← Back The South Asian Security Environment Download PDF
PoliPrepHub
Making Political Science Easy
poliprephub.in

International Relations of South Asia

The South Asian Security Environment

By Brajabandhu Mahanta•November 17, 2026•18 min read

South Asia is often described as one of the most dangerous and least integrated regions in the world. It has two nuclear-armed rivals (India and Pakistan) and a third nuclear power on its border (China). It has experienced several inter-state wars, long-running insurgencies, terrorism, mass migration and frequent political crises. At the same time, its states have very weak regional cooperation. To test the claims of structural realism, we must first understand this security environment in full.

Meaning of security

Key features of the South Asian security environment

  1. Enduring rivalries: India–Pakistan (since 1947) and India–China (since the late 1950s).
  2. Nuclearisation: India and Pakistan tested nuclear weapons in May 1998; China has been nuclear since 1964.
  3. India-centric asymmetry: India’s size and centrality shape the fears of all its neighbours.
  4. Intertwined internal and external threats: ethnic, religious and separatist movements cross borders and become inter-state issues.
  5. Non-state actors: terrorist and militant groups operate across borders.
  6. Extra-regional powers: the USA, the Soviet Union/Russia, China and Gulf states have long shaped regional conflicts.
  7. Weak regional institutions: SAARC has not functioned effectively; there is no regional security arrangement.
  8. Non-traditional threats: poverty, climate change, water disputes, natural disasters, migration and pandemics affect millions.

A short history of conflict in the region

PeriodMajor security events
1947–1949Partition violence; first India–Pakistan war over Kashmir
1962India–China war
1965Second India–Pakistan war
1971Bangladesh Liberation War; third India–Pakistan war
1974India’s first nuclear test (Pokhran-I)
1979–1989Soviet invasion of Afghanistan; Pakistan becomes a frontline state
1983–2009Sri Lankan civil war; IPKF in Sri Lanka (1987–90)
1989 onwardInsurgency in Jammu and Kashmir
1998India and Pakistan nuclear tests
1999Kargil war
2001–02Parliament attack and Operation Parakram (military standoff)
2008Mumbai terror attacks
2016, 2019Uri and Pulwama attacks; India’s surgical strikes and Balakot air strike
2017, 2020Doklam standoff and Galwan clash with China
2021Taliban return to power in Afghanistan
2025Pahalgam attack and Operation Sindoor (India–Pakistan); Pakistan–Afghanistan border clashes

The India–Pakistan Rivalry

The India–Pakistan rivalry is the central security problem of South Asia. Scholars such as T.V. Paul (The India–Pakistan Conflict: An Enduring Rivalry, 2005) call it an “enduring rivalry”: a long-lasting, intense conflict marked by repeated crises and wars.

Roots of the rivalry

Wars and crises

The 2025 crisis: Pahalgam and Operation Sindoor

Significance for realism

The India–China Rivalry

China is not a South Asian state, but it borders India, Pakistan, Nepal, Bhutan and Afghanistan and is deeply involved in the region. Many scholars therefore treat China as part of the South Asian security system, or speak of a wider “Southern Asia”.

Roots of the rivalry

Recent crises and thaw

Significance for realism

India-centric Asymmetry and the Smaller Neighbours

South Asia’s security environment is shaped by a basic fact: India is far larger than all its neighbours combined, and it sits at the geographic centre of the region. This creates an asymmetric power structure.

India’s perspective

The smaller neighbours’ perspective

Concepts to use

Role of Extra-regional Powers

Outside powers have always been part of South Asia’s security environment. Regional rivals have invited them in to balance each other, and great powers have used the region for their own strategic aims.

The Cold War period (1947–1991)

After the Cold War

Effects on regional security

Afghanistan and the North-western Frontier

Afghanistan links South Asia with Central Asia, Iran and the Middle East. It has been the region’s most unstable frontier for more than four decades.

Key phases

Pakistan–Afghanistan tensions since 2021

India and Afghanistan

Significance

Internal and Non-traditional Security Threats

For most South Asian states, the most frequent and deadly threats come from within or from non-military, transnational sources. This is a key point for the critique of structural realism.

Internal security threats

StateMain internal threats
IndiaInsurgency and terrorism in Jammu and Kashmir; ethnic insurgencies in the north-east (Naga, Manipur, earlier Mizo and Assam); Maoist (Left-wing extremist) insurgency; communal violence
PakistanTTP and other jihadi militancy; Baloch insurgency; sectarian violence; political instability
BangladeshIslamist militancy (e.g., the 2016 Holey Artisan attack); political violence; the Rohingya refugee crisis
Sri LankaLegacy of the civil war (1983–2009); Easter Sunday attacks (2019); economic crisis and protests (2022)
NepalMaoist insurgency (1996–2006); Madhesi unrest; Gen Z protests (2025)
AfghanistanTaliban rule; ISIS-Khorasan attacks; ethnic tension; humanitarian crisis

Terrorism and non-state actors

Non-traditional security threats

Significance

These threats show that the referent object of security in South Asia is often the people or society, not just the state’s territory. They cannot be solved by military power or balance of power alone; they need cooperation, development and good governance. This is a major limit of structural realism, which the next topics develop.

The Indian Ocean Dimension

South Asian security is not only continental. The Indian Ocean is increasingly important for trade, energy and great-power competition.

Significance: the maritime dimension shows South Asian security being drawn into wider Indo-Pacific great-power competition, where realist ideas of balancing and hegemony are often used, but where cooperation on non-traditional threats is equally important.

Regional Security Cooperation: Attempts and Limits

SAARC and other regional bodies

Confidence-building measures (CBMs)

Conclusion

The South Asian security environment is shaped by enduring rivalries (India–Pakistan and India–China), nuclear weapons, India’s central and dominant position, the involvement of outside powers, the instability of Afghanistan, and a wide range of internal and non-traditional threats. Recent events (the 2025 India–Pakistan conflict and the suspension of the Indus Waters Treaty, the Pakistan–Afghanistan clashes, the slow India–China thaw, and the new Saudi–Pakistan defence pact) show that this environment remains volatile.

Some of these features (arms races, alliances, balancing, deterrence) seem to confirm structural realism. Others (terrorism by non-state actors, identity-based hostility, internal insurgencies, regime insecurity, refugee flows, climate and water stress) fall outside its state-centric and military focus. The next topic examines what structural realism explains well in South Asia, before the following topic examines where it fails.

Quick Revision

ItemKey fact
Simla Agreement1972; ceasefire line renamed Line of Control
Indus Waters Treaty1960, World Bank-mediated; held “in abeyance” by India since April 2025
Operation SindoorIndia’s strikes on Pakistan, 7 May 2025; ceasefire 10 May 2025
India–China war1962
Galwan clashJune 2020
India–China disengagement agreementOctober 2024 (Depsang and Demchok)
Indo-Soviet TreatyAugust 1971
Pakistan in SEATO and CENTO1954 and 1955
Indo-US Civil Nuclear Agreement2005–08
Saudi–Pakistan Strategic Mutual Defence Agreement17 September 2025
Pakistan–Afghanistan border clashesOctober 2025; temporary ceasefire on 15 October 2025
Indian Ocean as a Zone of PeaceUN General Assembly, 1971
Human Development Report on human securityUNDP, 1994 (Mahbub ul Haq)
Last SAARC summitKathmandu, 2014

Key doctrines: Indira Doctrine (no outside intervention in the neighbourhood), Gujral Doctrine (non-reciprocal generosity), Neighbourhood First (2014), SAGAR (2015) and MAHASAGAR (2025).

Exam Practice

Long-answer questions

  1. Describe the main features of the South Asian security environment.
  2. Why is the India–Pakistan relationship called an “enduring rivalry”? Discuss with reference to recent developments.
  3. Examine the role of extra-regional powers in shaping South Asian security.
  4. How does India-centric asymmetry shape the security perceptions of the smaller South Asian states?
  5. Discuss the growing importance of non-traditional security threats in South Asia.
  6. Analyse the significance of Afghanistan for South Asian security after 2021.
  7. Evaluate the role of SAARC and confidence-building measures in regional security.

Short-answer questions

  1. Enduring rivalry
  2. Line of Actual Control
  3. Indira Doctrine
  4. Gujral Doctrine
  5. String of pearls
  6. Human security
  7. Operation Sindoor
  8. Strategic depth
  9. Colombo Security Conclave
  10. Stability-instability paradox

MCQs (UGC-NET / OPSC style)

  1. Which doctrine emphasised non-reciprocal concessions to India’s smaller neighbours?
    • (a) Indira Doctrine (b) Gujral Doctrine (c) Look East (d) Neighbourhood First
    • Answer: (b)
  2. The Indus Waters Treaty was signed in:
    • (a) 1950 (b) 1960 (c) 1972 (d) 1996
    • Answer: (b)
  3. The Galwan clash between India and China took place in:
    • (a) 2017 (b) 2019 (c) 2020 (d) 2022
    • Answer: (c)
  4. Which of the following is NOT a member of BIMSTEC?
    • (a) Nepal (b) Thailand (c) Pakistan (d) Myanmar
    • Answer: (c)
  5. The concept of human security was popularised by the UNDP Human Development Report of:
    • (a) 1990 (b) 1994 (c) 2000 (d) 2005
    • Answer: (b)
  6. The term “enduring rivalry” for India–Pakistan relations is associated with:
    • (a) T.V. Paul (b) Kenneth Waltz (c) Stephen Cohen (d) Barry Buzan
    • Answer: (a)
  7. Match the following:
    • A. Doklam standoff – 1. 1999
    • B. Kargil war – 2. 2017
    • C. Operation Cactus – 3. 2025
    • D. Operation Sindoor – 4. 1988
    • Answer: A-2, B-1, C-4, D-3
  8. Assertion (A): Smaller South Asian states often build ties with China. Reason (R): They seek to balance or hedge against India’s dominance.
    • Answer: Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
  9. Buzan’s five sectors of security do NOT include:
    • (a) Military (b) Societal (c) Environmental (d) Cultural
    • Answer: (d)
  10. Which pair signed a Strategic Mutual Defence Agreement in September 2025?
    • (a) China–Pakistan (b) Saudi Arabia–Pakistan (c) USA–India (d) Turkey–Pakistan
    • Answer: (b)

Suggested readings

Sources for recent developments

Category: International Relations of South Asia
Tag: South Asian Security
Source: https://poliprephub.in/international-relations-of-south-asia/the-south-asian-security-environment/
© PoliPrepHub · Generated on November 18, 2026