← Back Structural Realism: Concepts and Assumptions Download PDF
PoliPrepHub
Making Political Science Easy
poliprephub.in

International Relations of South Asia

Structural Realism: Concepts and Assumptions

By Brajabandhu Mahanta•November 17, 2026•20 min read

Realism is the oldest and most influential theory of International Relations (IR). It explains world politics as a continuous struggle for power and security among states in a world without a central authority. Structural realism (also called neorealism) is the modern, scientific version of realism developed by Kenneth Waltz in the late 1970s. It explains state behaviour mainly through the structure of the international system, not through human nature or the domestic character of states.

Why study structural realism in a paper on South Asia?

The realist tradition at a glance

PhaseMain thinkersMain source of conflict
Ancient and early modern thoughtThucydides, Kautilya, Machiavelli, HobbesFear, ambition, human nature, the absence of a common power
Classical realism (1939–1970s)E.H. Carr, Hans Morgenthau, Reinhold Niebuhr, George KennanHuman nature: the desire for power (“animus dominandi”)
Structural realism or neorealism (from 1979)Kenneth Waltz, Robert Jervis, Stephen Walt, John MearsheimerStructure of the system: anarchy and the distribution of power
Neoclassical realism (from late 1990s)Gideon Rose, Randall Schweller, Fareed ZakariaSystemic pressure filtered through domestic factors

Key idea for exams: classical realism says states seek power because human nature is power-hungry; structural realism says states seek security because the anarchic structure of the system forces them to, whatever their leaders or internal politics are like.

Classical Realism: The Background

Structural realism grew out of, and partly against, classical realism. A clear idea of classical realism helps to show what is new in Waltz.

Early roots

Twentieth-century classical realism

Morgenthau’s six principles of political realism

  1. Politics, like society, is governed by objective laws rooted in human nature.
  2. The key concept is interest defined in terms of power.
  3. Interest defined as power is a universal category, but its content changes with time and place.
  4. Universal moral principles cannot be applied directly to state actions; prudence is the supreme political virtue.
  5. The moral aspirations of a particular nation must not be identified with universal moral laws.
  6. The political sphere is autonomous; the political realist asks “How does this policy affect the power of the nation?”

Limits of classical realism (which led to neorealism)

Kenneth Waltz and the Structure of the International System

Kenneth N. Waltz (1924–2013), an American political scientist, is the founder of structural realism. His two key books are Man, the State and War (1959) and Theory of International Politics (1979).

The three “images” of war (Man, the State and War, 1959)

Waltz asked: what causes war? He found three levels of explanation, which he called “images”:

  1. First image: the individual (human nature): wars happen because of selfishness, aggression or stupidity of human beings (classical realists, St Augustine, Niebuhr).
  2. Second image: the state (internal structure): wars happen because of the nature of particular states, for example authoritarian or capitalist states (liberals, Marxists).
  3. Third image: the international system (anarchy): wars happen because there is no authority above states to prevent them. As Rousseau’s stag hunt shows, even well-meaning actors may fail to cooperate without trust and enforcement.

Waltz concluded that the first two images explain particular causes, but the third image explains why war is always possible: “wars occur because there is nothing to prevent them”.

Theory of International Politics (1979)

The three elements of structure

Waltz defined the structure of any political system by three elements:

ElementIn a domestic political systemIn the international system
Ordering principleHierarchy: a government with authority to command and enforceAnarchy: no world government above sovereign states
Character (function) of the unitsUnits are differentiated: different institutions perform different functionsUnits are functionally similar (“like units”): every state must perform the same basic tasks (defence, taxation, law)
Distribution of capabilitiesVaries, but the ordering principle matters moreThe key variable: how power is distributed among states (polarity)

How structure shapes behaviour

Waltz said structure works through two processes:

Therefore, states tend to behave similarly in similar structural positions, whatever their ideology or regime type. A democracy and a dictatorship facing the same threat will both balance against it.

Core Concepts and Assumptions of Structural Realism

Basic assumptions

  1. States are the main actors in international politics. Non-state actors (MNCs, NGOs, terrorist groups) matter less.
  2. The system is anarchic: there is no world government to protect states or enforce agreements.
  3. States are unitary and rational actors: they act as single units and choose the best means to achieve their goals.
  4. Survival is the primary goal of every state. As Waltz said, states at a minimum seek their own preservation and, at a maximum, drive for universal domination; but survival comes first.
  5. States can never be sure of others’ intentions: today’s friend may become tomorrow’s enemy, so states must plan for the worst case.

Anarchy

Self-help

Power and capabilities

Balance of power

Relative gains vs absolute gains

Security dilemma

Polarity and stability

Nuclear weapons and deterrence

After Waltz, structural realism developed into different branches that disagree on how much power states want and how dangerous anarchy really is.

Defensive realism

Stephen Walt’s balance of threat theory

Offensive realism

Neoclassical realism

Summary

All these variants share the realist core (anarchy, states, power, survival), but differ on whether states are security-seekers (defensive) or power-maximisers (offensive), and on how much domestic factors matter (neoclassical).

Comparison Tables

Classical realism vs structural realism

Point of comparisonClassical realismStructural realism (neorealism)
Main thinkersMorgenthau, Carr, NiebuhrWaltz, Mearsheimer, Walt, Jervis
Key textPolitics Among Nations (1948)Theory of International Politics (1979)
Root cause of conflictHuman nature (lust for power)Anarchic structure of the system
Level of analysisFirst and second image (individuals, states)Third image (international system)
Power seen asAn end in itselfA means to security (Waltz); maximised (Mearsheimer)
MethodHistorical, philosophical, normativeScientific, deductive, parsimonious
Role of statesmen and moralityPrudence and statesmanship are centralLittle attention to individuals or ethics
Domestic politicsImportant (national character, morale, diplomacy)Largely ignored (states are “like units”)
Theory ofForeign policy and international politicsInternational politics only

Defensive vs offensive realism

Point of comparisonDefensive realismOffensive realism
Main thinkersWaltz, Jervis, Van Evera, WaltMearsheimer
Goal of statesSecurity; “appropriate” powerMaximum relative power; hegemony
Effect of anarchyEncourages cautionEncourages expansion when possible
ExpansionUsually self-defeating; provokes balancingRational when the opportunity exists
Status quo or revisionistMost states are status quoAll great powers are revisionist until hegemony
Explanation of aggressive behaviourDomestic distortions, misperceptionStructural incentive
Rise of ChinaCan be managed peacefullyLikely to lead to intense competition

Structural realism vs its main rivals

Point of comparisonStructural realismNeoliberal institutionalismConstructivism
Main thinkersWaltz, MearsheimerRobert Keohane, Joseph NyeAlexander Wendt, Nicholas Onuf, Peter Katzenstein
Nature of anarchyFixed and conflict-producingFixed, but cooperation possible“What states make of it” (Wendt, 1992)
Main actorsStatesStates, institutions, transnational actorsStates and social agents shaped by norms
Main concernRelative gains, securityAbsolute gains, cooperationIdentity, norms, ideas
Role of institutionsReflect power; little independent effectReduce uncertainty and cheatingShape identities and interests
Key conceptsBalance of power, security dilemmaComplex interdependence, regimesSocial construction, identity, norms

Strengths and General Criticisms

Strengths and contributions

  1. Scientific and parsimonious: explains major patterns of world politics (recurring war, balance of power, alliances) with a few variables.
  2. Systemic view: shows that outcomes can be produced by the structure of the system, even when no state intends them (for example, the security dilemma).
  3. Explains continuity: why conflict and power politics persist across centuries, regimes and ideologies.
  4. Useful for security studies: concepts like the security dilemma, deterrence, balance of power and polarity remain central tools for analysing military competition, including in South Asia.
  5. Explains the Cold War “long peace” through bipolarity and nuclear deterrence.
  6. Policy relevance: warns against idealism and over-expansion (Waltz and Mearsheimer opposed the 2003 Iraq War on realist grounds).

General criticisms

  1. Neoliberal institutionalism (Robert Keohane and Joseph Nye, Power and Interdependence, 1977; Keohane, After Hegemony, 1984): states can cooperate through institutions and regimes; economic interdependence makes war costly; absolute gains matter.
  2. Constructivism (Alexander Wendt, “Anarchy is What States Make of It”, 1992; Social Theory of International Politics, 1999): anarchy has no fixed logic. It can produce enmity (Hobbesian), rivalry (Lockean) or friendship (Kantian) depending on shared ideas and identities. India–Pakistan enmity and India–Bhutan friendship exist under the same anarchy.
  3. Failure to predict the end of the Cold War: neorealism, focused on material structure, did not foresee the peaceful collapse of the USSR, which came from ideas, domestic change and leadership (Gorbachev).
  4. Ignores domestic politics and individuals: by treating states as “like units” and black boxes, it cannot explain why states with similar positions behave differently (a point developed by neoclassical realists and liberals, including the democratic peace theory).
  5. Critical theory (Robert Cox, 1981): neorealism is a “problem-solving theory” that takes the existing order for granted and serves the interests of the powerful; “theory is always for someone and for some purpose”.
  6. Richard Ashley (“The Poverty of Neorealism”, 1984): criticised its positivism and state-centrism.
  7. John Ruggie: neorealism cannot explain transformation of the system (e.g., the shift from medieval to modern states).
  8. Feminist critique (J. Ann Tickner, Gender in International Relations, 1992; Cynthia Enloe): realism’s concepts of power and security reflect a masculine view and ignore human and gendered insecurities.
  9. Third World or post-colonial critique (Mohammed Ayoob, Stephanie Neuman ed., International Relations Theory and the Third World, 1998; Amitav Acharya and Barry Buzan, Non-Western International Relations Theory, 2010): neorealism is Eurocentric and great-power-centric. In Third World states, the main threats are internal, sovereignty is contested, and states are weak, so the anarchy–external threat model does not fit. This criticism is the basis of the next topics in this unit.
  10. Human security and non-traditional security: neorealism ignores threats such as poverty, disease, climate change, migration and terrorism by non-state actors.

Relevance to South Asia: A First Look

This topic is the base for the rest of Unit II. The table below previews how each core concept will be applied and tested in the next topics.

Structural realist conceptHow it seems to apply in South AsiaQuestion to test later
Anarchy and self-helpNo regional authority; SAARC is weak; states rely on their own forcesDo internal threats matter more than anarchy?
Balance of power and alliancesPakistan balances India through ties with the USA (1950s–60s, 1980s, 2001 onward) and China; India’s treaty with the USSR (1971)Is it balancing against power, threat or identity?
Balance of threat (Walt)Neighbours see India as close, powerful and potentially threateningWhy do some neighbours (Bhutan) bandwagon instead?
Security dilemma and arms raceIndia–Pakistan and India–China military competitionIs the rivalry driven by structure or by identity and history?
Nuclear deterrence (Waltz)Both India and Pakistan tested in 1998; no full-scale war sinceHas deterrence brought stability, or more risky crises (Kargil 1999, 2001–02, 2019, 2025)?
PolarityCold War bipolarity shaped alignments; today US–China rivalry shapes South AsiaHow far do great powers drive regional conflicts?
Regional hegemony (Mearsheimer)India’s quest for primacy in South Asia and the Indian OceanIs India a benign or a hegemonic power?
States as unitary rational actorsGovernments make security policyWhat about non-state actors, army dominance and ethnic insurgents?

Indian and South Asian strategic thought

Conclusion

Structural realism, developed by Kenneth Waltz, explains international politics through the anarchic structure of the system and the distribution of power among states. Its core concepts (self-help, balance of power, the security dilemma, polarity, relative gains and deterrence) remain powerful tools for understanding conflict and competition. Its later branches (defensive, offensive and neoclassical realism, and Walt’s balance of threat) refine the theory in different directions.

But structural realism was built mainly on the experience of European great powers and the Cold War. It treats states as unitary actors, ignores domestic politics, identity and non-state actors, and focuses on external military threats. In South Asia, where states are post-colonial, internally insecure and identity-driven, these assumptions face serious challenges. Understanding the theory clearly is therefore the first step to understanding its limits in explaining South Asian security, which is the theme of the following topics.

Quick Revision: Thinkers and Works

ThinkerKey workMain idea
ThucydidesHistory of the Peloponnesian WarRising power and fear cause war; Melian Dialogue
KautilyaArthashastraMandala theory; six-fold policy
Thomas HobbesLeviathan (1651)State of nature as war of all against all
E.H. CarrThe Twenty Years’ Crisis (1939)Critique of utopian idealism
Hans MorgenthauPolitics Among Nations (1948)Interest defined as power; six principles
Kenneth WaltzMan, the State and War (1959)Three images of war
Kenneth WaltzTheory of International Politics (1979)Structure: anarchy, like units, distribution of capabilities
Kenneth Waltz“The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More May Be Better” (1981)Nuclear proliferation can promote stability
John Herz“Idealist Internationalism and the Security Dilemma” (1950)Security dilemma
Robert Jervis“Cooperation under the Security Dilemma” (1978)Offence-defence balance
Stephen WaltThe Origins of Alliances (1987)Balance of threat
John MearsheimerThe Tragedy of Great Power Politics (2001)Offensive realism; regional hegemony; stopping power of water
Gideon Rose“Neoclassical Realism and Theories of Foreign Policy” (1998)Named neoclassical realism
Randall SchwellerUnanswered Threats (2006)Under-balancing
A.F.K. OrganskiWorld Politics (1958)Power transition theory
Robert GilpinWar and Change in World Politics (1981)Hegemonic war
Joseph Grieco“Anarchy and the Limits of Cooperation” (1988)Relative gains
Alexander Wendt“Anarchy is What States Make of It” (1992)Constructivist critique
Robert Cox“Social Forces, States and World Orders” (1981)Problem-solving vs critical theory

One-line memory aids

Exam Practice

Long-answer questions

  1. Explain the main assumptions of structural realism as developed by Kenneth Waltz.
  2. Distinguish between classical realism and structural realism.
  3. Compare defensive and offensive realism with suitable examples.
  4. What is the security dilemma? How does it explain arms races in South Asia?
  5. Explain Stephen Walt’s balance of threat theory. How is it different from Waltz’s balance of power theory?
  6. Critically evaluate structural realism with reference to its liberal, constructivist and Third World critics.
  7. “Anarchy is what states make of it.” Discuss this statement in the light of the neorealist view of anarchy.

Short-answer questions

  1. Anarchy
  2. Self-help system
  3. Security dilemma
  4. Balance of threat
  5. Relative gains
  6. Polarity
  7. Stopping power of water
  8. Neoclassical realism
  9. Buck-passing
  10. Three images of war

MCQs (UGC-NET / OPSC style)

  1. Theory of International Politics (1979) was written by:
    • (a) Hans Morgenthau (b) Kenneth Waltz (c) John Mearsheimer (d) Robert Keohane
    • Answer: (b)
  2. According to Waltz, which element of international structure changes over time?
    • (a) Ordering principle (b) Character of units (c) Distribution of capabilities (d) None of these
    • Answer: (c)
  3. The concept of “balance of threat” was given by:
    • (a) Stephen Walt (b) Robert Jervis (c) Joseph Nye (d) Hedley Bull
    • Answer: (a)
  4. Which of the following is NOT one of Walt’s sources of threat?
    • (a) Aggregate power (b) Geographic proximity (c) Regime type (d) Offensive intentions
    • Answer: (c)
  5. “The stopping power of water” is a concept associated with:
    • (a) Defensive realism (b) Offensive realism (c) Neoliberalism (d) Constructivism
    • Answer: (b)
  6. Who coined the term “neoclassical realism”?
    • (a) Fareed Zakaria (b) Gideon Rose (c) Randall Schweller (d) William Wohlforth
    • Answer: (b)
  7. Match the following:
    • A. Politics Among Nations – 1. John Mearsheimer
    • B. The Tragedy of Great Power Politics – 2. Hans Morgenthau
    • C. The Origins of Alliances – 3. Kenneth Waltz
    • D. Man, the State and War – 4. Stephen Walt
    • Answer: A-2, B-1, C-4, D-3
  8. Assertion (A): Structural realists argue that cooperation among states is difficult. Reason (R): States are concerned about relative gains in an anarchic system.
    • Answer: Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
  9. According to Waltz, the most stable international system is:
    • (a) Unipolar (b) Bipolar (c) Multipolar (d) Non-polar
    • Answer: (b)
  10. The security dilemma was first described by:
    • (a) John Herz (b) Kenneth Waltz (c) Alexander Wendt (d) Robert Keohane
    • Answer: (a) (along with Herbert Butterfield)

Suggested readings

Category: International Relations of South Asia
Tag: Structural Realism
Source: https://poliprephub.in/international-relations-of-south-asia/structural-realism-concepts-and-assumptions/
© PoliPrepHub · Generated on November 19, 2026