← Back Borders and Boundaries in South Asia: Colonial Legacies and Disputes Download PDF
PoliPrepHub
Making Political Science Easy
poliprephub.in

International Relations of South Asia

Borders and Boundaries in South Asia: Colonial Legacies and Disputes

By Brajabandhu Mahanta•November 18, 2026•20 min read

South Asia is a region of contested borders. Almost every state in the region has an unsettled or disputed boundary with at least one neighbour. India alone shares land borders with seven countries (Pakistan, China, Nepal, Bhutan, Bangladesh, Myanmar and Afghanistan, the last through Pakistan-administered territory it claims) and maritime boundaries with Sri Lanka, the Maldives, Bangladesh, Pakistan, Myanmar, Thailand and Indonesia. Many of these lines were drawn by the British colonial state, often for imperial strategy rather than local realities. After independence, the new states inherited these lines and treated them as sacred markers of sovereignty and national identity.

This topic examines how the borders of South Asia were made, the major boundary disputes, and why borders remain a central issue of regional security.

Key concepts: frontier, boundary and border

Students must distinguish three related terms.

TermMeaningExample
FrontierA zone or belt of territory, often sparsely settled, between two political units; outward-looking and loosely controlledThe North-West Frontier of British India; the Himalayan frontier before the 20th century
BoundaryA precise line that legally separates the territory of two states; inward-lookingThe Radcliffe Line
BorderThe area on both sides of a boundary, including the people and institutions that live with it (borderland)The Punjab or Bengal borderlands

Stages of boundary making

The geographer Stephen B. Jones (1945) described four stages:

  1. Allocation: a political decision dividing territory (for example, Partition in 1947).
  2. Delimitation: describing the boundary line in a treaty or on a map.
  3. Demarcation: physically marking the line on the ground with pillars or fences.
  4. Administration: managing the boundary (customs, policing, maintenance).

Many South Asian disputes arise because a boundary was allocated or delimited but never properly demarcated, or because the treaty description (for example, the source of a river or a watershed) is unclear on the ground.

Theoretical approaches

The Colonial Making of South Asian Borders

The British drew the borders of South Asia in two phases: the external frontiers of the Raj in the 19th and early 20th centuries, and the internal partition of 1947.

British frontier strategy

The Durand Line (1893)

The McMahon Line (1914)

The western sector lines

Treaties with the Himalayan kingdoms

Partition and the Radcliffe Line (1947)

The colonial legacy: a summary

LineYearBetweenStatus today
Sugauli boundary1816Nepal–British IndiaKalapani dispute with India
Durand Line1893Afghanistan–British IndiaRejected by Afghanistan
McMahon Line1914Tibet–British IndiaRejected by China
Johnson / Macartney–MacDonald1865 / 1899Kashmir–Xinjiang/TibetAksai Chin dispute
Radcliffe Line1947India–Pakistan (Punjab, Bengal)Accepted, but legacy of Partition

The colonial origin of these lines explains why many South Asian disputes are about the interpretation of old treaties and maps, and why post-colonial states see any compromise as a threat to national identity.

India–Pakistan Boundary Disputes

The India–Pakistan border is about 3,300 km long and has several distinct segments: the International Border (IB) from Gujarat to Jammu, the Line of Control (LoC) in Jammu and Kashmir, and the Actual Ground Position Line (AGPL) at Siachen.

Kashmir and the Line of Control

Origins

Competing positions

IndiaPakistan
Accession of 1947 was legal and final; the whole of J&K, including Pakistan-administered areas and Gilgit-Baltistan, is Indian territoryAccession was invalid; Kashmir’s future should be decided by plebiscite under UN resolutions
The issue is bilateral under the Simla Agreement; no third-party roleThe issue is international; seeks mediation
Cross-border terrorism is the core problemThe “Kashmir dispute” is the core issue

Later developments

Siachen Glacier

Sir Creek

The International Border

India–China Boundary Dispute

The India–China boundary is about 3,488 km long according to India (China gives a shorter figure of around 2,000 km, because it does not count the boundary of Pakistan-administered areas). It is not demarcated; the two armies are separated by the Line of Actual Control (LAC), whose exact alignment is itself disputed in many places.

The three sectors

SectorAreaNature of dispute
WesternLadakh (Aksai Chin)China controls about 38,000 sq km of Aksai Chin, claimed by India; China built the Xinjiang–Tibet highway through it in the 1950s
MiddleHimachal Pradesh, UttarakhandRelatively minor differences; maps were exchanged in 2002
EasternArunachal Pradesh (and Sikkim)China claims about 90,000 sq km, rejecting the McMahon Line; Sikkim boundary settled by the 1890 Anglo-Chinese Convention

History of the dispute

Agreements and mechanisms

YearAgreement or mechanism
1988Rajiv Gandhi’s visit to Beijing; Joint Working Group set up
1993Agreement on Maintenance of Peace and Tranquillity along the LAC (first use of “LAC” in a treaty)
1996Agreement on Military Confidence-Building Measures (no firearms use near the LAC)
2003Special Representatives (SR) mechanism set up
2005Agreement on Political Parameters and Guiding Principles: a “package” settlement, taking account of settled populations
2012Working Mechanism for Consultation and Coordination (WMCC)
2013Border Defence Cooperation Agreement

Recent crises

The 2025–26 thaw and delimitation talks

Why the India–China dispute is hard to resolve

Other Boundary Disputes and Settlements in South Asia

India–Nepal: Kalapani, Lipulekh and Limpiyadhura

India–Bangladesh: a success story

Land boundary

Maritime boundary

India–Sri Lanka: Katchatheevu

Pakistan–Afghanistan: the Durand Line conflict

Bhutan–China

Other boundaries

Summary of major disputes

DisputePartiesBasisStatus
Kashmir / LoCIndia–PakistanAccession 1947 vs plebiscite claimUnresolved
SiachenIndia–PakistanUndefined line beyond NJ 9842Unresolved; ceasefire
Sir CreekIndia–Pakistan1914 resolution; ThalwegUnresolved
Aksai Chin / ArunachalIndia–ChinaJohnson Line, McMahon LineDelimitation talks
Kalapani–LipulekhIndia–NepalSource of Kali river (Sugauli 1816)Unresolved
Enclaves / maritimeIndia–BangladeshPartition legacySettled (2014–15)
KatchatheevuIndia–Sri Lanka1974–76 agreementsSettled; politically contested
Durand LinePakistan–Afghanistan1893 agreementNot recognised by Kabul; armed clashes
Doklam etc.Bhutan–ChinaHistorical claimsTalks; 2021 roadmap

Analysis: Why Borders Matter So Much in South Asia

Causes of border disputes

  1. Colonial legacy: lines drawn for imperial strategy (Great Game, buffer states) or in haste (Radcliffe) ignored geography, ethnicity and local economies.
  2. Ambiguous treaties and maps: unclear river sources, watersheds and undefined points (NJ 9842, the source of the Kali) allow competing interpretations.
  3. Nationalism and “sacred” territory: borders became symbols of identity and sovereignty after independence, so compromise is seen as betrayal. Parliamentary resolutions (India’s 1994 resolution on PoK) and constitutional maps (Nepal 2020) further limit flexibility.
  4. Strategic and resource value: high passes, glaciers, rivers, water, maritime zones and access corridors (Siliguri, Wakhan, Shaksgam).
  5. Divided peoples: Punjabis, Bengalis, Kashmiris, Pashtuns, Baloch, Nagas and Tamils live across borders, linking border issues to internal conflict.
  6. Power asymmetry: India’s size makes smaller neighbours fear domination; China’s power makes India cautious.
  7. Domestic politics: governments use border issues for nationalist mobilisation.

Consequences

Paths to settlement

Conclusion

South Asia’s borders are largely the product of British imperial strategy and the hurried partition of 1947. The Durand, McMahon and Radcliffe lines, along with older treaties like Sugauli, still shape interstate relations today. Disputes in Kashmir, Siachen, Sir Creek, Aksai Chin and Arunachal, Kalapani and the Durand Line continue to cause tension and, at times, war.

Yet the record is not entirely negative. India and Bangladesh resolved their land and maritime boundaries peacefully, and India and China have, since 2024, moved from confrontation to structured talks on delimitation. The lesson for students is that borders are not only lines of separation but also political choices: they can become sources of conflict or, with political will, zones of cooperation. A good answer should combine the realist emphasis on territory and security with the constructivist and borderland perspectives on identity and the lives of border peoples.

Quick Revision

ItemKey fact
Sugauli Treaty1816; Kali river as Nepal’s western boundary
Durand Line12 Nov 1893; Mortimer Durand–Amir Abdur Rahman; ~2,600 km
Johnson Line1865; placed Aksai Chin in Kashmir
Macartney–MacDonald Line1899; proposed to China
McMahon LineSimla Conference 1913–14; Henry McMahon–Lonchen Shatra
Radcliffe LineAward published 17 Aug 1947
Instrument of Accession (J&K)26 Oct 1947
Karachi AgreementJuly 1949; Ceasefire Line
Simla Agreement2 July 1972; CFL became LoC (~740 km)
China–Pakistan Boundary Agreement1963; Shaksgam Valley
Operation MeghdootApril 1984; Siachen
Rann of Kutch tribunalAward 1968
India–China agreements1993 (peace on LAC), 1996 (CBMs), 2005 (political parameters)
Galwan clash15 June 2020
Depsang–Demchok patrolling agreementOctober 2024
25th SR talks25 Aug 2026, Beijing; “early and substantial harvest”
India–Bangladesh LBA1974; implemented 2015 (100th Amendment)
India–Bangladesh maritime award2014 (PCA)
Katchatheevu agreements1974 and 1976
Nepal’s new mapConstitutional amendment, June 2020

One-line memory aids

Exam Practice

Long-answer questions

  1. “The borders of South Asia are a colonial legacy.” Discuss with reference to the Durand, McMahon and Radcliffe Lines.
  2. Distinguish between frontier, boundary and border. Explain the stages of boundary making with South Asian examples.
  3. Examine the India–China boundary dispute. Assess the prospects of an “early harvest” in boundary delimitation.
  4. Discuss the Kashmir, Siachen and Sir Creek disputes between India and Pakistan.
  5. Examine the India–Nepal boundary dispute over Kalapani and Lipulekh. What role does China play?
  6. “The India–Bangladesh Land Boundary Agreement is a model for resolving border disputes in South Asia.” Discuss.
  7. Why does the Durand Line remain a source of conflict between Pakistan and Afghanistan?

Short-answer questions

  1. Durand Line
  2. McMahon Line
  3. Radcliffe Award
  4. Line of Actual Control
  5. NJ 9842
  6. Sir Creek and the Thalweg principle
  7. Kalapani dispute
  8. India–Bangladesh enclaves
  9. Katchatheevu
  10. Doklam standoff

MCQs (UGC-NET / OPSC style)

  1. The Durand Line was drawn in:
    • (a) 1816 (b) 1865 (c) 1893 (d) 1914
    • Answer: (c)
  2. The McMahon Line was agreed at the:
    • (a) Lahore Conference (b) Simla Conference (c) Calcutta Conference (d) Lhasa Conference
    • Answer: (b)
  3. The Line of Control in Jammu and Kashmir was established by the:
    • (a) Karachi Agreement (b) Tashkent Declaration (c) Simla Agreement (d) Lahore Declaration
    • Answer: (c)
  4. The Kalapani dispute between India and Nepal is based on differing interpretations of the:
    • (a) Treaty of Sinchula (b) Treaty of Sugauli (c) Treaty of Titalia (d) 1950 Treaty of Peace and Friendship
    • Answer: (b)
  5. India’s Parliament passed the Land Boundary Agreement with Bangladesh through the:
    • (a) 99th Amendment (b) 100th Amendment (c) 101st Amendment (d) 103rd Amendment
    • Answer: (b)
  6. The principle that a river boundary follows the middle of the navigable channel is called the:
    • (a) Watershed principle (b) Thalweg principle (c) Uti possidetis (d) Median line
    • Answer: (b)
  7. Match the following:
    • A. Johnson Line – 1. 1947
    • B. Radcliffe Line – 2. 1865
    • C. Simla Agreement – 3. 1963
    • D. China–Pakistan Boundary Agreement – 4. 1972
    • Answer: A-2, B-1, C-4, D-3
  8. Assertion (A): Afghanistan does not recognise the Durand Line as an international border. Reason (R): The line divided Pashtun tribes and was drawn by the British colonial government.
    • Answer: Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
  9. The 73-day Doklam standoff of 2017 took place on territory disputed between:
    • (a) India and China (b) Bhutan and China (c) Nepal and China (d) India and Bhutan
    • Answer: (b)
  10. The author of The Nature of Frontiers and Boundaries (1959) is:
    • (a) Lord Curzon (b) Stephen Jones (c) Ladis Kristof (d) Willem van Schendel
    • Answer: (c)

Suggested readings

Sources for recent developments

Category: International Relations of South Asia
Tag: Borders and Boundaries in South Asia
Source: https://poliprephub.in/international-relations-of-south-asia/borders-and-boundaries-in-south-asia-colonial-legacies-and-disputes/
© PoliPrepHub · Generated on November 19, 2026