Article 275 |
| Discretionary Grants | Article 282 |
| GST Council | Article 279A |
| Finance Commission | Article 280 |
| Union Borrowing | Article 292 |
| State Borrowing | Article 293 |
| Financial Emergency | Article 360 |