← Back Crises of Governance in South Asia Download PDF
PoliPrepHub
Making Political Science Easy
poliprephub.in

International Relations of South Asia

Crises of Governance in South Asia

By Brajabandhu Mahanta•November 18, 2026•15 min read

Topic 4 examined whether South Asian states are democratic. This topic asks a related but different question: how well are they governed? A state can hold regular elections and still suffer from corruption, weak institutions, poor service delivery, economic mismanagement and loss of public trust. When these problems become severe enough to threaten the state’s ability to function, maintain order or retain legitimacy, we speak of a crisis of governance.

South Asia has seen many such crises: the economic collapse and Aragalaya in Sri Lanka (2022), repeated balance-of-payments crises and political turmoil in Pakistan, the 2024 uprising in Bangladesh, the Gen Z protests in Nepal (2025), the Taliban takeover in Afghanistan (2021), and constitutional battles in the Maldives. Understanding these crises is essential, because weak governance at home is one of the main sources of insecurity in the region.

Key concepts

Theoretical perspectives

PerspectiveThinkerIdeaSouth Asian relevance
Political order and decaySamuel Huntington, Political Order in Changing Societies (1968)When participation grows faster than institutions, the result is instabilityRapid mobilisation in Bangladesh, Nepal, Pakistan
Strong societies, weak statesJoel Migdal (1988)Social forces (landlords, clans, strongmen) limit the state’s capacityFeudal and tribal power in Pakistan; local strongmen
Crisis of governabilityAtul Kohli, Democracy and Discontent (1990)Weakening institutions and rising demands create a “governability crisis” in IndiaIndia in the 1980s
Extractive vs inclusive institutionsDaron Acemoglu and James Robinson, Why Nations Fail (2012)Elites capture the state for their own benefitRent-seeking and patronage across the region
Patronage / clientelismKanchan Chandra and othersPolitics as the exchange of benefits for votesEthnic and caste-based patronage
Military guardianshipAqil Shah, Ayesha SiddiqaThe army sees itself as guardian of the nationPakistan, Bangladesh

Dimensions of the Governance Crisis

Weak institutions and institutional decay

Corruption

Civil–military imbalance

Dynastic and personalised politics

Over-centralisation and weak local government

Judicial weakness or overreach

Policing, rule of law and human rights

Majoritarianism and exclusion

Weak service delivery

Youth unemployment and the “demographic dividend”

Economic Governance Crises

Economic mismanagement has repeatedly turned into political crisis in South Asia. Debt, inflation and shortages directly affect people’s lives and can quickly destroy a government’s legitimacy.

Sri Lanka: from default to recovery

Pakistan: the IMF cycle

Bangladesh: growth with governance deficits

Nepal and the Maldives

Common features of economic governance crises

FeatureExamples
Unsustainable debt and twin deficitsSri Lanka, Pakistan, Maldives
Narrow tax base and elite exemptionsPakistan, Sri Lanka
Prestige projects and poor investment choicesSri Lanka (Hambantota), Pakistan (some CPEC projects)
Policy-making by small circlesSri Lanka (fertiliser ban), Pakistan
Dependence on remittances and external aidNepal, Bangladesh, Pakistan
Vulnerability to external shocksCOVID-19, floods, oil-price shocks, Middle East war

Country Profiles: Governance at a Glance

CountryMain governance challengesRecent crisis / turning point
IndiaJudicial delays, police reform, corruption, centre–state tensions, debates on institutional autonomy; ethnic violence in ManipurManipur crisis and President’s Rule (2025–26)
PakistanMilitary dominance, economic fragility, political polarisation, terrorism, weak provincesRemoval of Imran Khan (2022); 9 May 2023; 2024 election; 26th and 27th Amendments
BangladeshWinner-takes-all politics, politicised institutions, corruption, mob violence after 2024July 2024 uprising; February 2026 election and July Charter
Sri LankaDebt, ethnic reconciliation, executive presidency2022 default and Aragalaya; NPP government (2024)
NepalCoalition instability, corruption, weak federal institutions, youth exodusGen Z uprising (Sept 2025); RSP majority (March 2026)
BhutanSmall economy, youth migration (to Australia and elsewhere), dependence on hydropower and IndiaGelephu Mindfulness City project; generally good governance (best CPI score in region)
MaldivesStrong presidency, judicial crises, debt, radicalisation concernsConstitutional amendments; failed referendum (April 2026)
AfghanistanUnrecognised Taliban regime, humanitarian crisis, exclusion of women, terrorismTaliban takeover (August 2021)

India: a note on governance debates

Governance Crises and Regional Security

Why does governance belong in a course on International Relations? Because in South Asia domestic governance failures quickly become regional security problems.

  1. Internal conflict: poor governance, exclusion and repression fuel insurgencies (Balochistan, Manipur, Sri Lanka’s civil war, Nepal’s Maoists) – Topic 3.
  2. Terrorism and safe havens: weak state control allows militant groups to operate across borders (Afghanistan, Pakistan’s tribal areas).
  3. Refugees and migration: crises push people across borders (Rohingya, Afghans, Sri Lankan Tamils) – Topic 6.
  4. Diversionary nationalism: governments facing domestic trouble may use hostility to neighbours to rally support.
  5. External intervention and influence: weak or crisis-hit governments become dependent on outside powers for loans and support, opening the door to great-power competition (China, the US, the Gulf states, India).
  6. Regional cooperation suffers: unstable governments cannot make long-term commitments; SAARC has been paralysed since 2016.
  7. Nuclear security: political instability in a nuclear-armed state (Pakistan) raises concerns about command and control (Unit III).

India’s neighbourhood policy and governance crises

China’s role

Western and multilateral actors

Reforms and the Way Forward

Institutional reforms

  1. Independent institutions: protect the autonomy of election commissions, anti-corruption agencies, central banks, auditors and courts; transparent appointment processes (for example, Bangladesh’s July Charter proposals for a caretaker system and constitutional appointments).
  2. Judicial reform: reduce backlogs, use technology, ensure judicial independence.
  3. Police reform: implement the Prakash Singh directions in India; depoliticise police across the region.
  4. Decentralisation: empower provinces, local governments and panchayats with funds and functions.
  5. Civil–military balance: firm civilian control, parliamentary oversight of defence budgets.

Fighting corruption

Economic governance

Political culture

Regional cooperation

Conclusion

South Asia’s governance crises are not only about bad leaders; they reflect deep structural problems: weak and politicised institutions, corruption and elite capture, military dominance in some states, dynastic politics, over-centralisation, majoritarianism and fragile economies. When these problems combine with external shocks, they can produce sudden collapses, as in Sri Lanka in 2022, Bangladesh in 2024 and Nepal in 2025.

These crises matter for International Relations because they spill across borders: they fuel insurgency and terrorism, produce refugees, invite outside intervention and great-power competition, and paralyse regional cooperation. At the same time, the region also shows capacity for renewal: Sri Lanka’s economic recovery, peaceful elections in Bangladesh and Nepal, Bhutan’s relatively clean governance, and India’s digital governance innovations.

The central lesson is that security in South Asia depends as much on good governance at home as on military strength. A balanced exam answer should combine theory (Huntington, Migdal, Kohli, Acemoglu–Robinson), comparative evidence and recent examples.

Quick Revision

ItemKey fact
World Bank definition of governance1992, “manner in which power is exercised…”
Worldwide Governance Indicators6 dimensions (voice, stability, effectiveness, regulatory quality, rule of law, corruption control)
HuntingtonPolitical Order in Changing Societies (1968)
MigdalStrong Societies and Weak States (1988)
KohliDemocracy and Discontent (1990): crisis of governability
Acemoglu–RobinsonWhy Nations Fail (2012): extractive institutions
CPI 2025 (out of 100)Bhutan 71; India 39; Maldives 39; Sri Lanka 35; Nepal 34; Pakistan 28; Bangladesh 24; Afghanistan 16
Sri Lanka defaultApril 2022
Sri Lanka IMF programme2023 (~US$2.9 bn EFF)
India’s aid to Sri Lanka~US$4 bn in 2022
Pakistan IMF EFFUS$7 bn (2024)
Hambantota port lease2017 (99 years)
Prakash Singh judgment2006 (police reform)
2nd ARC2005–09
RTI Act (India)2005

One-line memory aids

Exam Practice

Long-answer questions

  1. What do you understand by a crisis of governance? Examine its main dimensions in South Asia.
  2. “Economic crises in South Asia are essentially crises of governance.” Discuss with reference to Sri Lanka and Pakistan.
  3. Examine the role of corruption and dynastic politics in the governance crises of South Asia.
  4. How do governance failures in South Asian states affect regional security?
  5. Discuss India’s role as a “first responder” to governance crises in its neighbourhood.
  6. Critically evaluate the “debt-trap diplomacy” argument with reference to Sri Lanka.
  7. Suggest reforms to address the crisis of governance in South Asia.

Short-answer questions

  1. Good governance
  2. Worldwide Governance Indicators
  3. Crisis of governability (Kohli)
  4. Strong societies, weak states (Migdal)
  5. Sri Lanka’s 2022 default
  6. Elite capture
  7. Debt-trap diplomacy
  8. Corruption Perceptions Index
  9. Prakash Singh judgment
  10. Neighbourhood First policy

MCQs (UGC-NET / OPSC style)

  1. Political Order in Changing Societies (1968) was written by:
    • (a) Robert Dahl (b) Samuel Huntington (c) Joel Migdal (d) Atul Kohli
    • Answer: (b)
  2. The concept of “strong societies and weak states” is associated with:
    • (a) Joel Migdal (b) Gabriel Almond (c) Lucian Pye (d) Myron Weiner
    • Answer: (a)
  3. Democracy and Discontent: India’s Growing Crisis of Governability was written by:
    • (a) Rajni Kothari (b) Atul Kohli (c) Paul Brass (d) Sunil Khilnani
    • Answer: (b)
  4. In the Corruption Perceptions Index 2025, the best-performing South Asian country was:
    • (a) India (b) Sri Lanka (c) Bhutan (d) Maldives
    • Answer: (c)
  5. Sri Lanka defaulted on its foreign debt for the first time in:
    • (a) 2019 (b) 2020 (c) 2022 (d) 2024
    • Answer: (c)
  6. Which of the following is NOT one of the World Bank’s six Worldwide Governance Indicators?
    • (a) Rule of law (b) Control of corruption (c) Regulatory quality (d) GDP growth
    • Answer: (d)
  7. Match the following:
    • A. Why Nations Fail – 1. Joel Migdal
    • B. Strong Societies and Weak States – 2. Acemoglu and Robinson
    • C. Political Order in Changing Societies – 3. Atul Kohli
    • D. Democracy and Discontent – 4. Samuel Huntington
    • Answer: A-2, B-1, C-4, D-3
  8. Assertion (A): Pakistan has entered into more than 20 IMF programmes. Reason (R): It has failed to carry out structural reforms such as broadening its tax base.
    • Answer: Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
  9. The Supreme Court judgment that laid down directions for police reform in India is:
    • (a) Kesavananda Bharati (b) Vineet Narain (c) Prakash Singh (d) S. R. Bommai
    • Answer: (c)
  10. The Hambantota port, often cited in the “debt-trap” debate, is located in:
    • (a) Maldives (b) Bangladesh (c) Sri Lanka (d) Pakistan
    • Answer: (c)

Suggested readings

Sources for recent developments

Category: International Relations of South Asia
Tag: Crises of Governance in South Asia
Source: https://poliprephub.in/international-relations-of-south-asia/crises-of-governance-in-south-asia/
© PoliPrepHub · Generated on November 19, 2026